I agree that either boat is good. But where did Four Winns come up?
I have a lot of experience with Chaparral (dealer connection), and have owned a 26 footer. I'm also a frequent acquaintance of the NE factory rep. I think they are on par with Four Winns, and I might give them the slight edge. Many times they're compared against FW, Regal, Crownline and SeaRay. They are a well made boat, with nice components. Like any new boat, you'll have little issues, but overall they're a great boat IMO.
Make sure, however, that whatever you buy, that you are happy with the dealer. That's probably as important, if not more important than the brand of boat when you're comparing 2 brands such as Jason mentioned.