- Joined
- Jan 1, 2000
- RO Number
- 3238
- Messages
- 4,831
I started a new thread so as not to interfere with the thread on Capt Art's loss.
--------------------------------
Determining how much your bilge pump can be expected to pump in actual emergency conditions is important. This is especially true because the literature makes the determination difficult, and it tends to give answers that are not directly usable.
For reference here is a link to the Johnson L1600. Though I prefer a Rule pump, I was unable to access a spec sheet easily on the internet ( note to mfgr: Publish or perish )
1) What is the stated/rated GPH of the pump?
This is the number that is usually offered, and it is commonly given as GPH, Gallons per Hour. They use that unit of measure because big numbers sell well. But we nee something we can imagine, so convert that to Gallons per minute. in this case that means 1600/60 = about 27 gallons per minute ( GPM )
2) The pump is rated ( usually ) at "no-head" meaning it does not pump upward at all. In the real world, this means a head of a few feet or more. Johnson gives a handy chart on their easy to access specs, so I will look it up and get: with a 4 ft head, the pump will deliver 17 GPM.
3) Unless the test conditions are stated in the spec sheet, you can expect that they ran the pump at 12V to 14.7V to achieve that number. But, you will be using the pump under high load conditions so figure 11V, and down-rate the pump. I use 60% of rated flow due to low operating voltage. That means 17 GPM X 0.6 = about 10.2 GPM
4) The output hose will also cause a reduction in flow rate. Assuming a smooth bore ( never use corrugated hose!!! ) hose, that is very straight has not turns, kinks or mud-dauber nests you will lose at least a few percent. In practice, you will have a misshapen spot, a few dips and curves plus the loop near the outlet end. This means that you can easily justify yet-another-down-rate of around 20%. ie: 10.2 GPM x 0.8 = 8.16 GPM. ( aka: 489.6 GPH )
I have just shown that what you might expect to be a 1600 GPH pump can only be expected to provide 490 GPH in practice. ie: total system performance is slightly less than one-third of the rated capacity.
By the way: I an NOT taking a shot at Johnson pumps. ( Thank you again for posting your specs on the internet ). These calculations will affect ALL 12V DC BILGE PUMPS, regardless of make.
---
What does this mean?
First, in a frenzy of saving pennies in foolish areas, most boat mfgrs install a pump that a) has the word "bilge" in the name, and meets the absolute minimum required by the current standards. These pumps are tiny. I am not sure what they are good for, but they won't keep you afloat.
Second, bilge pumps, in most cases should not be expected to keep you afloat. At least, not in "smaller" boats, say up to around 35 ft or so. What they CAN do is to prevent sinking from small issues, like leaky hatches and a rain storm. They can give you added minutes to find/correct leaks, or to call for help and abandon ship. Increasing the total pumping capacity can give you added minutes when you most need them. ( Note: up to your battery capacity, which is limited! These pumps will not do this forever... )
---------
SO. What to do?
First, inspect and test all of your current bilge pumps. Determine the rated capacity, divide that by 3 then decide if this capacity make you comfortable enough. If you have stock pumps, it should make you shiver.
Second, decide just how much capacity you actually want. That is, real, actual, in the heat of the storm pumping capacity. Then build a system that will deliver that capacity.
---------
Alarms and signals.
You can buy a 12V LED indicator fixture for only a few $ each ( or less ). Easy to install and it will illuminate whenever the pump is ON. Get one for each and every pump.
Install a high water alarm. Buy one pre-designed, or you can use a float switch and a loud buzzer/beeper/siren wired to the float. Up to you.
------------------
I am not a "pro". These are the numbers I use. I welcome any and all who understand these systems better than I to shoot my numbers and ideas down in flames. Whatever you do, think about this, and carefully decide just exactly what you expect of this system, then do the research and set up a system that will meet those goals. I really HATE IT when I hear about a boat that did not return to the dock. I work very hard to ensure that my boat is not one of them. So should you...
--------------------------------
Determining how much your bilge pump can be expected to pump in actual emergency conditions is important. This is especially true because the literature makes the determination difficult, and it tends to give answers that are not directly usable.
For reference here is a link to the Johnson L1600. Though I prefer a Rule pump, I was unable to access a spec sheet easily on the internet ( note to mfgr: Publish or perish )
1) What is the stated/rated GPH of the pump?
This is the number that is usually offered, and it is commonly given as GPH, Gallons per Hour. They use that unit of measure because big numbers sell well. But we nee something we can imagine, so convert that to Gallons per minute. in this case that means 1600/60 = about 27 gallons per minute ( GPM )
2) The pump is rated ( usually ) at "no-head" meaning it does not pump upward at all. In the real world, this means a head of a few feet or more. Johnson gives a handy chart on their easy to access specs, so I will look it up and get: with a 4 ft head, the pump will deliver 17 GPM.
3) Unless the test conditions are stated in the spec sheet, you can expect that they ran the pump at 12V to 14.7V to achieve that number. But, you will be using the pump under high load conditions so figure 11V, and down-rate the pump. I use 60% of rated flow due to low operating voltage. That means 17 GPM X 0.6 = about 10.2 GPM
4) The output hose will also cause a reduction in flow rate. Assuming a smooth bore ( never use corrugated hose!!! ) hose, that is very straight has not turns, kinks or mud-dauber nests you will lose at least a few percent. In practice, you will have a misshapen spot, a few dips and curves plus the loop near the outlet end. This means that you can easily justify yet-another-down-rate of around 20%. ie: 10.2 GPM x 0.8 = 8.16 GPM. ( aka: 489.6 GPH )
I have just shown that what you might expect to be a 1600 GPH pump can only be expected to provide 490 GPH in practice. ie: total system performance is slightly less than one-third of the rated capacity.
By the way: I an NOT taking a shot at Johnson pumps. ( Thank you again for posting your specs on the internet ). These calculations will affect ALL 12V DC BILGE PUMPS, regardless of make.
---
What does this mean?
First, in a frenzy of saving pennies in foolish areas, most boat mfgrs install a pump that a) has the word "bilge" in the name, and meets the absolute minimum required by the current standards. These pumps are tiny. I am not sure what they are good for, but they won't keep you afloat.
Second, bilge pumps, in most cases should not be expected to keep you afloat. At least, not in "smaller" boats, say up to around 35 ft or so. What they CAN do is to prevent sinking from small issues, like leaky hatches and a rain storm. They can give you added minutes to find/correct leaks, or to call for help and abandon ship. Increasing the total pumping capacity can give you added minutes when you most need them. ( Note: up to your battery capacity, which is limited! These pumps will not do this forever... )
---------
SO. What to do?
First, inspect and test all of your current bilge pumps. Determine the rated capacity, divide that by 3 then decide if this capacity make you comfortable enough. If you have stock pumps, it should make you shiver.
Second, decide just how much capacity you actually want. That is, real, actual, in the heat of the storm pumping capacity. Then build a system that will deliver that capacity.
---------
Alarms and signals.
You can buy a 12V LED indicator fixture for only a few $ each ( or less ). Easy to install and it will illuminate whenever the pump is ON. Get one for each and every pump.
Install a high water alarm. Buy one pre-designed, or you can use a float switch and a loud buzzer/beeper/siren wired to the float. Up to you.
------------------
I am not a "pro". These are the numbers I use. I welcome any and all who understand these systems better than I to shoot my numbers and ideas down in flames. Whatever you do, think about this, and carefully decide just exactly what you expect of this system, then do the research and set up a system that will meet those goals. I really HATE IT when I hear about a boat that did not return to the dock. I work very hard to ensure that my boat is not one of them. So should you...