Anchor Choice

Brian Suhl

Member
exMember
Joined
May 9, 2001
RO Number
4517
Messages
168
The standard anchor on my '06 Silverton 34C was really not heavy duty enough and I bent a fluke. I have been told a Delta style anchor will fit the bow pulpit. What weight or size should I get? I found a polished stainless one on the auction site that is 33lbs. but it sounds big. The boat is now called a 36 and is 40' 6" overall with bow pulpit and swim platform. I usually say it is a 36 foot boat. Dry weight was around 21,000 lbs. if I remember right.
 
I just put a 35 lbs. Delta on a 37' Sedan Bridge - 42.5' LOA at 14k dry (Thanks to advice from Pascal). We were stuck at anchor for 3 days in winds up to 50 kts. Due to tight anchorage in our "hidey hole", I only had enough room for a 6 to 1 scope in 6' of water. Sandy bottom with no grass. The anchor held like a champ and didn't budge an inch after swingin 360 degrees in a 72 hour hard blow. I'm pretty sure our former 22lb. Danforth would have left us aground. I've used the anchor 6 times since new and it sets "right now". Just don't drop your chain on it if you have a free drop windlass or you'll be a "do over" candidate.

The only downside I've heard for this anchor is that it doesn't do as well in mud. The good news for us is that there's no mud in our future (that we're aware of)!
 
I have the Danforth Hi-tensile 35H anchor on my 38' boat. According to them, it will hold a 64' boat in 20kt winds.

My belief is more is better when it comes to ground tackle. Get the biggest one you can fit.
 
i agree with two of the above comments first get the biggest that will fit and a ton will depend on your ground tackle. my boat weights in at 14k dry according to the manufacturer however i know it is way heavier with the equipmetn i have added, probably closer to 20k total.

i run 35lb delta with 90 feet of chain. i never, never lose sleep. i have actually held three boats (sea ray 370ac, cruisers 420 express, and mine) in a 40+ knt blow.

bottom line is if you anchor and want to sleep well you can never have to heavy of ground tackle.

personally i stay away from danforth or fluke style anchors for anything more then an oversized storm anchor. when you spin on them they tend to have a hard time reseting.
 
The first thing to consider when anchoring is what the bottom is. If you moor at different locations with different bottoms, you may need to swap anchors. I tend to place it safe and get the next size larger. My boat is 28'+ LOA, 6400lbs and I use a high tensile Danforth, somewhere around 20 lbs. There are vast differences in Danforth anchors. The cheapies aren't worth a dime due to their metal composition. Chromeolly is waht you should look for, very high strentgth. I anchor in sand with some mud at times. I had one experience that tested it. We were hit with a microburst with winds estimated by the National Weather Service at over 100 mph. Was I a little scared? Sure. It's been the only time I wore a life vest on the boat. I was fully prepared to go into the water for myself or family. Visibility was zero. The only good thing was it only lasted a few minutes. Trees less that 50 yards away were snapped, a half a dozen boats were turned over. When I finaly pulled up the anchor later that evening, an old lawn chair was attached. Maybe it helped but I doubt it. Bottom line is that I feel real comfortable with a Danforth where I boat. I have ridden many a storm with it.
 
I just purchased a Fortress fx 23 from Boatfix.
I hope it holds in weeds and mud.
My boat has a lot of windage
 
Bert, FXs hold very well in mud but dont' do very well in grass. The problem with danforth is that they dont' reset well on a shift, they need to be pulled out, cleaned and re set.

a 23 is a little smallish for a 38 footer, personally i'd rather have the next size up. My Fx55 is also on the smallish side although it holds very well so i maybe a little over cautious.

indeed there is no such a thing as a perfect anchor... i recently had an 88 Delta fail to set twice in the same spot (mud) my FX55 sets and hold almost everyweek. It set fine 100 yards away... denser mud maybe, or the two failures were a fluke.

I'm seriously considering a 110lbs High Tensile Bruce, does anyone have experience with Bruces? how do they do in grass and mud? most tests are often mixed... the nice thing about the 110 Bruce is the price, about $300. vs $560 for a delta 88.
 
quote:

Originally posted by PascalG

Bert, FXs hold very well in mud but dont' do very well in grass. The problem with danforth is that they dont' reset well on a shift, they need to be pulled out, cleaned and re set.

a 23 is a little smallish for a 38 footer, personally i'd rather have the next size up. My Fx55 is also on the smallish side although it holds very well so i maybe a little over cautious.

indeed there is no such a thing as a perfect anchor... i recently had an 88 Delta fail to set twice in the same spot (mud) my FX55 sets and hold almost everyweek. It set fine 100 yards away... denser mud maybe, or the two failures were a fluke.

I'm seriously considering a 110lbs High Tensile Bruce, does anyone have experience with Bruces? how do they do in grass and mud? most tests are often mixed... the nice thing about the 110 Bruce is the price, about $300. vs $560 for a delta 88.






Pascal,

I don't have experience with the Bruce, but all of the heavier (45'+) deep keel boats in our marina seem to have them as a primary. Most of them also have a "claw" type for a secondary with the remainder carrying a large fortress as a storm anchor.

I spoke with most of these folks about their anchor choices and it seems the long range cruisers (deep Caribbean) have the Bruce. There's one couple who claim to have cruised 33,000 miles in 22 years who use a 55# bruce on a 40' sailboat exclusively. They carry a HUGE (wieght unknown) Fortress tht looks brand new.

Hope that offers some insight-
 
Brian
I believe the Danforth is a good anchor for the Mississippi mud, unless you get in an area where there is a large amount of rocks that can wedge between the flukes or in an extremely weedy area. The trick is to get at least the largest anchor your windlass is capable of handling. or add chain. Adding chain will add several lbs per foot of chain (how much depends on the chain size). I suspect for your boat it may be as much as 8 lbs per foot. Add 50 ft of chain at the anchor end of your rode will help keep the shank parallel to the bottom and give a straight pull that helps to keep the shanks set. 50 x 8 = 350 lbs laying on the bottom and thats a lot of anchoring power!
 
35 lb in the Delta is a good choice for that size boat. Be careful; the standard Lewmar genuine Delta Quick set, is only available in Galvanized high tensil steel. Many of the SS anchors are Taiwan or Chinese knock offs. Generally they have not been as successful as the genuine articles. Bruce are no longer being made in recreational boat sizes. There are copies available--they may not be as good as the origional. We have always carried a number of different types of anchors for the different types of bottoms. There are many choices. For mud, The Supermax is excellent, as is the Fortress--for your size boat Supermax at 44 lbs and Fortress FX 37 (this is oversize). Other newer anchors are excellent: Ronca, Manson Supreme(simlar to Ronca--cheaper and I found them to be very good in some recent tests we did), & Spade.

We cruised a total of 8 years and over 80,000 miles--using 60 lb CQR on boats from 18 to 30 tons. Back ups included 150 lb fisherman, 70 lb fisherman, 40 and 70 lb Danforth and a second 45 lb CQR. I like the Delta better than the CQR, but in hard bottoms once these set, they are awesome. We have held in sustained winds of 90 knots. Avoid cheap imitations perticularly of the Danforth.--The High Tensil Danforth and West Marine Performance anchors of the simlar size as Fortress work equally as well. Both the Fortress and Danforth can "sail" once they come out of the bottom, or in deployment.
 
Back
Top