Sea Trial - problem?

JJR222

Member
Joined
Sep 11, 2007
RO Number
28540
Messages
52
Hi all, I just did my sea trial yesterday on a 2005 Pro-Line 23 Sport. Merc. 200 SW Series has about 40 hours on it and it was kept on a lift since new. Great looking boat, but while on sea trial I wanted to see what the WOT numbers would be. At WOT we got 5,000 RPM and according to the speedo on the Raymarine DS 600X we only got to about 28 mph.

While I realize that I need to use GPS speed so won't know that until I install one, but it seemed to me that the boat was underpowered. I have heard people with the same boat/motor combo get nearly 40 mph or more. It has an aluminum prop and motor has not had service (tune up) since new. Owners says it's nearly ready for it's 50 hour service.

Had 1/2 tank of gas and 3 large guys on board.

My question is will a S/S prop get me any better cruising speed and/or top end and will a 50 hour service/tune-up really make much of a difference? The motor seemed to run great and didn't miss a beat, but just seemed like it couldn't get us anywhere near 30 mph.

Cruising attitiude was about 20 mph at 3,800 RPM. What is the RPM range for this motor?

Thanks very much,

John
 
I think it was a little sluggish. Before talking about speed and rpm, on any boat, the questions should always be: Is the bottom clean, Is the load right, Is the boat full of water, Is the trim right, Is the motor running right...
On a lift, bottom is clean, so is the inner hull drained dry of any rainwater, etc?
Then, is the motor running right? The way we always used to tell was with a "test wheel". What it does is consume HP without developing thrust, so the motor could be tested dockside or in a test tank. There was a wheel specified according to the motor, and included an rpm that motor should achieve at WOT. If not, something wrong. If so, proceed to match motor to boat and load by selecting a prop.
Underpowered? What is the boat's maufacturer's max HP rating? My personal rule of thumb for OB was to get into the top 1/3 of the max rating. So say this 23 carries a max rating 275. I'd think 200 or 225 should be pretty sweet, but would avoid 150 or 175 even though they should plane the boat.
 
According to Proline's website, a 23 sport is rated for 300 horsepower. If that's the same boat you are looking at, I would say it is severely underpowered. It seems so many dealers go low on power to make the boat more affordable. I don't think you would enjoy a boat that would only hit 28 WOT and cruise at 20. I would want to cruise at 28. JD gave you some good places to look, but I'm afraid it's just not enough motor to give you what you want.
 
The 2007 model which is essentially the same boat does have 250 hp max I think. But, Pro-Line says that 200 option should get approx. 42 to 45 mph. Assuming that's PR nonsense, the boat should at least do 30 cruise with a 200 and WOT of 35?
 
28MPH is SLOOOW for that boat (and most others as well). Sounds like she's underpowered to me.

Don't assume that since the boat is only a few years old you won't have any major problems either. My neighbor bought a 1 year old SR 195 sport with an mercury outboard (2006)for power and spent most of this season out of the water. He had major problems with the engine and didn't have a warranty or dealer to rely on.

Not sure where you're from, but the seasons up north are too short to miss time due to repairs.

There are some pretty good deals to be had right now on all boats so please don't make a decision you will regret.

Have you looked at the Laguna CC? The make an 18,19,21,24. Marine Max sells em and won't be carrying them next year. The ones that are left are being sold at or below cost. I've driven the 19 and was impressed with the ride, stability, and speed (40+).

If you can find one, you'd be getting a new boat motor, and aluminum trailer for cheap. I think the 19' was being sold for $22,995 with a 115 or 150HP (I forget).

If you are interested, send me an email or call me at 631-786-4472 and I will check to see whats left. I know they had 500+ of these and last I heard there were 5 or so left. After Norwalk BS this past week who knows.

There are a lot of intangibles that a dealer can (should) provide to you as opposed to private sale. Don't underestimate this or assume you'll pay more from a dealer.

Good Luck.
 
Thanks for the help. I spoke with Pro-Line and they tell me that with that motor I should get 40 to 42 mph rb2@gr5t WOT and an easy 30 mph cruise. WOT rpm should be 5,000 to 5,800 and I was barely getting 5,000 so the motor clearly needs a tune up at the very least. Engine still under warranty so I'm not too concerned. I bought the Pro-Line as I'm sure I'll be able to get the motor right. Thanks

John
 
Is the prop the correct one for the engine?
If the engine is running good and the bottom is clean, maybe the prop is the wrong diameter or pitch. Stainless steel of the same diameter and pitch isn't going to make that much of a difference. Also, that boat, if I'm not mistaken can handle a 300HP engine.
 
I wouldn't waste your time with that boat. Something is wrong. The dealer would never let a sick boat out for sea trial unless the boat wasn't fixable or the dealer is a complete dunce(which is entirely possible)
 
Check your prop pitch. That motor should turn 5500 rpm, not 5000. You bought a good boat. You'll see low 40's when you get it figured out. Good luck.
 
"At WOT we got 5,000 RPM and according to the speedo on the Raymarine DS 600X we only got to about 28 mph."

On a 23ft. boat?

LMAO..............................ROFLMAO
 
Did it seem like only 28 MPH?

I have a raymarine unit, and the transducer has a wheel that turns and calculates your speed. One day I noticed the GPS (SOG) was showing 28 MPH, however the water wheel (SOW) was only 5 MPH, I later notiuced some growth on the transducer that would cause the wheel to not spin that freely. Turning 5000 RPM's I would think would equate to a higher speed on that size boat, unless your prop pitch is "1"

MJK
 
Thanks to all for the advice. I did buy the boat and am taking delivery this weekend. Essentially I agree that the Raymarine is not all that accurate and the seller agreed to pay for the 50 hour engine service so I expect it will be much better once the motor is tuned. I also think the prop needs to be replaced. Once I have her in my driveway I'll be able to get it right. It's a beautiful boat with plenty of room to fish or cruise. Thanks again, John.
 
It's a big mistake to buy BEFORE the issues are resolved/fixed.
 
Charlie, thanks for the advice but the motor is still under warranty. Worst case scenario, Mercury has to make good on it. Nothing wrong with the engine, I just need to get the prop right and tune it up so RPM's will come up.
 
Back
Top