2005 New Leftover

JeffR

Member
exMember
Joined
Dec 7, 2005
RO Number
19718
Messages
277
I've found a 2005 leftover (non-titled, but does have a few "demo" hours on it) that fits what we've been looking for in our next boat. What does everyone think is a good starting point for price (What percent of original MSRP, for example)? Also, what are your thoughts on something sitting that long? Any real worries considering it's a dealer boat and will have full factory warranty? It's a gas, I/O powered boat. BTW, I would still plan on getting a complete survey.

Thanks.
 
Jeff, without more specifics of the actual boat...I would expect around 40% off MSRP for an '05 demo.
 
Jeff you left a lot to the imagination here !

I would look art what 2005 boats are going for on the market and start there. It is a used, though never titled boat. I'm sure they are dying to clear it out, so take the buyers market and use it !
 
Yes, I purposely left a lot blank, as it's too easy to be skewed otherwise. I could be mistaken, but I would think that if you look at a percentage basis, whether a 50,000, or 500,000 original price, it would be fairly consistent. (?) Wow, 40%? That seems like a lot, even though it is a 2005, but that's why I'm asking.
 
I would be suprised if they let it go for anything more than 25%
 
Jeff, I'm no expert but I know that you should be able to achieve 20 - 22% off a brand spanking new now '08 model. Definitely 30% off on a close-out '06. So...I don't think 40% is too much of a stretch for an '05 demo. Certainly 35% fits the equation, but again...you leave a lot out, and certain brands will differ. I think percentages do make a difference between 50k or 500K.
 
Ken, this particular brand holds it's value, and I don't think I can find a used '05 for 40% off original MSRP. Like you say, though, it may not be much of a stretch.

Any concerns from anybody regarding the length of time "sitting"?
 
Jeff- 35 - 40% is right on.

As reference:

We bought our leftover '04 at the end of '05 for 30% off msrp.

So, I would expect an '05 could have been had at the end of '06 for 30% off. With another year of sitting, 40% seems like a good goal, with 35% maybe being more realistic.

And forget about brands "holding" their value. A friend recently bought a Formula 37PC and got even more % off the msrp than I did on my boat! If it's a leftover and it's been sitting long, IT'S BECAUSE THEY CAN'T SELL IT! So they need to make you a deal.

Good luck!
 
quote:

Originally posted by JeffR

Any concerns from anybody regarding the length of time "sitting"?





No big concerns mechanically (and I would have the mechanicals surveyed), but if the boat sat outside open in the weather during all this time...then it goes in your favor for even more of a discount.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Britanic

I would be suprised if they let it go for anything more than 25%






Are you serious? If so, and if I ever get into boat sales as a career, I want to sell you a boat!

Here's how I calculate a deal on a new large cruiser or sedan.

Current model year: 25% - 30% off MSRP

Non-Current, 1 Model Year Old: 30% - 35% off MSRP

Non-Current, 2 Model Years Old: 35% - 40% off MSRP

Non-Current, 3 Model Years Old: 40% - 45% off MSRP.

Or better yet, look up the book value for a used 2005 with the same options. Then consider you have to pay sales tax in addition to that price, so subtract that from the sale price. All in all, I think if you can buy it for 45% - 50% off MSRP you'll be good to go.

If they won't cut you a deal like that, then walk away like the others have for the last 3 years.
 
And keep in mind, depending on the brand, dealer cost on a current model year can be as much as 40% off MSRP.
 
Granted, I've never bought a new boat, leftover or otherwise, but that sure seems a little optimistic. In a real world scenario, then, I should be able to buy a $100k "new" boat for $50k, or a $150k "new" boat for $75k? Jason, as an example, I'm guessing that the MSRP for an '05 Cruisers 300/310 Express was in the $140k-$150k range (round numbers)? Do you really think you could buy one for $70-75? For my sake, I hope you are right. I'm not arguing, because I really don't know. But like I said, I have not found a used '05 for the discount you guys are suggesting.
 
I wouldn't worry about it being unused since you are going to get a full survey and it will still be on warranty. Go for it as long as it passes the survey!

RadioguyJ----hey Jason, are you going to change careers??? Maybe become a Cruisers salesmen????? You would probably be good at it!
 
Perhaps I should have read Jeff's question a little more closly. "% off MSRP" or the Bulls#$t price. I just don't consider the MSRP as a legitamant price. So, haven said that 25% off the REAL price is probably close. Case in point 2007 33' larson cabrio MSRP $165,000 - I know I can buy one for under $140,000 never splashed. Take another 25% - $105,000. I really don't think you will get any better than that, regardless of demo hours.
 
Thanks for the input, everybody. I'm signing off for the night...I'll check back in tomorrow.
 
A Cruisers 310 retails for just over $200k if you get the gen, windlass, and other big options. Now, if it was a brand new 2005 300/310, I would expect to pay around $110k - $115k for that, if it's loaded. Our local dealer was selling 2 of the 2005 300/310's in 2006 (1 year old non-currents) and had them both listed at $115k, with no generators. They likely sold for around $110k if I was to guess.

A local dealer here has a brand new leftover 2005 Maxum 3100 Express. That boat had an MSRP of around $140k, I made an offer of $75k, but they wanted around $85k for it rock bottom price. So I walked from the deal. But it proves that those high percentages off MSRP are realistic, depending on the brand, situation, and the dealer's willingness to sell that boat!
 
.........and FWIW, I think surveying a brand new boat is a waste of money. Don't hang me, shoot me, or hate me......it's just my opinion, but if you can test the functions of the boat yourself, and the boat has a stem to stern warranty, save your money for fuel; you'll need it.
 
The reason to survey a new boat is to get the problems fixed before you accept delivary--and they dealer may put you down at the end of the list for repairs in season. Also almost all new boats have defects--and most owners don't pick them up--they come to bit you after the hull warantee has gone. For example--the failure to adequately seal limber holes. The cored decks which are not sealed every place a hole is put in them.

As for mechanical issues--hoses and belts are suspect after 3 years. The water pump impeller has most likely taken a set and should be replaced. I have looked at some 'dealer" 3 year old boats and they were really run down--upholustry stained, "fake" wood dash faded etc.

I think that you all are dreaming that the dealer will give 40% off list price. He has floored that boat (interest costs) for the 3 years. You are buying a boat which is instantly a 3 year old boat if you wanted to resell it--and you will only get low blue--if even that. But I think the dealer will hold out for a higher price--and that is the reason he still has this boat 3 years later!
 
Back
Top