Replacement Speakers

dad123

Member
Joined
Apr 18, 2008
RO Number
29891
Messages
40
What would you recommend for replacement speakers for those that came standard in the cockpit in a Regal 3860? Currently there are Kenwood speakers, I think the 6.5 inch diameter. Sounds quality is really important so we don't mind paying for that. Saw some Bose but that would mean cutting bigger holes in the fiberglass which we really don't want to do. Appreciate any suggestions!
 
Anything but bose. Overpriced and overhyped. Kenwood, Clarion, Blaupunkt, Alpine, lots of good brands that should just bolt in fit and sound better than bose for less money.
 
I plan to replace four speakers this summmer. My audio guy highly recommends poly-planar.
 
JL Audio, Poly-planar, Infinity ....in that order.

Ken
 
If you can get by without a marine type speaker you will be better off sound quality wise. My recommendation is Kicker brand.
 
i'd upgrade to components but that would probably require a little cutting...would sound so much better...do you have an amp running these speakers?
 
I highly recommend Pioneer marine speakers. They sound great even if you are not running an amp.
 
Ping Big Bliss. Dom had an awsome setup in his Regal. Donm't recall th brand offhand. Clarion comes standard in Sea Ray. Good sound, however after years around jets and helicopters, a tin can would sound good to me.
 
I had a pair of Poly Planer speakers on my open center console offshore boat for 10 years and they never went bad. Same for the radio. I washed the boat with soap and water, I got salt water spray on it, rain, sun, nothing damaged them. Great speakers and radio. I just put another set of speakers and radio in the boat I have now and I bought the same thing again.
 
Wet Sound has the best sounding speakers for a boat, the speaker is specially designed for boats as unlike a car the sound get lost very soon after it exits the speaker. Wet Sound produce speakers that project the sound and in particular the quality.
Hope this helps
 
The best speakers I've ever heard for a boat were Polk Marine units with a amp. Not too expensive and really very dynamic. Crisp, clear highs and nice tight bass. Even better with a sub-woofer.

Many of these types of speakers come as Component or all in one units. Component speakers have separately mounted tweeters and require a "crossover" to work. All in one units contain the tweeter and mid-range/bass unit combined and usually have a built in "crossover" and will usually work as direct replacements of what you have. The advantage of the components is better separation of the highs and mids. But most decent all in one speakers have the ability to "aim" the tweeters. High frequency sound is directional.

If you do decide to go the sub-woofer route (in any brand) make sure you install a separate, second amp dedicated to the sub for the best performance. In the best situation, your source unit will have a separate low frequency output just for a sub-woofer that should go to the sub amp. If you don't, most amps have a filter that can re-direct low frequency to a separate amp and then to the sub.

I have found that sound is a matter of personal preference so go to your favorite store and listen. Just make sure that you know how they are being powered. If you go to the store and hear speakers hooked up through an amp, they will sound very different if installed without an amp. Placement on your vessel also makes a difference. Typically, the more air-space behind the speaker, the better they will sound. Just something to think about as you listen.

Remember, power is not about how loud you can play your system, it's about how well speakers perform and produce the dynamics of what you are listening to. In most cases, more power from amps is better. But too much can over-drive speakers that can't handle it. Make sure that whatever you end up with is rated to handle whatever you're feeding it.

If you have a decent source unit with no additional amp then you want a set of speakers that are efficient with the power that they are receiving. So keep asking questions. There is a lot of good info available on the web. I don't endorse them however, you may want to check out a site like Crutchfield for reading about systems and speakers.

At the end of the day, it's how much $$$ you want to spend vs how you like to listen. If you are a critical listener, then you won't be happy with run of the mill speakers.

If it just music in the background, then any average speakers that "sound good to you" will work. If you want to hear your music over the din of running on plane, then you may want to consider amps as an upgrade. You do get more volume with additional amps. Keep in mind though that amps eat battery power like inverters. The more amps you have, the more battery juice you will need to use them when on the hook w/o running a genny to keep your charger running.

When you go to the store, take your tape measure with you to make sure they will fit the existing holes though it's not hard to enlarge existing holes. I know that this is more than you asked for but I hope it's useful in some way.
Best,
 
I have both the Pioneer and Poly Planar marine speakers.

Both are good, 6.5 Pioneers are a great value. Search the web for an 'E' site in NYC that has the best price, around $65/pr.

Jonathan
 
dad123
In your Regal, you do not want to try to enlarge the speaker opening in the cockpit area. If you remove the speakers, you will find that when Regal made your boat, they installed fiberglass enclosures behind your cockpit speakers. The reason this is done by Regal is that your boat can utilize the cockpit area as sleeping quarters. The cockpit table will convert to a small berth or the cockpit sunpad area can be used as a berth. The speaker enclosures are to prevent any dangerous fumes from entering the cockpit area from your engine room if you are using the cockpit as a sleeping area, especially if the glass and canvas are installed.

The Poly-Planar Model MA-905 is a good speaker that will fit into your 6.5" openings that are 3-way speakers. The units are rectangular in shape and will protrude about 3/4" from the boat wall. These are great replacements for 6.5" opening when you can not expand the opening.

The comments regarding the amp is on target. The amp really adds the extra power to get you quality sound without overpowering volume. Also you may want to consider adding speakers at the helm if you listen to music while cruising. The helm speakers allow the sound to be blown past your ears so you get to actually hear something beside the wind.
 
My recomendation would have to be Polk/Momo with an external amplifier.
I just installed 6x9's in cockpit of a SeaRay 340 and 6.5" in the dinette area with an equalizer, 400 amp Alpine amplifier and Pioneer head end unit.
They are exceptionally clear, great midrange and tweeter on the 6.5", and the 6x9's have amazing bass and Clarity.
 
Thank you so much to everyone for all the detailed responses. I think the more detail the better and it is always useful...so keep those details coming! Is it safe to assume that installing a replacement speaker is as simple as removing the old, reconnecting the wires to the new speakers and resecuring? Does this one fall into the Do It Yourself category or is there something more to it than that?

And folieadeux - thanks so much for pointing out the Regal specific issue related to NOT cutting the fiberglass...really appreciate you letting me know that!
 
dad123

Speaker replacement is one of the easiest DYI jobs on a boat. Just pop off your present speaker covers, unscrew the present speakers, unhook the wire to the speakers, hook the old wire to the new speakers and mount the new speakers. Sometimes the new speakers will have a different hole pattern than the old speakers and you may have to drill some new holes but that is very easy. If you drill new holes just go slow and "measure twice but only drill once".
 
I'd have to agree with the Polk Audio recommendation. I had the entire first floor of my home wired for sound last winter using Polk Audio speakers. Even have a marine speaker in the steam-room. Sound is great!!
 
We installed a couple of sets of Clarion marine units with the seperate tweeter. Since the tweeter is wired from the main speaker you do not have to re-wire and is you use the tweeter mounting (as we did) you only need to drill a small home for the wires to run through. We picked spots that would give some bass resonance (sp?) rather than the usual radar arch and the speakers delivers crisp sound and nice deep bass. Sounds awesome...

Kuredu08.jpg
 
I just replaced 4 6.5 " round speakers on my boat, It was supposed to be super easy DIY job but as Murphy's law will have it, the previous cut-out holes were about a 1/4" too small for the replacement speakers (JBL marine speakers).

Luckily I found a circular rasp tool that popped into a cordless drill and I was able to widen the opening without cutting.

I also purchased a JBL marine amp, butI haven't tackled that installation yet.
 
I've heard that Clarion Speakers are good while thay work but that they DON'T LAST. You'll replace them often. I'm looking to replace my Clarions that did go bad.
 
Back
Top