Surveyor Question

douglee25

Member
Joined
Jan 9, 2008
RO Number
29196
Messages
337
I am in the process of getting a 1997 27' Larson Cabrio surveyed shortly. I spoke with surveyor who was SAMS certified for about 20 minutes the other day. He seems quite knowledgable on the phone and the pricing seems in line with others that I've spoken to. I asked him if the pricing he quoted me included the sea trial. He said it did not. He countered and asked me if I was familiar with boating, engines, etc? I said yes definitely. He said I charge $100 (or whatever the exact figure was) extra for the sea trial. He goes to be honest with you, the only thing I can do on the sea trial is monitor the gauges, listen for any abnormal noises from the engine, and double verify everything that he checked on land worked in the water. He said he would go if I wanted him to, but said if I wanted to save a couple bucks, I could do it myself. While I totally agree with his philosophy, I was curious if others felt the same way and would contemplate doing the same.

Doug
 
i guess on a small boat it's not as critical for the surveyor to be on the sea trial although i woudl think is opinion woudl be good to have. Not sure about stern drive but on an inboard, the surveyor will want to check engine mounts by having the captain shift in Fwd and rev and increasing RPM. i woudlnt think that's a valuable test on a stern drive boat too, along with noise and vibration.

i wouldn't try to save $100 on this...

and make sure you see trial the boat before the survey to make sure it is even worth surveying...
 
I spoke to another SAMS surveyor about an hour ago. I scheduled him because he seemed to be very upfront and very knowledgeable. This is what is included:

On land (approx 3 - 4 hours) -
1. All system check
2. Hull and structural survey
3. Moisture analysis
4. Visual on engine and drive

On water (approx 15 minutes) -
1. Complete in water system check

Sea Trial (approx. 1 hour) -
1. Note gauge positions
2. Note performance (plane speed, etc)
3. Check for vibrations, abnormal noises, etc

He provides two bindered copies of the survey along with a CD of 150-200 pictures. He basically said the report will almost be an owner's manual for the boat when he's complete.

I inquired as to why several of the surveyors I've spoken to quote the sea trial extra. He explained that from this area or other areas in Ohio, the actual drive distance for the sea trial can be lengthy. Most surveys include the land portion which is no problem. Now the surveyor must schedule another trip say between 2 hours round trip drive time, plus the actual sea trial time. Some owners seem to want the sea trial to go on for hours because they are just enjoying the cruise and not checking out the actual systems. Many surveyors are aware of this issue from the area and hence why they quote it differently than say Philadelphia, where the water is a 10 minute drive.

The surveyor lives 5 minutes from the dealer. He said that the dealer is probably one of the best dealers he's ever worked with. They present their boats very well and he's never had an issue in dealing with them. That makes me feel good and it also reaffirms my positive guy feeling that I've already received from my initial transaction/phone calls.

Doug
 
the seatrial should include monitoring at various speeds/rpms to determine if the boat is hitting it's published specs. you might also want an engine oil analysis done to determine if the engine has been abused.
 
The surveyor lives 5 minutes from the dealer.

he's never had an issue in dealing with them.

Sounds to me like he gets most of his work from the dealer. Somethimes you get what you pay for. Think this over.

Gary
 
yep... I hate to question someones integrity when they may be no reason to, but the 5 minutes from the dealer and frequent business is not ideal.
 
I think you guys are taking my post the wrong way...

The surveyor has lake front property that is 5 minutes from the dealer. The surveyor commented that out of the **** load of boats he's surveyed, the boats that's he's done at that specific marina were advertised correctly and were in great shape. The marina did not recommend this surveyor, I found him on my own through SAMS. The surveyor has been in the business for 20 some years. After a while, you're going to have an idea of who does and who does not represent boats accordingly.

Doug
 
quote:

Originally posted by gbarger

The surveyor lives 5 minutes from the dealer.

he's never had an issue in dealing with them.

Sounds to me like he gets most of his work from the dealer. Somethimes you get what you pay for. Think this over.

Gary






If the surveyor lived 3 hours from the marina and never had issues, would that make things different? I think you read way too far into my response.

Doug
 
I have a friend who's a marine surveyor and he lives near Duluth, MN.

Would you like his name and number?

LOL... [:-thumbu]
 
WOW, some of us on this board are sure suspicious!

G
 
quote:

Originally posted by douglee25

quote:

Originally posted by gbarger

The surveyor lives 5 minutes from the dealer.

he's never had an issue in dealing with them.

Sounds to me like he gets most of his work from the dealer. Somethimes you get what you pay for. Think this over.

Gary






If the surveyor lived 3 hours from the marina and never had issues, would that make things different? I think you read way too far into my response.

Doug








I just had to read the facts that were posted and could not read what facts were not there.

So I pointed out that hiring a surveyor who has a close(business) relation with the dealer might not be the best idea. You are aware of this and feel comfortable, that is all that is important.

I will ask you, would you feel comfortable with a surveyor who has an ongoing business relationship with the dealer and/or was refered to you by the dealer?

I will answer the question you asked me, it's not the distance the surveyor lives from the dealer, but the question of whether or not there is an ongoing business relationship that would be a concern of mine.

Gary
 
You want to feel more comfortable? Simply ask the surveyor for references of former customers - and ask for clients that have smaller and also much larger boats. See what they have to say. The truth is - 5 mins or 5 hours - a relationship with the dealer or not - is simply not going to matter. If previous customers tell you they had problems that's your best indication. Realize that the references you get are probably going to be customers that didn't have any problems - or the surveyor wouldn't give them to you. So unless you know someone that used this guy before - and get some feed back from them - you're just simply never going to know - unless you have some unbiased and trusted referral.

You have the same issues when you hire anyone to do a job - unless you have someone that you trust that did work with this guy before you'll simply never know what will happen until you hire him - and even then nothing is a sure thing. So what do you do? Trusting your instincts is always your best bet...
 
Back
Top