Another Wake Discussion

rnbenton

Active member
Member
Joined
Apr 4, 2009
RO Number
31163
Messages
2,834
Location: ICW just south of Crescent Beach, FL. Fairly narrow but well marked channel. No speed limit.

Vessel #1: South bound 47' Bertram SF running cruise speed casting, estimated only, 4' wake. 4 pax.

Vessel #2: North bound 17' bass boat running cruise speed. 2 pax.

Incident: As the distance between vessel #1 and vessel #2 diminished, vessel #2 came off plane to what was reported to be headway speed because of the approaching wake. Vessel #1 maintained his speed, did not slow. Upon striking the first wake vessel #2 was thrown into the air and then struck the second wake bow down. Vessel #2 took a substantial amount of water over the bow pretty much filling it with water. Passenger in vessel #2 was thrown from the boat, luckily, wearing a life vest and was able to re-board the boat. Vessel #2's engine was disabled and the boat was partially submerged.

Vessel #1 kept going but was identified by another boater and the incident was reported to the USCG and FWC.

Opinions: Was vessel #1 responsible and liable?

This is an actual incident that took place yesterday. I did not witness the incident but arrived shortly after and saw vessel #2 still partially submerged, several other boats on the scene rendering assistance. Claims were made of attempts to contact Vessel #1 by radio but no response.

As a side note, I was also south bound in the ICW and was passed by vessel #1 about 30 minutes earlier. I was running 7.5" kts, vessel passed on my port side, full speed, no horn or radio contact. His wake rocked my 28' Voyager fairly violently knocking a lot of stuff off of the dinnette table and galley cabinet and really pi$$ing off the Admiral, but no damage.

Bob

PS: As another side note, I make no claims about the facts of the incident. Since I did not witness it I am only restating what I was told by others who did witness it.
 
Operator of vessel #1 is an inconsiderate ASS. You should post the vessel name so that others know to watch out for him/her.
 
I don't think I've ever seen any size boat come out of the water at headway speed. But regardless of fault, every boater needs to learn how to take a wake with minimum impact because there are lots of idiots out there with big boats. You need to slow down, keep as much distance between your vessel and the other as possible, and turn into the wake, taking it at about 45 degrees.
 
Legally responsible? I don't think so. Inconsiderate? Yes. The smaller boat could have, should have taken action like slowing way down before he hit the wake and he probably would have been fine. What's cruise speed for a bass boat? Around here it's about 50 mph and that's way to fast to hit a large wake.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Gregory Saracco

Legally responsible? I don't think so. Inconsiderate? Yes. The smaller boat could have, should have taken action like slowing way down before he hit the wake and he probably would have been fine. What's cruise speed for a bass boat? Around here it's about 50 mph and that's way to fast to hit a large wake.






Well, as stated in the OP, I was told he slowed to "headway speed". Don't know, didn't see it, but that's what a witness told me.
 
You should report the guy as well for your incident. Then let the CG and FWC sort it out. If nothing else, the hassle from the LEAs might cause the guy to change his behavior. Seeing the small boat and continuing to throw that wake can be interpreted as willful endangerment. Rule 2(a) covers this situation. We always put out a "Securite" warning when we come across one of these jerks, though as long as we are paying proper attention and able to maneuver into the wake, or with the stabilizers on, they have no effect on us. We once had the pleasure of finding one pulled over a few miles on down the ICW.

George
Hatteras 56MY
 
While the offending vessel (vessel #1) was certainly inconsiderate at minimum, I agree with Les and GS as well. Vessel #2, the bass boat, should have done something very different than what was done.

Nobody is going to take care of you on the water - a boater has to watch out for himself. A boater can't count on some inconsiderate person to come off plane to prevent an incident/accident.

I certainly don't mean that you have to wake someone before being waked or anything of the sort. I mean that a captain needs to take care of his boat and his crew. If a big wake is coming - and one can usually see it coming at some distance - take the necessary precautions. You just gotta do what you gotta do to take care of your boat and crew. Sometimes it is just inconvenient but necessary. Otherwise be prepared for consequences.

Too few people anticipate what may happen next while driving a car or operating a boat. This is especially true for anticipating a wake. If you wait for something to happen, it just maybe too late.

I feel bad for the bass boat but believe that if properly handled it could have avoided the worst case. A person thrown overboard at headway speed? I just wonder where that person was in the boat, was the person seated or standing, was the person on one of the fishing seats on the front or rear platform? Subsequently I also question whether it was really headway speed.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Mackeral Hunter

While the offending vessel (vessel #1) was certainly inconsiderate at minimum, I agree with Les and GS as well. Vessel #2, the bass boat, should have done something very different than what was done.





OK, for discussion sake, what should he have done? As stated in the OP, I was told he slowed down to "headway speed". Also, as stated, the waterway in that area is fairly narrow so it's not like he had any place to run and hide.

Since he took the second wake over the bow, I have to assume he turned into the wake to begin with. I don't know that he did because I didn't see it happen but I am also not going to assume he didn't.

So, what else could he have done differently?

I am not trying to be agumentative at all. I'm just interested in the discussion and offered opinions.

Bob
 
It seems to me that vessel 2 had to of seen vessel 1 come out of water and then plow into water and ofcourse see passenger overboard. Correct me if I am wrong but isn't there a rule about leaving a boat in distress.
 
we have to deal often with this running poker runs boat 2 is at fault for not being prepared or changing course to better deal with the wake you should see the rollers a ship in the st lawrence can leave its not the ships fault if we miss time or underestimate it. the first timers even though they have been warned in the drivers meetings often blow by us as we slow and turn to cross at a 45 degree angle so as not to stuff its always the third wave that does you in the first bumps you up in the air the second is like a ski jump the third is the one you hit from landing deep in the trough a wall of water goes over you and the sudden stop can hurt
 
OK...let's say there is a big Ocean Liner coming down the narrow channel of the Delaware River...pretty far up river where it really narrows up...... at cruising speed. It's a 'no speed limit' zone. And, let's say that a smallish 20 something foot bow rider is running the opposite direction in the channel. Let's say it's a very calm day....other than the wake from the two boats, the water is like jello. What should the Ocean Liner do....slow to 'no wake' speed?
 
Bob, I don't think anyone is trying to be argumentative. But Mackeral is dead on. It is every boater's responsibility to operate his or her vessel in a manner that will not endanger the vessel or passengers. I've run into this situation a few dozen times in North Palm Beach with meetings of large sport fish doing 25 knots and it was always a pain. I'd have to come off plane, slow way down, get as far right as possible, and then judge my entry into the wake to minimize the effect. As I said earlier, I've seen a lot of 17' boats in this same situation and never saw one become airborne. That fact alone would lead me to speculate that the bass boat was going way too fast. The fact that a passenger was tossed from the boat would lead me to believe that the passenger wasn't warned of the wake. Granted, my boat had lots of bow freeboard and a foredeck because, unlike a bass boat, was designed to handle larger waves. Bass boats are not blue water boats.

But, as noted above, it doesn't matter who was at fault. None of us saw exactly what happened. The lesson to be learned here is how to avoid that problem yourself.
 
Bob I don't see any thing argumentative here. Just some lively discussion. Crossing a 4' wave in a bass boat with another large wave or two following certainly presents problems that the bass boat wasn't designed to handle. First thing a captain needs to do is ensure that his/her boat will handle all conditions met on a trip. If it won't handle the conditions on a planned trip, the trip should be aborted. A large wake from sportfishers, large cruisers and other big boats in the ICW isn't unusual. Counting on large boats to always look out for the little guys is making a very dangerous assumption.

Given the fact that the bass boat had no choice but to cross the wake - the angle of attack, speed and the distance from the stern of the boat producing the wake all make a difference. Crossing a wake perpendicular certainly increases the chance of punching the bow of a boat through the next wave. Speed over the first wave often determines where you "land on/in the next wave". Crossing a wake at too oblique an angle presents the possibility of capsize.

None of us saw the accident so it is very hard to judge what should have happened in this case. Evidently, some thing different should have been done.

There was no mention of the length of the bass boat. Dependent upon the length of the bass boat it could easily land between the waves and take the second wave over the bow.

Please don't misunderstand vessel #1 bears some responsibility too - vessel #1 should have been courteous and responsible in the first place. Vessel #1 probably never looked back.
 
I have a hard time believing vessel 1 didn't look back just because when the bass boat came out of the water it made a distinctive sound.I also believe vessel 2 was very careless in handleing the situation.
 
There is no way I am slowing down for every or any boat coming in the opposite direction. If It is an area where you are allowed to run your boat , you run your boat. I also don't slow down for the fisherman who love to block the channel and many times will gather near a marker making it hard to locate that marker. I have a 16 footer as well , and I don't expect any vessel in a channel to slow down just cause I am there.

Regarding looking back to see the results of my wake on another boat, occasionally at best. I can pass hundreds of boats on a weekend run, and I am not looking behind me, I am looking forward . Come on with this crap of boater 1 is an Ass. Seems like everyone wants to be pissed off at a boat wake on this board.

No wake zone, absolutely.

wake zone , all bets are off!
 
billyb, you make my point clearly. Everyone has to ensure they are taking care of themselves. If it is not a no wake zone with no speed limit, then small boats should anticipate that the big boys and girls are going to run at rates that will produce wakes. I don't expect you to do anything else. IF you DO slow down for small boats that might be impacted seriously by your wake, then it is to your credit. I don't operate my 23 footer expecting every 47 footer to creep along just because I am there. If every big boat on the ICW slowed to no wake for every small boat, the big boats wouldn't ever get to their destination. For alot of them time is money.

Would it have been considerate for the 47 footer to slow down to no wake speed for the bass boat? Yes.

We don't know if the bass boat was operating responsibly or not - I am suspicious of bass boats.

A bass boat on the ICW has a right to be there - just like I have a right to bungee jump or jump out of a perfectly good airplane with a silk sheet attached to my back.

As for looking back, a 47' Bertram with two diesels running, stereo or TV operating, VHF on, 4 passengers conversing, and who knows what else going -- probably didn't look back -- just my opinion.
 
I don't know what the actual circumstances were in the OP's scenario but I will say that a blanket statement like "There is no way I am slowing down for every or any boat coming in the opposite direction" is a bit worrisome. Its easy to declare that here on a boating forum, but if someone was injured, swamped or capsized due to your wake even if the fault was shared, that’s not the explanation I would recommend telling the Coast Guard or LEO who arrives at the scene.
 
quote:

Originally posted by billybokay

...... I also don't slow down for the fisherman who love to block the channel and many times will gather near a marker making it hard to locate that marker. .........
........





You mean like this.....
IMG_0420-1.jpg


or this......

IMG_0423.jpg


happens all the time around here!!!!
 
I do all my boating in a "narrow channel" called the Ohio River. We seem to have more than our share of bass boats around here as you can imagine. I slow down to no wake speed for every marina or dock that I pass as my 34 Convertible throws a large wake at cruise speeds. I do not routinely slow down for oncoming boats though and I don't believe I am responsible for the wake they get from my passage. Am I wrong here?????
 
Greg. I believe you are correct ... legally you are not responsibe and I don't expect anyone to slow down when I am approching ... I am confident that I can handle my boat in any situation that may be caused by a wake. On the other hand a coupe of weeks ago my grandson & I were coming back to the marina ... I was running my usual 3600 cruise RPM. There was a yong couple drift fishing (not realy a channel) I pulled the power back and passed them at idle speed .. did I have to ... no, but at the time it was the right thing to do. We got a friendly wave and smile from them ... that's what boating is all about in my opinion.
 
Back
Top