Fuel Saving Idea??

FlyWright

Member
exMember
Joined
Mar 21, 2001
RO Number
3887
Messages
748
With diesel surpassing $4.00/gallon out here in CA, I've been thinking about ways to conserve fuel. Then last weekend, I hit a submerged log on my 34 Californian trawler and, out of precaution, returned to the slip with one engine shut down. I found my cruise speed dropped from 8 kts to 6.5 kts. Maneuvering on one engine was nearly as easy as on two, but the turns into the operative engine took a bit more effort.

This got me to thinking. If my second engine is just giving me an extra 1.5 kts (plus the bonuses of redundancy and maneuverability), but is doubling my fuel burn of single-engine ops, what if I just cruised on one engine for a period, then alternated to the other for the same length of time? I could be saving 50% on fuel, cutting my maintenance costs nearly in half and still have the advantages of maneuverability and redundancy. The negative to me would be a reduction in cruising speed, the need to track engine use so each engine gets similar time in service, and the reduced ease of maneuvering in cruise. Of course, I'd restart the other engine for docking and close quarters handling.

The only system that runs from just one engine on my boat is the hot water from the stbd engine only. All else is available from either engine.

Has anyone had experience with this? I'd love to hear any thoughts on this before trying it.
 
first, make sure you trannies can windmill with no damage... some can't.

this has been discussed many times, the benefits are not as significnat as it seems. You burn less on one engine at 6.5kt than on two at 8kts because is takes much less power to push the boat... especially on a 34 footer... at 8kts you are above hull speed and fuel burn increases dramatically. slow down to 6.5 on both engines and you will notice that the fuel flow will be much lower. Maybe not quite as low as on 1 engine but not far off.
 
Running on one engine will not double your economy. Running slower will.

Your hull speed is about 7.3 knots and the extra effort to push up to 8.0 is very expensive. The optimum economy, for diesels and according to David Gerr's "Propeller Handbook", is the square root of the waterline length or about 5½ knots in your case.

Take note of the wake you produce at different speeds. That's where the energy is going.
 
Thanks for the input, guys.

I wasn't even thinking about the trannies, Pascal.

So if I have this right, my best economy speed is not my hull speed. I had that wrong all along.

Thanks for setting me straight!
 
Hull speed is not the square root of the water line. It's the square root of the water line X 1.33. So, a boat with a 36' water line has 6 as the square root times 1.33 which is 7.98 knots.
I'm guessing a 34' boat has about a 32' water line which gives the boat about a 7.5 knot hull speed.
 
So if I understand this correctly, with a 48 foot length at waterline my most efficient hull speed would be 9.2 knots.

Does the beam (15 feet) factor into this computation?

Does it make a difference if it is a planing hull with a cruise on plane of around 17 knots. I would be willing to spend more time in route at 9 knots if my GPH goes from 25 to 8.

I suspect this would not be good for the diesels over time if this was the only speed you ran them at.
 
Hull speed is usually your most efficient speed. It takes a lot of power (gas, diesel) to get a boat up on plane.
My 38 Carver gets about 1 mile per gallon at hull speed. Cruise speed, around 15-16 knots, gets me less than 1/2 mile per gallon.
 
That's right, hull speed is higher than the square root of the water line length but it is not the most efficient speed. At least not according to Gerr in his book. You can also tell a lot from the wake produced at any speed.

With diesels, the fuel consumed is proportional to the power produced. That's not true of a gasoline engine, even an injected one. If it takes 20 hp to push your boat at a slow speed, it doesn't matter if you are runing one or two or three engines except for the very small parasitic loads of each engine.
 
let's just say that hull speed is the highest speed you can push a hull thru the water without a significant jump in power (therefor fuel) needed.

once you exceed hull speed, fuel burn will increase exponentioally.

the most efficient speed will be below hull speed, usually slowing down by a knot will result in large savings, IF your engines can handle running that low for long times. usually if they remain warm enough and if you run at higher speed for short while after a long slow run, they will be fine.

The worst speed is half on plane, dragging you stern in the water and pushing a large bow wave. on my 53 for instance, I burn twice as much fuel at 12 kts... It's a no brainer, twice the fuel, 25% more speed.

true displacement hulls are the most efficient, well sailboat are even more efficient. You can see it by the wake...
 
quote:

Originally posted by kgd

So if I understand this correctly, with a 48 foot length at waterline my most efficient hull speed would be 9.2 knots.

Does the beam (15 feet) factor into this computation?






The actual formula for hull speed is the square route of the waterline length times the prismatic coeffient of the hull. For most monohulls the prismatic coefficient is somewhere around 1.3.

A canoe would have a much higher prismatic coefficient and a square barge would have lower one.
 
there is a marginal fuel economy of running one engine vs. two, but it is a very small economy. it takes X # of BTUs of fuel to push the boat a Y knots. using one engine to produce that qoutient at low speed will produce a larger differenttial, at high speed its not possible as you don't have the additional HP capacity to offset using one motor. if you do run with one motor, a good rule of thumb is use 1/2 your rated RPMs no more, otherwise you are overloading the remaining engine. the only way to run with one motor at or near your rated RPM's is to reprop the boat. generally speaking the boat will be more efficient if you leave the unused motor in gear, the free wheeling prop will creat more drag spinning than fixed. if you do leave the motor free wheeling, make certain that if you have dripless shaft log that it is crossfed so it does'nt run dry.
 
I doubt best economy on a 48‘ will be at 9+ knots, probably more like 7.5-8kts. Maneuverability will probably be much better because as you begin to over drive the boat on a single steering becomes more difficult.
IMO the vast majority of folks are going too fast for economy when not on plane.

Best economy will likely be at the speed below the point of any bow rise. Any development of a hump or wave forward and aft with a trough amidships indicates that the boat is using power to push water instead of moving the boat as does any separation of the water at the transom.

From a fuel used standpoint it really doesn’t matter much how many engines produce the power used but for a longer passage in an area with little maneuvering required running one engine at more than idle load may contribute to better engine operating conditions especially for older engines. Alternating engines every few hours balances the hours and keeps everything lubed and cool. Transmission makers manuals frequently detail whether “lazy engine” operation is allowed but keep in mind they mean slow speed. Probably every transmission can tolerate being towed or prop turning while at a dock in a current. For my transmissions ZF specifically allows lazy engine operation they also don’t expect anyone would be dumb enough to overload the running engine as it would likely fail before the lazy transmission.

MY 44’ aft cabin, twin diesel ,planning boat will yield 2 Nmpg at 8.5-9kts dual and about 3 NMG at 7.5 on single engine. I really haven’t gone far enough to ascertain the answer of single vs. dual at slowest speeds for economy because at 3+ NMPG without fuel flow metering you have to make many longish trips with frequent refills to develop consistent data. But with 450 gallons It theoretically has a 1000+ mile range, not bad for a 38,000# planning boat capable of 23 kts.
 
For those researching this topic look at your engine makers fuel use curves. Look for a prop demand fuel curve, not max output curve as the prop load is what the engine will normally see as load. The two curves will only intersect at one point, max rated load. At all other RPMs the load will be lower than max load. The load curve is dependent on may assumptions but it is a good starting point in understand fuel use.
 
Great discussion here. Thank all for the input. I think it's time to throttle back a bit. I'll be paying more attention to my stern wave.
 
I undestand that it is not good to run diesels at low RPM for a long time, but what about gas engines? Many people want to cruise at low speed around 7 - 8 knots and that means to run the engines at almost idle RPM.
 
with gas engines if you run them at very low speed for extended periods of time you may want to consider changing to a hotter spark plug within the range specific to that engine. carbon fouling is the issue. with diesel the issue is unburned fuel if there is no load running down the cylinder walls and diluting the lubricating oil. in either engine fouling can generally be cleared up by simply raising the engine speed and load for a few minutes at set intervals.
 
quote:

I undestand that it is not good to run diesels at low RPM for a long time,





Another in a long series of diesel myths. It very much depends on the engine, installation. And operating area. Colder water can over cool some SWAC diesels.
Modern fresh water cooled thermostat controlled engines , gas or diesel will usually maintain proper operating temps at low speed. A brief run at the end of the day at high load will burn off any carbon. Excessive smoking on power up indicates excess fuel was accumulating and either that engine doesn’t like slow running or more likely it has a problem.
 
All these numbers are giving me a headache. I find when I drive too slow, I drink more beer and the wife bitches more. At about $8 a gallon for beer, it is not economical to drive slower plus add on the lost days on my life listening to the wife. I drive a on plane cruise speed!!!
 
Love this place. Finally we dispell the bad math that says that running 1 engine is half the power of two.

One point, if your going to run your diesels at moderate RPM's make sure your temps are up enough. On my 3208's, I replaced my thermostats last year and the temps went from 160 to 180. I spoke with a club peer this past weekend and he was describing how his 3208's were rock solid 160 running engines. There is but one part number in the catalog if I recall. Springs wear out, make sure your engines run up to temp.

Also, to push my 48 to 9 knots requires about 1400rpm. I run both engines, that's what the boat is propped for. They love it.
 
Back
Top