What's your compass deviation...

Inkblue- See what you started! To almost answer your question, The average deviation on my 2 compasses I believe is plenty enough to warrant getting busy and adjusting, especially at the tower station. I've added a lot of stuff to the boat since they were last adjusted properly. Thanks for the reminder. Another reminder to all, just because your compass reads reads accurately in a particular heading such as 0* mag N, does not mean it is at all accurate say at 90* or 180* . That cell phone (or 8/0 hook, etc.) placed directly ahead (in this case) of the compass on the dash may set you waaay off course as you turn into the next leg- temp deviation can be more dangerous than constant onboard deviation. Worse, the smaller temp influences are harder to detect than larger ones. Luckily , in most cases these days GPS tends to save us from possible innattention to some of these compass problems, but also means we are less likely to attend to their fix.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Gene Johnson

I have to disagree with Divedaddy. I had Jens Jacobs, a compass adjuster here on Long Island, come down to the boat and take it out into the bay and "swing the boat". While he does this his assistant reads headings off a master compass set up on a tripod in the stern of the boat. From the different readings between the boat's compass and his, he makes up a deviation card for the boat.






That's the right procedure. The issues with boats are the ability to hold a very steady heading and the fact the the master compass is on the boat and can be affected by anything ferrous or electrical by an undetermined amount.

In my experience with airplanes when a good compass has been properly installed and compensated on N,S,E and W alignments, then the maximum deviation I have seen is about 4 deg. and 2-3 is more typical. For a typical pleasure boat, the swings to average will be much greater than the deviation.

So, the principal is sound, but the practice will be extremely difficult on recreational vessels to the point of being impractical for most folks. It can be done, but to be useful it would require ideal conditions. My preference would be to get the compensation adjustment good, and for that a good master compass would do the job. That will probably do more for accuracy than trying to measure actual deviation for a compass on a moving boat.

I have seen more than one magnetic compass on an airplane that was nearly useless due to the aircrafts changing fields. One I remember well was on a Jet Commander about 35 years ago. In an attempt to get the compass away from the radios and electronics, it was installed behind and above the left seat (not uncommon in small and larger jet with a lot of electronics). A small folding mirror was installed on top of the instrument panel, so if you did want to reference the magnetic compass you flipped up the mirror and read the image. On this Jet Commander with everything turned on, sitting still on the ground, the compass would oscillate +/- 30-40 degrees -- back and forth. In flight it would oscillate even more and at times would just turn steadily for a while. Needless to say, the magnetic compass was never referenced.

As far as navigation goes, as I was taught way too long ago to remember the course you plot on a chart is measured as a true course. From that you calculate a course to steer by a compass. In an ideal world the calculation accounts for both magnetic variation and compass deviation.
 
"Not for me. I constantly use both compass and GPS to steer by and prefer they agree as much as possible considering wind & current."

Like I said, to each his own. But I don't see the point of steering by both compass and GPS when they only agree "as much as possible". :-)
 
Bear in mind you may not always have the GPS. A magnetic compass is the most reliable nav aid you have. Keeping it adjusted and knowing how to use it is good insurance.
 
Excellent point, Willie.

I was taught years ago to always use two methods of navigation simultaneously. Pilotage, dead reckoning, radio/electronic, celestial - combine any two as appropriate for the course, equipment and conditions. Never rely on a single method for any course leg.
 
If I thought that my compass had deviation I would simply tell it to straighten up or be replaced.
No deviates allowed on my boat.
 
No deviates allowed?

Must be a really boring trip. Who's driving the boat by the way??? Otto?
 
Capt Bill is merely making the point that True is easier to plot, involves zero conversion, and more accurate to navigate by. If you lose your electronics and you have to go to your wet compass, you merely add or subtract your variation and deviation and you are in business. Seems to be effective, simple, less prone to error WHEN you think about the human processes involved.

Let me give you example of eliminating error in human process and see how you folks think.
If you have an intertial unit where you have to tell it where it is before you navigate, you must enter the lat/long. Here are your choices, list them in order of preference.

Get out a chart plot your position and enter the lat/long numbers manually

Use a database of coordiates, select your location and let the database enter the lat long directly to the unit.

Get out a list of coordinates, one of which is your position and enter those numbers manually

Select the GPS coordiates and transfer them electronically into the interial units.
 
Have to agree with GeeBee (for once). I agree with his priorities too. Only one thing to add: after you plot your position and that of your destination, plot the course between the two and write down the details. At least then you should know the GPS is steering you right.

Failure to do so is arguably what nailed KAL007
 
Back
Top