Dockside Fuel Delivery...

Last summer I was getting my boat filled dockside on a regular basis. I called to get gasoline and my supplier informed me they could not deliver anymore because of a city code and that they were fined. So I started checking and found out that I lived in the only city in south Florida with ordinance prohibiting dockside fueling. The fight began. Since I live in a waterfront community I got a couple of neighbors together and started to proceed to change the ordinance. The Fire Chief tried to play the safety issue which was the best thing for us. I had already checked with the Fire Marshall for the city I work for and he had confirmed there was no laws prohibiting dockside fueling. I wrote the fuel companies requesting their safety records and they were more than happy to reply. I passed out fliers to all the water front homes in my neighborhood. To make the story short about 200 boaters showed up at the city commission meeting and requested the code be changed. Here is what happened.
http://www.waterfront-news.us/07/03/
http://www.boatered.com/forum/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=95957
 
That's a good article....the sulphur doesn't lubricate but the process taking it out reduces the lubrication of the diesel. That I understand.....my Dad was an oilman for 40 years.....he bought oil fields for a large company. I know for a fact oil has a very different sulphur content based on where you get it.....sweet Texas crude almost none...Venuzalean mayo a ton.

So if sulphur lubricated there would be an issue....because its very different depending on where you get it. So they'd have to inform you of the content....if it was a problem for the last 50 years.
 
Let's assume for the sake of argument there is/will be some differences between #2 Diesel and home heating oil in the sulfur content. The only thing I've seen so far in the thread that prevents a fuel wholesaler from delivering diesel dockside is insurance considerations.

In my recent trip from Ft Lauderdale to the Chesapeake, every marina I stopped at for diesel insisted I pump it myself - obstensibly for the reason if it is spilled, I am responsible, not the marina. They won't let me pump out the holding tank, but I pump the fuel...

If I approach a fuel dealer and offer to pump it myself, shouldn't this get around the insurance issues, just like the marinas. Correct? Comments?

Delaware Jim
 
Here's the problem (I talked to my guy for five minutes)

Risk/Reward

You'd have to find a very, very small operator and talk to him personally.

He says his insurance specifically excludes any claims if he fills boats.

He said the chances of us spilling anything really are nearly zero (he said he'd prefer his guy to fill, I asked him about me filling), but you know what you'd think the same with oil, but people call and have fill up caps with no tanks, disconnected tanks, bad equipment, etc, etc, etc....he said insurance is a big old pain.

So what happens if we have a leaking tank, or some a-hole complains for no reason, or some marina gets mad at losing business and complains??

Now he has an issue. He doesn't have insurance (even if nothing is spilled), he doesn't have a containment system, now the DNR or state or local regulators are up his you know where for what? 1,000 gals???

He said look I'm going to have a ton of pressure to deliver Home Heating Oil, when the laws say it must be off road diesel.....that I could really make money on 100,000's of gallons of fuel but the risk isn't worth the reward.

So bottom line is he was telling me you could get a fly by nighter down in the eastern shore somewhere to do it but he didn't know anybody.

I also wouldn't expect him to tell a stranger over the phone.....but even if we paid him marina prices just to spite the marina we're talking about $300 bucks per 1,000 gallons if you had a decent business would you take that risk??

If there was enough demand for a guy with a single truck I'd say yes, but not a big operator.

I think the marinas have many reasons to have you pump your own. Wrong tank (water/waste) your fault, not hooked up your fault, overflow into your bilge your fault, you spill a bit your responsibility to report.

I think this makes sense for places that have tons of boats/less regs...MD isn't that.
 
The fire chief claimed that he had spoken to a fuel supplier and that he claimed he could not get insurance to deliver gasoline. The funny thing was that the water front news had just come out with their latest edition and I happen to have it with me at the commission meeting. The fuel supplier had a full page add stating that they deliver gas and diesel dockside. As I showed the ad to the city commission I asked how ironic that the fire chief claims the supplier can't get insurance and yet he has a full page ad stating he is fully licensed and insured.
It may just be that the insurance cost more and the fuel supplier just doesn’t want to pay higher insurance cost for a few boats he may fuel and feels it is not profitable for him. I would bet this is the case.
 
Delaware Jim,

You could also go the route I did. I have 4 55-gallon drums for fuel along with a pump and lots of hose that I use for my boat. I go fill the drums at the cheapest gas station and then take my truck to my boat. It can be labor intensive, but I save roughly $66.00 a barrel compared to marina prices.
 
I own a 2002 Dodge 2500 pickup with the 5.9L Cummins diesel. (the last of the "Clattering Cummins") On the Dodge-Diesel.com forum a year or 2 ago there was much discussion about the lubricity question. Many are putting outboard motor oil in their fuel tanks to restore lubricity. After much reading, discussion and thought, I went out to my boat and grabbed a quart of TCWIII (I believe that's the number) and added it to my truck's tank. I have the 64 gal. Aero tank, and had just added 50 gal. The accepted level that I'm working with is 1 qt per 50 gal. Started it up and drove away. I'm sure many or most of you have heard the earlier Cummins pickups - very noisy at low speed. I got about 1/4 mile down the road and the engine noise....stopped. Well, not quite, but the friend riding with me and I looked at each other in astonishment. The difference was incredible. I believe it took that long for the oil to mix in and get to the injector pump. Longer term driving showed that fuel mileage increased from around 12 to over 13 with the camper on board. Some time later, on a trip, I noticed while driving thru a town that the engine sure was noisy. Then realized I'd forgotten the outboard oil. Added it and 1/4 mile farther on it quietened down again. If you try this, be sure to use outboard oil - it's designed to burn cleanly and leave no deposits.

You can believe this or not, try this or not, that's fine, but the above has been my experience, and I'll continue to use it.

Lar.
 
Jim, marinas typically charge more for fuel because often their operating costs are higher. Consider the shorter boating season we face in Maryland; add to that the labor it takes to run a fuel dock as compared to middle eastern guy sitting in a bullet-proof booth or in a 7-11. While the fuel dock is busy on the weekends they pump only a small amount of fuel during the week. Marinas have to get special pollution insurance because they are on the water. A few weeks age I just received from MDE a notice to get our underground tanks inspected, the cost $1,800 and that doesn’t included any recommended repairs/upgrades to bring our facility into compliance with the most recent rules (no grandfathering here). Then there is the working capital necessary to carry the fuel inventory – the marina has already paid for that liquid gold you are pumping in your tank (our facility has three 10,000 gallon tanks so typically we’re talking about 24,000 gal. x $2.50 or $60,000). On Middle River many marinas have stopped pumping fuel because of the hidden cost to support their fuel docks; which in turn may lead to more of a monopoly and less options for boaters. And finally there is quality, at our fuel dock we get the highest quality premium diesel available – no off road junk, is that what you want sitting in your tank, not in mine anyway. So get your fuel from a truck, get a “bad” load and then see how much your fuel really cost. Like everybody else I am looking to save a little somewhere, but boating is not the place to look especially when you consider your investment.
 
Montauk Yacht Club doesn't offer fuel services, but they did suggest I call a local fuel delivery guy when we visited back in July. He needed 48 hours advance notice and was $0.30 per gallon cheaper than Star Island Marina, just around the corner. Although we didn't make use of his services (didn't have enough time for the 48 hour window)I did notice that it was a regular home heating oil fuel truck that was making the delivery. I got his card for the next time I'm in the area....
 
I was interested in this as well should I end up with a diesel, so I emailed a buddy here on Lake Travis:

There have been a variety of solutions over the years. Pumping from a truck directly into the boat is usually the best.

There is diesel that is dyed red and no road tax of 40 plus cents per gallon is charged, and that is what I use. Most recently a company, Suncoast, has been great about sending mass emails to everyone when they have a delivery confirmed. They come to Emerald Point at the base of the drystack ramp and we line up early in the AM.


Sounds pretty easy going here. I doubt that the marina would allow gasoline (since they sell it), but not issues with the diesel.
 
We are lucky here in the Pacific Northwest in that there are a number of marinas that are publicly owned by the port and can only charge their cost plus a small mark-up. Port of Poulsbo, WA is once such marina. I think that fact helps keep neighboring marinas in check as they would lose business otherwise.
 
Back
Top