Vern, I believe the 21'er would be fine with a 150 to 200 hp engine. I think the 23'er will need the 225. You wont notice the extra weight of the 4 stroke engine because the boat floats high in the stern any way. The last 3 digits of my HID are 86, making it an 86. The number doesn't reference the length.
Having read countless articles on mid 80s boats, you need to be very careful. Check the following:
1) Transom, stringer or deck rot.
2) Fuel tank leaks.
3) Engine shot.
4) Bad Hatches or windows.
5) Loose hard top.
6) Bad electrical (THis is critical)
Any of the above will set you back a long time.
Things like electrical can cost thousands to replace. Please take a look at the other 21 and 23' Trophies on the market, all of them less than the cost of a Honda 225.
You might offer them $1000, if it's sound.
The following picture shows my 21'er floating high with a OMC/GM 5.0 and two batteries aboard.
Even simple things like hoses can be bad:
I have a link to my photo album, showing all the gory details of my repower. It took approximately 35 days of hard work.
http://www.baylinerownersclub.org/gallery/album480