Bunk versus Roller Trailers

I actually was going to ask that but didn't......I know you don't want to dunk your truck bearings in water but I've even wondered about that.....here were I live you have so much salt on roads you can take it off 1/4 inch thick with a putty knife after a tough storm.....there is standing water everywhere......you can't tell me that in the upper bay even dunking your truck bearings is worse than driving after a winter storm.
 
quote:

Originally posted by KiDa

..as it eventually destroys the ramp.






I was curious about that, as the ramp I use has all kinds of signs warning everyone not to 'power' onto their trailers. How does this destroy the ramp?
 
The soil at the end of the ramp gets blown back and builds up into a nice berm that you can run aground on later.
 
quote:

I was curious about that, as the ramp I use has all kinds of signs warning everyone not to 'power' onto their trailers. How does this destroy the ramp?





It undermines the cement slab by sucking the sand, muck, or whatever bottom out from under it destabilizing the structure. Power loading can also cause a drop off behind the slab. This can cause a depression that your trailer wheels get stuck in and hang up on the slab. Don't be lazy and crank that winch handle!

Roller vs.Bunk? Have owned both types and found roller to be the most versatile based on different ramp characteristics. In general, ramps without much water were problematic with bunk trailers where rollers were easier to launch.
 
I have a Venture and would not recommend one unless you are using it like I do to launch and retrieve once a year. My dealer calls them "portable cradles".

The hardware on them is barely adequate. The 4th dunk on my 12k trailer resulted in one centering bunk with bent brackets and the 1/4" lags (already rusted) pulling out of the carpeted pine bunk. I am now removing them and purchasing parts from another manufacturer to repair the trailer. I really did not anticipate it being that bad but I was wrong.

Take a look at Pirate Marine in Ohio, he ships all over the country and has a really nice aluminum. He sells Venture but will tell you about the difference in quality.
 
I researched this a bit as well. I'm sure you have a great dealer......but I think there is a huge difference in price here because of location. If you are saying 12k and mean $12k I'm wondering how big of a trailer??? It can't be 12,000lbs, they don't make one. In anycase PM for prices but aluminum with alloy wheels is under $3k for 6,000lbs.

I will say a very courteous secretary connected me to tech support who was very knowledgeable. Seems that there definitely are adjustments required....they even say they are not a custom trailer and don't price like one on their website......so axles go fore and aft, bunks go starboard and port, the winch shaft goes up and down, and brakes need adjustment.

After you load up with the boat and get everything right you need to retighten hardware after its stressed......didn't seem to hide at all.

So I kind of thought its like a boat (or plane)....always keeping on top of stuff......jump in and just run (kick the tires and light the fires).... bad sh#$t happens.

I will report back after the winter.

I think labor is expensive (and unfortunately in the marine industry mostly poor quality) so this could be a major problem.

I have no expectations for adjusting other than myself so I probably will have a reasonable experience.
 
At one point in my boating past it was suggested that the roller trailers would eventually cause the bottom to dimple where each roller supported the boat. It was suggested that while on the trailer for extended periods, the straps should be loosened relieving some of the stress on the hull. Others have said that is not the case. I know many of the bunks are not straight and the points where they are attached are the only areas that support the boat, therefore causing the same problem. I do feel the bunks allow the boat to set more securely on the trailer,(more friction) where if your straps fail the boat will roll off the trailer easier on rollers. However in shallow water ramps the roller trailer is easier to load. The bunk trailer is easier to maintain.(fewer parts)A properly adjusted bunk or roller trailer should allow you to easily center the boat while loading as long as the trailer is in the water at the proper depth!
Sometimes power loading is unavoidable! I challenge anyone to load a 12,500lb boat on a bunk trailer with a strong side wind to do otherwise!
As far as getting the bearings wet, I ordered mine with a built in flushing system for the brakes but have yet to determine how to load without getting the hub in the water. The bearings should not get wet as long as the grease seal is doing its job!
 
I'm sorry, that was a bit confusing. Admiral was calling me for dinner so I was a bit hasty. My trailer is the largest one they build, around 12k GVW triple axle model VBT-10, or something like that. The price I paid was 4k and Pirate was a couple hundred less but then I had to pick it up or pay freight.

I went over the trailer, nothing was loose, the hardware is just plain too light duty and the stuff bent due to the undersized lag bolts pulling out of the bunks. After I straightened the metal, repositioned the bunks due to the need to drill new pilot holes and installed lags twice the size, it worked ok.

All that will be changed this winter with better hardware.

I will admit, the company is courteous on the phone. Best of luck with yours!
 
I'll report back....we'll see that is what the board is for......

Could be very poor for a big boat.....great for a small or poor period we'll see.

I will say in my experience when you are building for a price that works well except for the high end stuff.....then it falls on its face, because you are using standard parts for high end needs.

I can't find a 12,000 pound trailer on their website.....I'm sorry the max is 10,600....

12,000 is a huge trailer.....not defending them at all....call me in a year....but if you have a 12,000lb boat....I don't think they are for you.....they look like a low end place....kind of like Dell.....

You should have seen the trailer rig that was near my house with at least a 30ft twin Sundancer with twins on it for sale.....it was awesome, but it wasn't in the same league.....SingleA versus the Big Show.
 
Psugar,

I looked at the website. The carrying capacity of my triple axle is 10,600# and my GVW is 12,200 if I remember correctly but it might be a touch more.. The factory specs for my boat is 7800# dry weight so it certainly is not overloaded.
 
Donald, I'm right there with you....you are not overloaded.....just checking, because some trailer sales guys are like software sales guys....

"what is the difference between a software salesguy and a used car salesman??? The used car salesman knows when he is lying..."

I sell software.

I'll report back. I'm a newbie at trailering but am going less than one quarter as far as I walk my dog each night........I walk her from my house well past the ramp and back again so I definitely am buying for a price.
 
I understand perfectly, that is what I did. Did not realize what a bargain I really got :)
 
Back
Top