Which Manifolds and Risers

gcolton

Well-known member
Member
Joined
Aug 10, 2002
RO Number
9708
Messages
2,581
It looks like my purchase of the 1999 Pursuit 3000 Express is going through. The only thing left is hull survey and mechanical inspection. These are scheduled next week.

I do know that the manifolds and risers on the boat are original. I talked to George yesterday and he suggested either the Siera or Osco products. He said that the Osco is heavier duty (heavier material) and the Siera has a little more performance (maybe 7 to 10%).

I expect to keep the boat 4 to 5 years at which time I will probably be ready to leave boating as I will be 75 or 76 years old.

Does anyone have any experience on either of these brands that would help me make a decision? The mechanic that has been maintaining the boat only likes OEM equipment so he is no help. (I guess he could be right.) I had been thinking of having him change out these items before bringing the boat the 110 miles here. However, with his attitude I am not sure. I would be more comfortable if they were changed, but one last run should be OK as the engines will be running the whole way except for probably a fuel stop at Tyndall AFB.

G
 
Giving up so early! At 75, you've got years of boating ahead of you...

That boat will actually make you younger!
 
I replaced mine last weekend. I purchased the Osco's. . . they are somewhat heavier than the Barr brand that I took off (if that means anything). Can't add anything else to the discussion.
 
Always had good luck with the Osco brand. Should suit your needs.
 
I've had Barr and Osco and both worked. Did I tell you the story about the boat I bought once, who's risers caused the boat to fail the day after I bought it?
 
not to hijack the thread, but I am also on the verge of getting my manifolds and risers, for a 1991 boat with twin Volvo 305s.

if buying aftermarket, I had pretty well convinced myself to get the Sierras or the Oscos. For some reason not well explained, my mechanic prefers the Sierras.

I am now considering getting Volvo OEMs. Obviously this is the most expensive options, but probably the "best".

I have a quote on these that is acceptable (looks like about $800 per engine vs. $600 for the Sierras - this looks like a sensible premium to me).

I live up here in Canada and by the time I've paid to ship the parts from their depot in Maine, I can't realistically return them....

The price of $800 compares to $1,400 that the Canadian suppliers are quoting me for the Volvo OEM parts. Did I just find a good route to go, or is it a case of "too good to be true"?

Thanks.

Orcbait
 
You can't go wrong with OEM. But if the Siera have the potential for more performance, more performance equates to less gas too. More for you to consider.
 
Geo,
Just curious, couple months ago the sierra were backordered. Did Geo say they were caught up?
 
quote:

Originally posted by jtybt15

Geo,
Just curious, couple months ago the sierra were backordered. Did Geo say they were caught up?






We did not discuss whether or not they were in stock. I will not order until the boat has passed all surveys/inspections so did not ask the in stock question.

Some I do not think he would have suggested them if they were not in stock but???

George
 
I went through this last year and decided on Sierra. I ordered them from a local supplier and picked them up. When I picked them up all the boxes looked the same and said Sierra on them,so I loaded them up and took them home. When I opened the boxes up at home a few said "Barr" and some said "Aqua Power" on them. The point is what makes you so sure that they're any different. The only thing I learned was to stay away from "GLM" because of some kind of casting problems. I'll add that a friend did his boat at the same time and used "GLM" and has no problems.
 
I used GLM on my boat.So far they are fine. The only things I have found are, be careful of the edges, you can shave with them. They have powder coated all over the fittings and I had to change them out which was a pain. The temperture sensor plug was way to big and I went to a plumbing store and bought a fitting which I screwed the sensor into.
I hope to sell the boat next year so I will not be able to attestto their longevity.
 
I just learned something that takes the urgency out of my replacing these manifolds.

I had heard about a "recall" because of water injestion. A few minutes ago I talked to Mercruiser and they told me that for the serial numbers that I had provided the manifolds and elbows had been replaced in 2003. That is A LOT BETTER than what I thought were original 1999 units.

I still will need to make a decision within a year or so but do not have to be in a hurry.

G
 
George suggested Sierra because he wanted me to get that little performance boost they offer. I followed his advice and got Sierra manifolds and risers from BoatFix. Boat uses 3-inch spacers which he furnished in OSCO. Said "it's just a spacer and OSCO is less expensive than Sierra".
Sierra has larger exhaust passages, so the external size is bigger to get enough water around that bigger exhaust area. This makes sparkplug changing clearance minimal, but it isn't a problem and I'm pleased with what we've got. Installed in 2005 and have run 500 hours.
BoatFix service: They were out of stock on SBC manifolds and had an order enroute from Sierra. In order to keep my project on schedule, he had Sierra ship a pair direct to me. I had it all here when I was ready to start.
Advice from George: No need to remove paint from gasket surfaces unless it's loose or lumpy. Use Ultra Black on gasketed surfaces.
Advice from j-d: If you get an OSCO product like my spacers, paint the dickens out of them! I used what I thought was enough black engine paint and got surface rust on the spacers just about right away. That's a plus for the Sierra parts - They come with a smooth, solid black finish, no burrs, ready to install.
 
j-d, thanks. Good information. I am a little concerned about the larger size of the Sierra. This Pursuit is rather cramped in the "engine room" to start. Partly because the boat is only 10'6" wide and partly because the hatch only opens about 24" in the back. You have to stick your head out of the day hatch to breath.

George
 
I replace my volvo(5.7) manifolds & risers 2 years ago. (GLM) Just pulled the risers for overheating problem. Sent them back for a warranty claim.
 
George, you won't see any size difference but you'll feel it when you put the plugs back in. I can "sit down" beside the front of the engine since it's single and covered by a motor box as opposed to under a cockpit sole. The rear plugs were and still are hard to get at because the back of the engine is hidden in the transom area.
As mentioned above, you can't go wrong with OEM. If Newport Dave weighs in on this, I'm sure that's what he'll say.
 
Back
Top