Antifreeze

dritter

Member
exMember
Joined
Oct 18, 2005
RO Number
19332
Messages
216
I was going to use the sierra antifreeze because it has the proylene glycol formula. Is there any difference between this and the marine antifreeze?
 
propelyne glycol is the same ingredient in both. It's the ethelyne glycol (automotive AF) that is poisonous
 
What are you going to use if for? Winterizing or running in the motor?

How old is your motor?
 
quote:

Originally posted by Msibley

It's the ethelyne glycol (automotive AF) that is poisonous






Can you elaborate? My Crusader manuel specifically calls for a 50/50 mix with ethlyne glycol.
 
Propylene glycol is typically referred to as "marine/rv" antifreeze, designed for winter layups. It is suitable for potable water systems...another way to look at it, essentially, propylene glycol is what you drink in preparation for a colonoscopy (electrolytes are added)

Ethelyne glycol is automotive rated antifreeze...either as 100% or 50/50, you would this as a "coolant" for engine systems. It can also be used to winterize engines providing you dispose of it correctly. It is toxic.

I've used the auto a/f for winterizing my boat engine for the severe Minnesota winters...better peace-of-mind.
 
Ahh, got you now. I would never dream of putting Ethelyne in the water system. Now, if there was 100% certainty that I would be the first to use the fresh water system next season, Mrs. Know may try to slip some ethlyne in the water system.
 
No....you don't have me. I said specifically, that ethelyne is to be used in "engine coolant" applications...NOT potable water systems. ;)
 
I am going to use it for the engines. I just did not know if it might leave a film on the water like the ethelyn glocol does.
 
Use if for the engines when they are running of for winter storage?

Closed cooling system or raw water cooled?

Year?
 
quote:

Originally posted by Msibley

No....you don't have me. I said specifically, that ethelyne is to be used in "engine coolant" applications...NOT potable water systems. ;)






Mike, I thing ITK was saying "got you now" as in "I understand what you are saying", not "got you now" as in "gotcha".

Tim
 
I think you're right! Sorry ITK! I read everything as literal these days! I beg humble foregiveness.
 
No problem Mike. And, for the record, I did mean "I understand what you are saying".
 
dritter, the place to check is the manual on your engines as to what antifreeze to use. there are engines out there that are sleeved and require a very specific type of anitfreeze that is PH balanced to prevent the liners from siezing in the block. its worth reading the owners manual specifications to see what the engine mfg calls for before you change the fluid.
 
Sierra PG has corrosion inhibitors in it, the marine stuff suitable for potable water systems does not. I use the sierra for the raw water side of my engine. Works fine, and is low tox for the water ways. Don't use it in the potable water system however. Use pure PG.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Robyns Nest

Use if for the engines when they are running of for winter storage?

Closed cooling system or raw water cooled?

Year?






Dritter?
 
So you are using it for winterization and not a FWC system. I use Sierra Low tox to get the benefit of corrosion inhibitors. I won't put the pink stuff in my blocks, I use that for everything else. I think there has been some confusion here as to what you wanted to do.
 
Back
Top