Disaster in the making

Ehoyles

Member
exMember
Joined
Dec 6, 2005
RO Number
19707
Messages
217
The road to hell is paved in goal. Here is a prime example: What started out as a suit to prevent bad things fromhappening to our waters has now morphed into the following need for us boaters to stop traveling down the road.

For 34 years the federal Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has exempted discharges from recreational boats from the Clean Water Act permit system. Regretfully, a recent court ruling cancelled this permit exemption. EPA is required by the court decision to develop and implement by September 30, 2008 a national permit system for ALL vessels in the United States for a variety of normal operational discharges.

We have been working behind the scenes with other boating organizations to get the exemption reinstated for recreational boats. Fortunately, the Recreational Boating Act of 2007 (H.R. 2550) has been introduced by Representatives Gene Taylor (D-Miss) and Candice Miller (R-Mich) which would protect recreational boats from being swept into this unnecessary and expensive permitting system.

It is critically important that H.R. 2550 be passed and your support is essential. Please contact your Congressman and Senators TODAY and ask that they co-sponsor or support H.R. 2550.

If the permit system becomes a reality, you will be required to pay for a state permit for each of your boats. EPA will be monitoring your deck runoff, grey water, bilge water, engine cooling water, and the use of copper bottom paints.

The original lawsuit that led to this court decision sought to address ballast water discharges from large ocean-going ships, which can introduce damaging aquatic invasive species into U.S. waters. Keeping our waterways clean and preventing the spread of invasive species is of utmost importance to the future of boating. But taking a complex permitting system designed for industrial dischargers and applying it to recreational boats will not yield significant environmental benefits and it will come at a very high cost. Requiring recreational boaters to purchase a permit would not prevent the spread of invasive species.

BoatUS has been a leader in educating boaters about Clean Boating practices for more than a decade. Our nonprofit Foundation has funded local education projects on invasive species prevention, helped develop voluntary Clean Marina programs, and authored much of the country's Clean Boating outreach. These positive education efforts are making a difference.

Please ask your elected federal representatives to support H.R. 2550., and your email needs to have a subject line with Docket ID No. OW-2007-0483.
 
Glad I looked for a thread on this before I posted my own. This is an example of judges gone wild. Most of us know about misplaced marine and freshwater life hitching rides. Most of us are willing to obey antifouling paint laws. Most of us (but all should) obey waste and ballast water discharge rules and the like. If I read this ruling correctly, then I will have to permit every thing from my inflatables to my kayaks to my sailboat. Good grief. These permits will do nothing except cost money as they seem to be based on the honor system and don't include education. As usual, instead of enforcing the laws and providing guidance, they come up with new ones that effectively say "enforce the law" and then charge for it. alan
 
Just remember ... all taxes were temporary measures! The government see's a way to make money, if you believe that it is anything more than that then more power to you. The cynic in me has been watching less money come home because of higher taxes and more government waste. All the while Exxon-Mobil has become a TRILLION dollar company! I will now step off my soapbox.
 
I've already emailed my two senators and congressman. I hope every boat owner and anyone who loves boating will do the same!
 
Most of our elected officials can read and write. All of them have advisors. How can crap like this exist?
Who is a poroponant of this bill?
Why dont Lawyers petition the Bar to Disbar Judges who punish the populace with thier assanine petty temper tantrums at having to seperate the useful from the usless in legislation?

It seems like everytime we have a decision to make it is because somebody is trying to do something stupid or useless.
More sickness is making me more sicker!
 
Thank you, my congressman and state senators have been written, with copies to Boat US and EPA
 
Send a letter/e-mail here... http://www.rallycongress.com/boattestcom/803/

Recreational Boating Act 2007
In September, 2006, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals struck down a 34-year-old exemption for recreational boats from an EPA regulation intended to stop ballast water discharge from ocean-going freighters and tankers in U.S. waters.

If a higher court or the U.S. Congress does not act, 18 million boats will be required to have special EPA permits that couls cost $800 or more.
 
I got this response to my email today:

Dear Morgan,

Thank you for contacting me regarding recreational boating. I appreciate your comments and having the benefit of your views.

As you may know, the Clean Water Act (P.L. 80-845) helps improve the quality of the water in our lakes, rivers and other bodies of water by restricting pollution caused by industries and water-going vessels. Part of the Act requires permits for ships known for heavy polluting, such as cruise ships, container ships, and supertankers. While the legislation affected all vessels, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has long provided an exemption to certain water-quality standards for small recreational boats due to their limited impact on the environment and the burden that recreational boaters would bear in meeting stringent environmental standards meant for larger vessels.

However, in a case related to the regulation of ballast water from cargo vessels, the U.S. Court of Appeals recently determined that the EPA was acting beyond its scope with exemptions to the Clean Water Act, such as the one provided for small recreational boats, and required the creation of a new permit system by September 2008. The EPA is currently appealing this ruling.

Many recreational boaters like you are concerned that if the EPA loses their appeal they will be forced to obtain expensive and burdensome permits that will greatly impact their ability to own and use personal recreational watercraft. To this end, Representative Gene Taylor (D-MS) has introduced the Recreational Boating Act of 2007 (H.R. 2550) to reverse the U.S. Court of Appeals decision and codify the exemptions for small recreational watercraft into federal law. H.R. 2550 has been referred to the House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee, where it awaits consideration.

As the representative for eastern Connecticut, I know how important recreational boating is to the communities along Long Island Sound and the many bodies of water across the second Congressional District. Please be assured that I will continue to monitor this issue closely and will keep your views in mind should it come before me for a vote.

Should you have any additional comments or suggestions, please do not hesitate to contact me in the future. For more information on my views on other issues or to see what I have been working on in Congress, please feel free to visit my official website at www.house.gov/courtney and sign up for my e-newsletter.

Sincerely,

JOSEPH COURTNEY

Member of Congress
 
Inspector I used your link to send to my State officials. That was a well put together site I might add.

I bet those guys are bombarded with tons of emails every day.
They probably have someone counting the 'pro' and 'con' on each subject and only read a certain few of them.

Here's hoping for some useful action by the usless in action!
 
I had thoughtfully written replies from both of my state Senators (even though the bill is not in the Senate) But only "thanks for your interest from my Representative. Both replies were semi sympathetic--but also seemed to indicate that limiting discharge from recreational vessels would help keep our waters cleaner...remember this is in Florida, where a lot of the economy is dependant on our boating industry! There is only a House bill in committee currently, and apparently no Senate bill which is comperable....More control and regulations--where to move to now!
 
The suit sounds like a left handed attempt by the radical tree huggers to put recreational boating out of business!
 
quote:

Originally posted by thataway4

I had thoughtfully written replies from both of my state Senators (even though the bill is not in the Senate) But only "thanks for your interest from my Representative. Both replies were semi sympathetic--but also seemed to indicate that limiting discharge from recreational vessels would help keep our waters cleaner...remember this is in Florida, where a lot of the economy is dependant on our boating industry! There is only a House bill in committee currently, and apparently no Senate bill which is comperable....More control and regulations--where to move to now!






This was pretty much the reply that I received as well. With the exception that my Senator was concerned about the "thermal contribution" of exhaust water to the florida waterways. Hmmm... it's the recreational boaters that are causing global warming, yeah, that's it. It all starts with me running in the gulf once a week. I should have known.
 
Just sent my 2 cents to my representative and senators.
 
I had to register on their sites to send it but it's done.
 
It seems to be just a revenue generating scheme as per usual. The folks that dream this legislation up know there is no practical way to test every boat for discharge, be it deck runoff or bilge effluent. So now they want to assign a dollar value to a new permit and blanket the recreational boaters under the premise of " we just know your boat introduces pollutants into the water, some more than others, but since our coffers are low we're going to charge you this fee so we can continue to study the problem." I don't know, I may be way off on this. But so many things that were once considered farfetched have come to pass and lawmakers are resorting to very creative means to disguising the true intent of such legislation. Bottom line: who gets the money and where's the breakdown on how it's spent?
 
Back
Top