Would you do this?

kalcris

Member
Joined
Jun 5, 2002
RO Number
8891
Messages
106
Would anyone here try to sail from Halifax, NS to Bermuda in late December on a 29' sailboat..Then ask the US coast guard to come and get you? I think he should be sent a bill for stupidity.

Commander William Kelly (left) talks with Collin after his rescue.

By Globe Staff

Tossed on the waves 350 miles southeast of Boston, the sailor alone in the 29-foot boat made a desperate call for help. The Coast Guard raced to his rescue.

Early this morning, Canadian Jean Raymon Collin stepped aboard the cutter Tahoma and was swathed in blankets, safe at last.

The Tahoma made visual and radio contact Friday morning with Collin. But the weather was too rough for the crew to launch a small boat.

The cutter remained on the scene overnight, positioning itself to block the winds from the disabled vessel. The Tahoma was able to launch its boat this morning and rescued Collin, bringing him aboard at about 7 a.m.

The Tahoma is now on its way to Boston with Collin aboard. Commander William Kelly, commanding officer of the cutter, said Collin was happy and relieved to be off the boat and on his way back to loved ones for the holidays.
 
There are no laws against stupidity. And yes, I agree he should get some kind of a bill from the CG.
 
Agreed. Some of these air heads should get a bill from USCG for their rescue work
 
FWIW- The report I read said he didn't have enough fuel (on his sailboat) to reach his destination. The CG left a GPS tracking device onboard so he can get back to the boat later.
 
Take the boat as payment for the rescue , and then tell the guy he needs to go camping or something that is a bit more less hazard less.
 
Bob might try it. Did the sailboat have bowrider seats?
 
I have a question about our Dilbert in his Sailboat.
I thought Sailboats were pretty much a 'bad water' boat.
Meaning when the Gale is upon you, trim the sails, lash the Rudder amidships, Jamb the Cabin door shut aginst the weather and go strap yourself down for a heckuva ride.

Unless the Ocean breaks through the cabin door, or you get pitch poled and the mast breaks below the top deck and lets the ocean in, what can go wrong?
Why couldnt our 'almost brave' voyager just ride it out?
 
When most hear of Bermuda, they think of the Caribean. "Oh yeah, Bermuda is just down there by the Bahamas, the Virgin Islands or somewhere."

Well, if you think Bermuda is anywhere near there, Chicago is a suburb of NY. The distance is the similar.

Being 1000 miles N of the Bahamas we get our fair share of N Atlantic winter storms. A relatively short trip from The Cape Hattaras NC to Bermuda at this time of year is hazardous in a small (defined as under 40') boat.

To do it from Halifax on a route that takes you due S across the paths of the winter storms is sheer stupidity.

SEND THE IDIOT A BILL!
 
I agree VB. He needs to pay the bill. You gotta wonder why he ever considerd trying that kind of a trip!
I was just curious about why he didnt batten down the ship and tie himself in his bunk, and wait for calmer weather?
Wont sailboats do a thing like that? What happens to them to make that a bad idea?
 
"The CG left a GPS tracking device onboard so he can get back to the boat later."

That's the icing on the calke ... now the CG is helping him find the boat he abandoned ... the CG should sieze the boat and sell it to reimburse them (ultimately us) for his stupidity.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Thudpucker

I agree VB. He needs to pay the bill. You gotta wonder why he ever considerd trying that kind of a trip!
I was just curious about why he didnt batten down the ship and tie himself in his bunk, and wait for calmer weather?
Wont sailboats do a thing like that? What happens to them to make that a bad idea?






thud, maybe these questions should be posted in the sailboat forum. I'd be interested in seeing a response from sailboters myself!
 
Well, imo, there is an unnecessary risk anyone gets in a pleasure boat and sets sail, regardless of conditions.
If you start billing one boater for placing themselves in danger, then where does it stop? Realistically, we all could be billed just because we left the safety of land.
 
People sail in these waters due to ignorance; each year, there are rescues, and deaths because of foolishness. However, this does not inhierantly make voyaging in able pleasure boats either risky as "blueMonday" implies. If you feel that boating offshore is unsafe, then don't do it, but no reason to condem others who successfully voyage.
 
Why is this so readily being crowned an idiot? Do we know anything about their captaining abilities? How was the vessel outfitted?

As a veteran of 6 Newport - Bermuda runs (one of which was done in late November), I can tell you I have literally drifted to Bermuda and have smashed our way through storms to get there.

A 29' sailboat to Bermuda is not in the realm of stupidity - I know people who have done the Newport-Bermuda run in J 22s.

These SAR's are part of the CG's mission and duties - why should they send the bill for doing what it is they volunteered to do?
 
It's like going mountain climbing when you know the weather is likely to get bad and then putting other lives at risk trying to rescue you.

Here in Louisiana a week or two ago two men and two women (one pregnant) went out into Lake Pontchartrain and Lake Maurepas in a small boat about 16 to 18 feet. The weather got bad. They had cell phones and even called home to say they were heading in. The boat capsized in the rough water. And it wasn't until they were missing for two days that someone in the family back on shore decided to notify the Coast Guard. The two women managed to make it to shore and spent a couple of near freezing nights out and the two men died.

The shallow lakes here get bad in a hurry when they winds kick up. I can't imagine going out in that size boat with the weather we were having at that time. And I can't imagine no one calling for help until they had been missing for two days.

I guess I'm more cautious than most.
 
"It's like going mountain climbing when you know the weather is likely to get bad and then putting other lives at risk trying to rescue you."

All depends on who is doing the mountain climbing. Based on your logic, you would classify any participant in the following as an idiot:

Newport to Bermuda race
Marion to Bermuda race
Sydney - Hobart
Transpac
Fastnet
Volvo Ocean Race
Global Cahllenge
Clipper Round the World
Velux 5
Vendee Globe

I for one, will not paint the captian with a broad stroke of idiocy without first knowing their skill set and preparedness.

Also, the men and women of the CG put their lives on the line when they signed the enlistment papers.
 
Strongly opposed to billing people for SAR response, or anything else that would discourage them from calling out at the first sign of trouble.
 
I think there should be a review board that determines idiocy. Dont they do this with real captains?
Only this would be for getting charged, as well as you rticket pulled.
 
quote:

Originally posted by November Charlie
Strongly opposed to billing people for SAR response, or anything else that would discourage them from calling out at the first sign of trouble.





Excellent point Mike! Better to look foolish and get rescued then to not call for help and die. Now that is really stupid!
 
Back
Top