VHF's

Interesting topic. All the charters and anybody who has fished a private boat very often out of the Outer Banks of N.C. (Hatteras or Oregon Inlets), uses Loran lines (actually just the lower line and the depth) to refer to their position. Typical transmission would be something like "I'm on the 230 line at 90 fathoms". I realize that this is not nearly as accurate a position as the GPS numbers, but that's the way it is done down there. It is a much quicker and easier way to give an approximate position than the GPS numbers at least in this location. The reason it works well is that the lower line runs not so far from perpendicular from the shoreline. No doubt the CG still wants your real lat/long if you have an emergency.
 
Okay my choices are if I am distress

1)40 08.600' x 71 18.500' or;

2)I am 10 miles east of Block Island

3)I am at the mudhole

So, number 1 gives the most accurate, pin pointable condition as to my location.

Number 2 tells people that I am in the Atlantic Ocean - they should be here in no time

Number 3 tells people the area I am fishing and is a well known fishing area - should get people there - BUT WAIT - there are two mudholes. I would just love to put out a mayday telling people I am at the mudhole and see the entire rescue party go to New Jersey when I am actually east of BI.

I will stick with coordinates thank you.
 
bottom line, you need to give both. "i m 41 10 00 N 72 00 00 W about 1 mile east of cerberus shoal"

that gives both accuracy AND a quick reference... actually.. I'd say... "i'm about 1 mile east of cerberus shoal, 41 10 00 and 72 00 00 W" this will get the attention of those in the vicinity and make them jot down the numbers.
 
1. Nicely done Mike, thanks. There's nothing wrong with a rant when it contains accurate and helpful informtation.

2. Pascal, I agree 100% about offering both co-ordinates and a description of your current loc during an emergency.

3. Jim, One mile SW of the South Bass Light is: N41.37.062 W82.51.385 I determined that in less time that it took me to type the 2 sentences above. YOU NEED TO LEARN HOW TO *TRULEY* NAVIGATE! Just because you rant about using paper charts DOESN'T MEAN YOU HAVE A CLUE about what you're doing! Staring at a paper chart and guessing where you are IS NOT NAVIGATING! I've said this before: that is dead reckoning with paper.

I fear the day that you find yourself in trouble, in poor visibility in bad weather. You will indeed, be in trouble.
 
My rule of thumb is a bit broader I suppose. If I can hear the vessel's mayday call I'm probably close enough that I want to copy their position and find it either on a chart or my plotter. Finding it on the plotter is relatively easy...I just hit the "waypoint" button then "enter by lat/long" instead of "cursor" or "ships position." I even get an ETA and course line doing it that way.
 
Pascal - I think I missed that - thank you for catching t. Geographic gets people to listen and might ge them in the general area, and a lat and long gets them to you.
 
using both also lessons the chances for mistakes. In a panic, you might say "I'm located 1 mile NW of South Bass Island", when you meant to say SW of North Bass Island.

It's also possible to transpose or miss digits in the co-ordinates. I sometime listen to archives of distress calls - the average pleasure boater in an emergency rarely calls in a mayday in a calm, cool frame of mind.
 
Yesterday, a 63 footer called in a mayday with a fire on board, just outside Johns Pass (between St.Pete beach and Clearwater Fl.) By the time the CG got the basic info, souls onboard, length, further requests for color, lat longs etc. went unanswered. The one soul on board had abandoned ship.

The communications were hampered by several calls for radio checks, and the usual advertising responses from Sea Tow or Tow Boat US, stepping on the transmissions from the CG and boat in distress.

Fortunately the general location description was good enough to get immediate response from fellow boaters and a Sheriffs boat, just inside the pass.
 
Over the Memorial Holiday, I made a distress call for a fellow boater that did not have VHF (rental boat). I thought I knew my chartplotter pretty well, but it took me a minute to finger out the lat/long on my chartplotter. I was able to provide geographic location, however CG really neeeded the lat/long. That experience reinforced that I need to KNOW how to get to the lat/long display from whatever screen my multifunction display is in, and of course now I do.
 
Speaking of Sea Tow and BoatUS, if you've called in an accurate mayday call, 9 times out of 10 Sea Tow or BoatUS will be on scene faster than the CG.
 
The last time I called in for someone who was about to go on the rocks, I gave them the EXACT point on a particular island. "XXX tow, the vessel is located at XXX point on the north tip of xxx island".

them: "Okay sir, we'll have a vessel there in about 90 minutes"

me: "XXX tow, please confirm location, your XXX harbor boat just passed us about 5 minutes ago"

them: "But sir, xxx point is just off YYY island".

me: "Right point, wrong island"

them: "Thank you sir, we will be there in 10 minutes"

Moral of this story is to reinforce the idea that you want to give BOTH the location AND the coordinates. Just as Pascal and Mike described.
 
Back
Top