Skiff-Float Plane Collision

L. Keith

Active member
Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
RO Number
1615
Messages
2,397
Full details unknown at this time, but two persons are dead after a 16' skiff and a Float Plane were involved in a collision at Port Fourchon, Louisiana at approximately 1600 hrs, C.D.T. on Thursday, May 24. Port Fourchon is a very busy commercial Oilfield/Fishing port in southern Lafourche Parish and float planes come and go all the time. Not sure if the dead were in the plane or the boat.
 
From the web site "huma today dot com" Plane collides with boat in Leeville, one man dies

LEEVILLE- A Cessna floatplane collided with a boat in Bayou Lafourche this afternoon, killing a Hammond man who was driving the boat, authorities said.

The plane was leaving the Chevron dock at about 3:30 p.m. and was preparing to take off by taxiing along Bayou Lafourche when it hit collided with a westbound fiberglass boat, the Lafourche Parish Sheriff's Office said.

The Hammond man, whose identity has not been released because his family has not yet been notified, was declared dead at the scene. Authorities are unsure if he died from the impact or from drowning. He was the only person in the boat.

The three people in the plane were transported to East Jefferson General Hospital by one of Chevron's private helicopters, the sheriff's office said.

The Federal Aviation Administration and the Louisiana Department of Wildlife and Fisheries are investigating the crash.
 
the story on local news site, wwltv.com, says witnesses claim the boat crossed the plane's path as it was taking off.
 
Uncontrolled seaplane operations areas can be very hazardous. In Louisiana, where much of the oil operations are offshore, there is an incredible volume of seaplane traffic. And they use the same protected inland waterways as boaters ( for most of the same reasons. ) I am more familiar with the Venice area, but the "short trip" to the fuel dock from the Mississippi is about as exciting as it gets, as the seaplanes are stacked up in a pattern and landing as fast as they can ( and of course, taking off ). It becomes necessary to increase the normal "watch area" from a 360 deg circle, to a hemisphere. I have always been relieved to make it to the dock. Similar to crossing the interstate on foot during rush our...
 
Thanks for the updates, info I had came from a local in the Golden Meadow area. Chevron has it's own air operations and Leeville is their main base for the central Louisiana Gulf coast. Helicopter traffic can be intense, float plane traffic not so intense. (Helicopters serve offshore, float planes serve inland) The bayou is wide and straight in that area with no hidden curves. There is not a tree for twenty miles so visibility is unlimited in all directions. The bays to the west of Bayou Lafourche are good fishing grounds and I'm sure the sports were out yesterday. This incident will keep a few of the Poydras Street law firms working for the next year or so.
 
The witnesses likely know what they saw, but probably unqualified to speculate on the analysis of what they saw and make proper conclusions.

Seaplanes are at the bottom of the scale as to being a stand on vessel. If the plane hit the boat, there is a very high likelyhood it was the plane's fault. The small skiff would have had to make a course change just before impact. So, so summarize the skiff operator was likely not at fault, but just as dead anyway.

bp
 
Not sure what you mean Ghost.
I have many many T/Landings in Float planes all through Southeast Alaska. All the passengers up there learn to help the pilot spot for logs and skiffs.

If a Skiff pulls in front of a Float plane, it's next to impossible for the Float plant to turn or stop in time (depending on the distance of course)

A float plane just pulling away from the Dock dont make much noise, yet.
But when he starts his takeoff run, the racket is impossible to ignore.
Some older folks dont hear well, so noise cant be used as a defense. The guy in the skiff might have been an old Oil field guy who couldnt hear his own skiff running.

There are times, especially loaded when the Plane pitches up for a few moments before going on the plane. During that Pitchup, the skiff might have entered the Plane's course and the pilot or co-pilot might not have seen him.

Unless it's landing, at a pitched up attitude, or on takeoff at a pitched up attitude, the pilot would most likely see the skiff in time to throttle back.
But any other sort of a collision, it's 99% the Skiff drivers fault.
 
There seems to be a frequent impression that float planes are stand on vessels. They are not. It is the float plane's responsibility to ensure that their takeoff path is clear.

We have lots of floatplanes in Puget Sound as well as you know. We see them all the time. They can be a bit intimidating and people often go every which way trying to get out of their way, but by the rules, it is the responsiblity of the float plane to keep clear of boat traffic.

I ASSUME that boat traffic would need to "maintain course and speed", so if the skiff changed direction at the last minute, that could be the exception. The skiff may have failed to "maintain a proper lookout" to be aware that a plane was taxiing and made the unfortunate action to change direction. Still, most planes I see are off the ground in 15-30 seconds, so again I have to hold the plane resonsible for not leaving enough room for possible course changes by other boats.

Rule 18
(e) A seaplane on the water shall, in general, keep well clear of all
vessels and avoid impeding their navigation. In circumstances, however,
where risk of collision exists, she shall comply with the Rules of
this Part.

bp
 
Ghost, I didn't check your reference, but I believe that your are correct. Nevertheless, it is one of those rules where avoidance of testing the rule ( whenever possible ) is a better choice... ( ie: plan your boat's path so you do not intersect the "landing zone", whenever possible )
 
This is another accident that we will have forgotton about long before the results of the investigation will be available.
 
Sometimes I think that that its the intent of the long time frame ( I know, it's not, but it feels that way )
 
From the NTSB:

http://www.ntsb.gov/ntsb/brief.asp?ev_id=20070529X00645&key=1

On May 24, 2007, approximately 1530 central daylight time, a single-engine Cessna U206G float-equipped airplane, N45WT, was substantially damage during collision with a 17-foot powerboat during a water take-off from the Bayou Fourchon Seaplane Base, near Leeville, Louisiana. The commercial pilot and the two passengers in the airplane were not injured. The sole occupant of the motor boat was fatally injured. The airplane was owned and operated by Chevron USA, of Picayune, Mississippi. Visual meteorological conditions prevailed, and a flight plan was not filed for the training flight conducted under the provisions of 14 Code of Federal Regulations Part 91. The local flight was originating at the time of the mishap.

Initial witnesses statements to the Federal Aviation Administration Inspector, who responded to the scene of the accident, indicate that as the airplane initiated its water takeoff run, a powerboat emerged from a channel and crossed in front of the takeoff path of the airplane. Witnesses observed that before completing the crossing, the boat executed a U-turn in front of the airplane. The pilot of the airplane attempted to avoid the watercraft by attempting to get the airplane airborne. The floats of the airplane struck the fiberglass boat and the airplane then nosed-over into the water. The airplane sustained structural damage and was partly submerged.
 
"the boat executed a U-turn in front of the airplane."

Panic. The original error of not paying attention may not have resulted in a collision, but that U-turn...

--

I KNOW it is 20-20 hindsight, but I have to wonder if leaping overboard in a dive might have saved his life. Sad.
 
Back
Top