An Observation...Comments?

JohnH

Member
exMember
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
RO Number
1474
Messages
541
This is not meant to be a criticism of the site, merely an observation. Obviously the paticipation in BoaterEd is huge. Generally speaking this would be considered a good thing. Sometimes however, this is a disadvantage to a boater with a valid post, particularly in the ATC forum. With the volume of posts in the ATC forum, posts move down the line extremely fast. So quickly in fact, that members who may have valid input or comments often miss them because they fail to scan down past the first page, probably more eager to get to NBR or the forum of their local area.
Part of the problem, I think, is that many posters fail to place their posts in the proper category, using ATC as the catchall. Ultimately, this practice may fail to get the results or responses they are looking for because of the burying effect in the high volume ATC forum.
In addition, there is plenty of stuff in ATC that probably would be better if not posted at all. Some would say that this post is one of them. I'm ready...what are your thoughts?
 
Just click on "active topics" and you will be taken to all new posts.
 
This should really be in NBR!!

Hey, you asked for it :)
 
John, I think you have a valid point. That is why, if I post a topic and do not get much response, I'll bump it back up to the top a time or two. If that doesn't work, then so be it.
 
Actually, I just scrolled down to the bottom of the page and it goes back 4 days before you have to go to page 2. That seems pretty reasonable. I know there are spurts of activity at certain times of the year, but I like a busy forum where there is lots happening; lots of new posts and just a lot going on in general. It makes things more interesting.

PaulS
 
If we could keep the number of polls down, the legitimate posts wouldn't get buried.
 
I agree but Liz has the answer. Just respond to your own post by saying BUMP and it'll shoot to the to[p of the list.

'Using active page' is ONLY good if every viewer uses it.
 
the active page has nothing to do with anyone else using it. It will show all posts since your last visit. It's all I use.
 
OK, Well, how often do we all click on to boaters ed? I'll admit that I check at least twice a day...once in the afternoon and once in the evening. Shoot, do you think I'm to obsessive?
 
Liz gets the point I was trying to make. Sometimes posts get buried so fast that those who might be the most appropriate to respond might not even see them.
Hence, the need to "bump" if you really need the help.
 
I almost missed this post. Thank goodness I contributed. :)
 
Hogan,
There are many of us using BOATED and we don't have 'active topics'. There are also many who don't know what 'active topics' is. In order for any viewer to see just the 'active topics', they have to click on it.
 
quote:

Originally posted by jtybt15

I agree but Liz has the answer. Just respond to your own post by saying BUMP and it'll shoot to the to[p of the list.





Here's a hint. Go into your post as if you are going to edit it. Then click on Post Changes. That will bump it up to the top again.

Shhhh, don't tell Les. It might p#ss him off!
[}}:-|>>]
 
I am new member. I do not think posts are pushed off the first page too quickly. I have been logging in at least once a day and current postings as well as post several days old are on page 1. I can see the issue if you log in once a week or once a month. Log in every day and there are just a handful of post.
 
Liz:

Great to have you back on the forum!
You haven't missed a step, and still dance with the best of 'em.

"Shhhh, don't tell Les."

You old scheming, conniving, sneaky old ...

Thanks! :D

OS

Edit: Oops! Sorry about the "old" ...
but I really meant "sneaky" ...
 
I missed you too, OS. Yup, sneaky and old and a broad skipper to you.

FB
 
quote:

Originally posted by mandm1200

I am new member. I do not think posts are pushed off the first page too quickly. I have been logging in at least once a day and current postings as well as post several days old are on page 1. I can see the issue if you log in once a week or once a month. Log in every day and there are just a handful of post.






Only ONCE a day! Michael, run, before its to late :)

Stan
 
I agree with your observation, John. I also agree that something has to be done about disadvantaged boaters with a valid post. Things have just gone to hell in a handbag...
 
Back
Top