Are there any current tests comparing them? Everybody seems to have their favorite. Something they've been using and are happy with. But only a side-by-side, multi-year test would really tell us anything semi-scientific. PowerBoat Reports did one some years back, and that's the only real test I've seen. Don't recall which one won, but the West Marine stuff (CFF?.. I know it when I see it in the store) came in second and was something like $100/gal cheaper than the winner. That's the one I've used ever since. Of course, formulations and formulators can change, so not sure how relevant an old test may be today.
JB