Today I received a call back from the insurance company. The adjuster has spoken with all interested parties. Let's start with the damaged vessel's owner. He stated to the insurance adjuster that no way did our boat cause this damage. Period. He did not offer any explanation for where the damage was incurred but he clearly stated we were not responsible. He has been boating 55 years from what he said to me in front of other people. Hold onto that thought.
The owner of the tow company was also contacted by the insurance company. He stated that due to "personality conflicts", he was going to absorb the cost of the damage. So the claim that I opened has been dropped by the insurance company.
Let the sparks fly but I say we have an inept captain being covered for by the owner. He might have waited for an opportune passerby to claim damage against. When he thought he had a good mark he moved from the far side of the channel and crossed the channel to a minimum wake. It was 6 inches or less at the time he crossed it. But preceding this, there was a two foot wake that rocked all boats and it was caused by the bowrider cutting between us and the tow. We were doing 4-5 knots at that time. Leading up to that point, and moving away from it we never exceeded 8 knots. I can prove this with GPS data. He crossed that wake with a lazy turn to port, with the tow to starboard. The owner of the tow company said due to the heft of our boat we caused the damage. That is to say, our boat has sufficient wake at 4 to 5 knots to exceed all of the professional preparations they have made to ensure the safety of the property they work with.
I say the piloting or preparation for the hip tow caused the damage due to the wake of the boat that passed between us. We can also post photos of the fenders used by the tow boat along with the registration numbers of the towing boat. All fenders were well above the damaged area. None were at the water line or there abouts where the damage occurred.
We're talking about a tow with twin 150 outboards on a cat. Ok? I could have pushed that boat into the wake properly with my dink faster than he could have done it with his tow.
The insurance company has investigated and they are closing the claim out.
So be careful if you need a tow, or hear on 16 about a tow up ahead that you might pass. Especially if it's a member being towed to their next destination where there's no money to be made.
Here is a photo of the damage as pointed out by the owner.
Again, my only interest here is alerting fellow boaters to the what went on out there. They'll make a buck any way they can and they will use your insurance to maintain their bottom line.
If I really had an axe to grind, I'd mention exactly where this happened and who was responsible.
But I know there are very capable and good captains out there answering the call to aid boaters in distress. We have witnessed several example of this in the Jupiter inlet area earlier this week. Those captains were gracious and appreciative of our behavior when we met them while they had tows in progress.
Note, they were tows not HIP tows. They also issued a broadcast when they were in the ICW.
This captain did not issue a broadcast. But we knew he was out there based on scanning all of the appropriate channels.
Again. If it looks like it stinks, it does. Take photos.