Bad fuel Question

If these are carbureted engines, I think you need to get the stbd carb cleaned or rebuilt, soon. Seems to me your symptoms are consistent with crud in the carb bowl. You might not have enough gunk in there to block the idle passages but it could be laying down in the power valve or main jet. Or it works its way in those after you run for a while and bounce around. So now you can't get enough gas through the carb to sustain high RPMs under load, but, you have enough to idle or rev it up in neutral. What's worse, if you continue to try and run this way, you could cause excessively lean operation and detonation, which is very bad for the engine's long term health prospects.

If your filter gets loaded up with junk from the tank, when the filter surface is blocked off, it will often separate around the edges from the end plate or gaskets and then pass unfiltered gas. I have seen this with my Fram canister filter elements. All that suction from your fuel pump is going to pull something through there, one way or another. And then you get that gunk in your carb, and you can't let it stay in there. It's not going to magically dissolve and go away.
 
Did it look like this?

Image036.jpg


Image037.jpg


Been there, Done that!
 
Wow, thanks Ron (and others) I am going to probably for sure have the carbs rebuilt. I will have a mechanic so this. What do yo uthink an average prive would be to do one engine (crusader 454) at $95 an hour?
 
Zach,

Cost of a carb rebuild with that labor rate will probably be about $300-$400.

Now before you go siphoning off the gas I suggest you read this recent thread - you need to think about this a bit before you jump in. You may only have ~25 gal's of fuel. But, what are you going to do with it? If it's phase separated it's basically useless as gas. Next question is do you know how to get to the bottom of your tank? Please read the thread through.

http://www.boatered.com/forum/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=113427

Also look at the pics posted by CurrentSea above. I suspect what you will get out will look very similar. The brown color comes from the dissolved gums and varnish. See the two layers in the close-up and several of the jugs on the ground? The lower layer is water and ethanol extracted from the gasoline. The remaining stuff on top is gasoline that has a reduced octane due to the ethanol loss - about 3 points.

Give this some serious thought before tackling this on your own.
 
quote:

Originally posted by douglee25

What the heck is that?

Doug






That was my issue with ethanol back in 2004.
Lost my genny carb, fuel pump on my horizon 350 MPI, had to clean all fuel injectors and drain bottom of tank.
That is what we pulled out until it got clean.
Then I changed filter until it ran clean again!
 
quote:

Originally posted by CurrentSea

Did it look like this?

Image036.jpg


Image037.jpg


Been there, Done that!






Dave, are you back to drug testing or getting ready for the new Howard Hughes documentary.
 
Why would you have the carbs rebuilt until you have made sure you have clean fuel? I think clean fuel will solve your problem. Start pumping and welcome to boating.
 
I just thought that the carbs were so gunked (or may be so gunked) that they need to be cleaned. At this point,It has taken me 2 trys to get my boat home from chicago (a 100 mile journey) and 2 mechanics. I just want my boat home. Its my first boat and I STILL have not been able to enjoy it. I dont want to get stuck on the water again. Lake Michigan is a big lake. I would rather make sure everything is safe and in working order on the boat. With that said, if I dont have to spemd the money, I dont want to. I just really want this thing to be fixed.
 
I used the word 'soon' in reference to your carb. Not 'immediate'. I agree with Ironworks and others that your fuel is the most immediate concern, otherwise you'll just recreate the problem. I'm just saying that may not be all there is to it. I am skeptical that a mere filter blockage is going to be the only thing behind these symptoms, because a filter element is just so much fan-folded cardboard, not a brick wall. I can say for certain that when I had issues caused by Ethanol 'cleaning' my tanks, changing filters was not enough. What looked like a tablespoon full of beach sand had gotten past and was in my carb bowl, and my problems ended only after I cleaned it out.

Question. You said it acted up, you docked, you changed the filter "and now it won't even start". So the not starting is only after you changed the filter? Is that filter upstream of the fuel pump, ie closer to the gas tank? How long did you try to crank it? It can take a while to refill that filter with gas and get the air out of the lines, so it's been suggested here by many to refill the filter with clean gas before reinstalling. A suggestion which I now follow with my filter changes.
 
quote:

Originally posted by dsmboosted

I just thought that the carbs were so gunked (or may be so gunked) that they need to be cleaned. At this point,It has taken me 2 trys to get my boat home from chicago (a 100 mile journey) and 2 mechanics. I just want my boat home. Its my first boat and I STILL have not been able to enjoy it. I dont want to get stuck on the water again. Lake Michigan is a big lake. I would rather make sure everything is safe and in working order on the boat. With that said, if I dont have to spemd the money, I dont want to. I just really want this thing to be fixed.






Yep, that's what I was thinking, I'd want my boat home. It sounds as if you may be half way there. For the remainder 50 miles, I'd get in the boat and put-put along for about six-ten hours. Do you have sea tow or boat us towing?

In regards to not starting: Can you see gas in the carbs when you pump the throttle? Did you try ether? Did you ever think you'd learn so much about a fuel system?

There's always the dangerous trick of putting an external fuel tank on the deck and running it to the fuel pump....but it could be dangerous if not done 100% right.
 
You should have Rochester carbs (I think) on those engines. You should be able to rebuild them yourself. They aren't too difficult. My recommendation is to change the filters again and try and start the engines. If only one engine runs, take it home the last few miles on one engine. Once you get it home, clean the tanks, rebuild the carbs, and go from there.

Doug
 
I'd agree with that - I've had my Holleys apart enough times I can probably do it blindfolded. You really would not need a rebuild. You would need to empty the fuel bowls, put some carb cleaner in there and blow air through all the passages. Replacing jets, needle valves etc, not really a reason to think you need all that. You would need a rebuild kit just so you get a new air horn gasket in case the old one breaks when you take it apart. But, you don't sound like you have tackled anything like that yet. And you definitely don't want to be dropping little tools or parts down the intake manifold or losing carb parts, or twisting the metal fuel line that supplies the carb by being careless when you back the nut off. It's the fuel system, so if you are not confident in your ability you may not want to mess with it beyond filter changes.
 
There is no way I would run either engine for even one minute on the gas you have in the boat now. You only stand to make matters worse and possibly do some serious engine damage along the way.

You may have cruded carburetors, and rebuilding them won't hurt. But I wouldn't rush into it. Rebuilding a carb is corrective, and right now you don't know there is a problem with either carb. Yous suscpicion is sound, but you can wait on that if you wish.

From everything you have described and given where the boat came from (Chicago area I believe ), you have probably experienced the very well known e-gas phase separation problem. The starting point is to find out what is in your tank. If it's phase separated you need to get rid of all of it and dispose of it properly. Then you need to clean the tank, replace all filters, fill it with fresh gas and see what you have. If the carbs are gunked up, then pull and overhaul. The most troublesome part on a carb for this kind of problem are the idle circuit passageways - very tiny and difficult to get clean - this is a job for someone who knows what they are doing. And don't be surprised afterwards if you have periods where an engine runs rough or idles poorly. Once the dissolution process starts it can take a while before all the gums and varnish are cleaned from the system. During that time don't hesitate to change the filters and if that doesnt resolve it be prepared to pull a carb or both again.
 
I agree get the old gunk (fuel) out of the tank as soon as possible. I wouldn't move the boat under it's own power until you have a clean tank and fuel delivery system. It seems that one engine has most of the problems the only reason I can think it's that way is the pickup must be the deeper of the 2 or the boat has a slight list or both. Another thing you want to be real careful that any flexible fuel lines aren't being dissolved by the "gunk". Check to make sure they are the type rated for E-10 marine use their rating/standard should be printed on the hoses. Once you are at that point then you can start cleaning or rebuilding the carbs. Make sure you change filters frequently I would change them at the 1st sign of a drop in power or RPM's don't wait for the engine to stall. Good luck this can be fixed it just requires that the proper steps be followed or as other's have said or you could have big engine problems in the near future.
 
Ok. Here is how all of this played out. I finnaly got the boat started and home. The reason the right engine didnt start, is because the fuel pump went on it. It was just a pure coincidence of timming, and had nothing to do with the engine cutting out. The new mechanic changed all of the fuel filters (again) and put in a new fuel pump (at a cost of $989). So I paid the bill and put 50 gallons of gas in to get me home. we were running at about 25 mph for a half hour. Then the right engine cut out agian...so the fuel pump wasnt the problem. I putted at about 5 mph for about 10 minutes. The nI gave her throttle again and it ran at about 25 mph for the rest of the way home. So here is what I'm doing, but doing it myself, these mechanics are NOT helping at all.

I am emptying the old gas out (I have a thread open on how to do this...Ive been having problems getting teh gas pumped out). Then I'mEither tossing the gas or filtering it out. Then Im going to change all of the fuel filter and rebuilt the carb. That should fix her!!
 
DSM,

Glad you got the boat home

Did you check the old gas for water, etc? Moving gas around is bear and dangerous.

The symptoms you have on stbd could indicate the anti-siphon valve is going bad. Basically, the va;vedoes not allow enough flow as it wears out, and after running hot for a while, you develop vapor lock. If you idle , you can clear the vapor lock and go again. I chased this for three weeks last summer. I would change the anti-siphon valves (shoudl be on each pickup from the fuel tank) as they are cheap and easy to do (generally) they cost about $12. Even if this is not the cause, they probably will be sooner or later.
 
quote:

Originally posted by dsmboosted

Ok. Here is how all of this played out. I finnaly got the boat started and home. The reason the right engine didnt start, is because the fuel pump went on it. It was just a pure coincidence of timming, and had nothing to do with the engine cutting out. The new mechanic changed all of the fuel filters (again) and put in a new fuel pump (at a cost of $989). So I paid the bill and put 50 gallons of gas in to get me home. we were running at about 25 mph for a half hour. Then the right engine cut out agian...so the fuel pump wasnt the problem. I putted at about 5 mph for about 10 minutes. The nI gave her throttle again and it ran at about 25 mph for the rest of the way home. So here is what I'm doing, but doing it myself, these mechanics are NOT helping at all.

I am emptying the old gas out (I have a thread open on how to do this...Ive been having problems getting teh gas pumped out). Then I'mEither tossing the gas or filtering it out. Then Im going to change all of the fuel filter and rebuilt the carb. That should fix her!!






Holy COW!!! $998? Why so expensive for a $50 fuel pump and filters? Glad you got it home though. Keep us posted.

Doug
 
As promised...here is the outcome of my saga...it has a happy (but expensive $$) ending.

The reason the starboard engine didnt start was the fuel pump went on the engine. It was unrelated to the other engine problems, it just happened to happen when I was having all the other probs. For the rest of the issues:

I actually got very lucky. A few veteran boaters that run charters near my slip ended up helping me completly tune up my engines and help with the gas problem. We went through and changed the plugs, wires, distributor, oil sending unit, belts and hoses, retimming the engines, changing all the fuel filters and a few other odds and ends on the boat. Instead of trying to get the gas out we burned the fuel down a bit and added a few cans of sea foam before filling the tank up. The boat runs like a champ now! I appreciate all of the help on this forum. It feels so good to finnaly be able to take the boat out. Now I just have to work on the manuvering part...but thats fun. The canvas is being made as we speak and the upolstry will be finished in a few weeks. I am seeing the light at the end of the tunnel!
 
Watch Out For That TRAIN!!!!!

just kidding......I'm happy for you!
 
Back
Top