Bilge pump size

Radioactive

Well-known member
Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
RO Number
3238
Messages
4,831
I started a new thread so as not to interfere with the thread on Capt Art's loss.

--------------------------------

Determining how much your bilge pump can be expected to pump in actual emergency conditions is important. This is especially true because the literature makes the determination difficult, and it tends to give answers that are not directly usable.

For reference here is a link to the Johnson L1600. Though I prefer a Rule pump, I was unable to access a spec sheet easily on the internet ( note to mfgr: Publish or perish )

1) What is the stated/rated GPH of the pump?

This is the number that is usually offered, and it is commonly given as GPH, Gallons per Hour. They use that unit of measure because big numbers sell well. But we nee something we can imagine, so convert that to Gallons per minute. in this case that means 1600/60 = about 27 gallons per minute ( GPM )

2) The pump is rated ( usually ) at "no-head" meaning it does not pump upward at all. In the real world, this means a head of a few feet or more. Johnson gives a handy chart on their easy to access specs, so I will look it up and get: with a 4 ft head, the pump will deliver 17 GPM.

3) Unless the test conditions are stated in the spec sheet, you can expect that they ran the pump at 12V to 14.7V to achieve that number. But, you will be using the pump under high load conditions so figure 11V, and down-rate the pump. I use 60% of rated flow due to low operating voltage. That means 17 GPM X 0.6 = about 10.2 GPM

4) The output hose will also cause a reduction in flow rate. Assuming a smooth bore ( never use corrugated hose!!! ) hose, that is very straight has not turns, kinks or mud-dauber nests you will lose at least a few percent. In practice, you will have a misshapen spot, a few dips and curves plus the loop near the outlet end. This means that you can easily justify yet-another-down-rate of around 20%. ie: 10.2 GPM x 0.8 = 8.16 GPM. ( aka: 489.6 GPH )

I have just shown that what you might expect to be a 1600 GPH pump can only be expected to provide 490 GPH in practice. ie: total system performance is slightly less than one-third of the rated capacity.

By the way: I an NOT taking a shot at Johnson pumps. ( Thank you again for posting your specs on the internet ). These calculations will affect ALL 12V DC BILGE PUMPS, regardless of make.

---

What does this mean?

First, in a frenzy of saving pennies in foolish areas, most boat mfgrs install a pump that a) has the word "bilge" in the name, and meets the absolute minimum required by the current standards. These pumps are tiny. I am not sure what they are good for, but they won't keep you afloat.

Second, bilge pumps, in most cases should not be expected to keep you afloat. At least, not in "smaller" boats, say up to around 35 ft or so. What they CAN do is to prevent sinking from small issues, like leaky hatches and a rain storm. They can give you added minutes to find/correct leaks, or to call for help and abandon ship. Increasing the total pumping capacity can give you added minutes when you most need them. ( Note: up to your battery capacity, which is limited! These pumps will not do this forever... )

---------

SO. What to do?

First, inspect and test all of your current bilge pumps. Determine the rated capacity, divide that by 3 then decide if this capacity make you comfortable enough. If you have stock pumps, it should make you shiver.

Second, decide just how much capacity you actually want. That is, real, actual, in the heat of the storm pumping capacity. Then build a system that will deliver that capacity.

---------

Alarms and signals.

You can buy a 12V LED indicator fixture for only a few $ each ( or less ). Easy to install and it will illuminate whenever the pump is ON. Get one for each and every pump.

Install a high water alarm. Buy one pre-designed, or you can use a float switch and a loud buzzer/beeper/siren wired to the float. Up to you.

------------------

I am not a "pro". These are the numbers I use. I welcome any and all who understand these systems better than I to shoot my numbers and ideas down in flames. Whatever you do, think about this, and carefully decide just exactly what you expect of this system, then do the research and set up a system that will meet those goals. I really HATE IT when I hear about a boat that did not return to the dock. I work very hard to ensure that my boat is not one of them. So should you...
 
I might add that that high water alarm should be powered independently of your ships batteries.
 
Bill, excellent and thought provoking information.

I also like the idea mentioned in Art's thread about a separate power supply in the bow or forward area and a back up pump.

Plus I like the idea of a portable, pre-wired emergency pump that can be delpoyed in an emergency.

Question: The USCG has a gas powered emergency pump they will drop in some cases of emergency. Does anyone know the name, model or where one can be purchased? I've seen them work and they are really impressive.

Bob
 
There are darn few bilge pumps that will keep you afloat if you suffer damage, but they may buy you enough time to do some repairs. This is where the alarms come in; often if you can get to the problem early enough you can control it. However if it's under 4' of water by the time you find out you're outta luck.

My high-water alarm goes off with about 4" of water in the engine room; the auto-alarm siren is loud enough to wake me AND the neighbors. There's a sensor in every compartment.
 
I'm glad you brought this up. I was getting alerted by other members here to this in another thread I had started in the plumbing section about my fresh water tanks. So I decided that this past weekend I spend some quality time in the bilge to try and learn what I need to know about the bilge system. As I am still very new to this, I ask you guys to help me evaluate my needs.

In my 35' CHB trawler (Senator brand) there are two pumps and a high-water alarm. One pump is a Sahara S1100. It's an automatic but can be activated with a breaker in the electric panel. The other is a Rule 2000 with a separate float switch located about 6" higher than the Sahara. Three inches above that, the high-water alarm is a float switch with a very rude tweeter alarm located up on the flybridge. All three I cleaned and tested this weekend and they all seem to work. However, I did not test them for flow rate.

From what I can tell, they are both located at the lowest part of the bilge. As noted by the ever present 1" body of water. There is another portion of the bilge near the stuffing box that I assume is a little higher and might be a good place to put a monster third pump. It's also near the shower sump and FW tanks and there are a couple of gently used thru-hull cocks I might be able to use as an output until I can dedicate one to the task.

Any opinions and thoughts?
 
One thing I disagree on the OP assumption is that the voltage will drop to 11 volts. If the engine is runnig, I would expect closer to 13 volts. Most DC electrical systems are set up to drop less than 10% of the voltage across the wires. Better planning and wiring will drop less than 5%. It would be interesting to have some actual voltage measurements at the pump while it is in operation under load.
Another thing to keep in mind is that as the water level builds up in the bilge, the more the pump will flow. Call me crazy!. Once the water level in the bilge is at the same level and the thru hull for the pump, the lift is now zero. No, I am not going to fill my bilge with 18"-24" of water to see if this is true.
If using corrugated tubing, it would be advisable to go 15%-25% larger than smooth wall. That should eliminate the resistance versus smoothed walled tubing.
 
As to how much capacity is "right", only you can tell. Since it is so unlikely that you will actually prevent a sinking ( in the event of a major issue ), the issue is more of "how much time do you want".

I can tell you that I had a 27ft deep-V type hull, with little available volume in the bilge. The boat was delivered with two pumps having a total rated capacity of 1000GPH. ( true cap was therefore about 330GPH ). I upgraded to three pumps, with a true capacity of over 3500GPH. If the boat had gotten a hole in the hull, then, for a brief time, I would have looked like an inverted Niagra Falls. But it was enough to give me time to either patch, or to notify then bail-out.

Since the main issue here is "time" the issue of alarms is an important one. The sooner you are informed of a potential problem, the more time you will have to resolve the issue ( and the more likely you are to be able to find and stuff something into the hole! ) Alarms and pumps work together to provide a proper system.

In the fwiw department, One (1) cubic ft = 7.5 gallons. This may help you in making the decision.
 
mandm1200: "If the engine is running"

This is a big assumption. You are correct about the voltage, IF the engine(s) are running. You should not make the assumption that they will be, because it is quite possible that whatever caused the hole, also caused issues with the engine(s). In sizing the pumping system, size then as thogh they were a "stand-alone" system. Then, if you DO have working engines, you will have a well-above minimums pump system, but the pumps will still be enough even without the engines. Otherwise, if, for whatever reason, you need "full capacity pumping", but have no operable engines, you are sunk. Literally and quickly. That is why I down-rate for low voltage. The "sizing problem" calls for a "worst case" analysis. No engines is the assumption in the worst case.

--

"If using corrugated tubing, it would be advisable to go 15%-25% larger than smooth wall. That should eliminate the resistance versus smoothed walled tubing."

It is better to use smooth-bore in the first place. Note that smooth bore is usually what is recommended by pump mfgrs, and they also usually specifically state that ribbed/corrugated hose should not be used. The point is, do it right in the first place, rather than depending on a work-around from the beginning. Using the correct hose is not much more expensive that the cheap stuff.
 
The CG pump that you asked about is a P-6. i don't know how to obtain one.
The CG-P6 dewatering pump is used primarily for emergency dewatering of
vessels in danger of sinking. The CG-P6 model has a rated output of 250
gallons per minute at a 12-foot suction lift. Under load this pump will
dewater for approximately 4 to 5 hours on the gasoline supplied with the kit.
 
Saying if I wanna add another pump to my bilge, can I just "T" the discharge hose to the original outlet one at the very end of the hose without cutting another hole to my boat?. If the rated capacity "drops" as you described above due to "head/no head" and the curve of the hose, smooth bore/corrugated hoses and voltage drops....., I would think the size of the original outlet would be sufficient for both pumps. Your though.
 
quote:

Originally posted by DeeVee

Saying if I wanna add another pump to my bilge, can I just "T" the discharge hose to the original outlet one at the very end of the hose without cutting another hole to my boat?. If the rated capacity "drops" as you described above due to "head/no head" and the curve of the hose, smooth bore/corrugated hoses and voltage drops....., I would think the size of the original outlet would be sufficient for both pumps. Your though.






Two problems:
Pumps can fight each other and output is drastically reduced. Or, you can pump out of one pump into the bilge of the other. There is no check valve in the system (and there shouldn't be).
 
I may not got my question clear but I though if the rated cap. was 1600 GPH at the pump, and after all the restriction/blockage/voltage...., it's only get 1/3 of it GPH comes out at the outlet, so if the outlet was rated for a 1600 GHP pump but only gets 1/3 of it flow thru, I'd think adding another 1/3 of the flow from another pump wouldn't be a problem, they both not sharing a same hose, only using same outlet at the end of the boat.
 
Still not a good idea. Keep your systems separate. Any tees, check valves, etc will reduce your flow even further.

Some time ago I came across a pump that mounted on the propeller shaft. It spun whenever the shaft was turning; if there was water, it pumped. Can't find it online though.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Robbins29

The CG pump that you asked about is a P-6. i don't know how to obtain one.
The CG-P6 dewatering pump is used primarily for emergency dewatering of
vessels in danger of sinking. The CG-P6 model has a rated output of 250
gallons per minute at a 12-foot suction lift. Under load this pump will
dewater for approximately 4 to 5 hours on the gasoline supplied with the kit.






That's the one I'm talking about. I saw one in action once and it was truely impressive as to how much water it will pump. I'm going to look around and, if I can find where to get them and the cost I will post it.

One other thing I am doing is, in my boat I have anough room to raise my batteries about 8". In doing that, in the case of flooding I would be able to keep power longer and run my pumps longer to buy time.

Bob
 
RE: "T" in outlet line

Not a good idea as stated above. You can end up simply moving water about the boat, rather than moving water out of the boat, plus, the whole idea is to keep restrictions out of the flow path. These pumps are not designed to produce pressure, just a relatively high flow rate. Any increase in outlet pressure greatly decreases flow rate.

----

On raising the battery

From the standpoint of increasing the time before the battery floods, it is a good idea. The catch ( there is always a catch ), is that batteries are heavy, and you are raising the boats center of gravity... Depending on the boat and battery, 8" might not be important, but in some boats raising this much weight might be quite significant. Be sure to consider this before you make the move.
 
about gas pumps, there are many out there, do a search, plenty of models, as low as $500/$600 with 10 000 gph+. there are 2 issues with them though, storage and keeping them in ready state. That means firing it up every once in a while, keeping fresh gas etc. also, while they will do near miracles once they are running, you will have to set them up, etc... which takes time. Not a bad idea to have if you routinely operate offshore. In my case i just don't know where i'd store one, whether on my 53 footer or even on Charmer (the 70 footer i captain)

bill is right obviously about electric pump limitations. that Sahara 1100 Tom mentioned is a convenience pump, nothing more. it will take out a few gallons that may get in from a dripping stuffing box or from a strainer clean up. nothing else. once you factor in the head, friction, etc.. it's probably closer to 600gph.

It all comes down to doing the math. I do know that a 1" open seacock will NOT generate more water than a 2000gph pump can handle... there are tables out there showing how much water a hole will let in depending on size and depth. interesting (sorry i dont' have the link handy..., google it)

as previously explained in other threads, the big advantage of electric bilge, properly sized and installed, is that they will kick in right away. this is critical as every second counts. Assuming that the boat will not stay afloat forever on the bilge pumps alone, the sooner they start the more time you have to find the leak, call for help, beach the boat, whatever. by the time you have 4' of water in the ER, the engines are gettind swamped, the batteries flooded... you are done.

imagine getting in the engine room of your boat, with 3" of water, oil floating at the top, probably no light, maybe a genny still running with waster spalshing on AC wires, stuff floating around and find the source of the leak. good luck.

If your bilge pumps and alarms have alerted you early, chances are you will know which part of the ER is flooding because water will not have reached the top of the stringers and overflowed.

the actual nr and type of pump depends on your boat.

on my old maxum 37, I had the 2 factory installed 1500gph pumps (one in the fwd bilge, one in AR/aft) plus a back up 3700 I added early on and installed 5" higher, in the ER. that was a decent set up for near coastal cruising and the occasional run to bimini.

On my Hatteras 53, i have 4 rule 2000 (bow, each ER, and stern) plus a 3700 back up in the genny room, between the bow and the ERs. the 3700 in hooked to a differnt battery bank from the others. it's ok considering that i'm always in shallow waters in the bay of the keys. Ideally, i'd put in another 3700 at the stern, as well as in each ER, again, all higher as back up). Warning lights for the pumps are at the lower helm only, I should add lights upstairs...

on Charmer, the 70 footer I captain, we have 5 3700 plus manual fixed hand pump (unknown capacity) in the ER. There are 5 high water alarms; all pumps and alarms have lights at the helm (single helm on the enclosed flybridge) as well as on the eletrical panel in the saloon. that's decent set up, although adding an 8000GPH rule in the ER is very tempting... the ER is constantly monitored by a pretty good CC tv, which is shown on a decently sized LCD TV on the flybridge. I may not be able to see water accumulating early but i'm confident that any smoke or spray would be visible.

also, while i dont' have any valve to use the engine raw water pumps the strainers are very low in the bilge, i shoudl be able to open one or both, close the seacock and use that in an all-else-has-failed scenario.

Adding a CCTV is not that difficult. decent cameras can be found for $100 to $200 and on most boats you can add a $200 15" LCD near the helm, although obviously weather is an issue on an open flybridge. I dont' see the point of displaying the ER cam on the helm displays since unless you have an extra one, you can't monitor the cam all the time. While you're at it, you can easily add a back up cam if you're running a larger boat with a selector switch. running the wires is the hardest part of the job.

smaller boats owners shoudl also review their pump setup. on a 24-40 cruiser, the setup in had on the 37 woudl work just fine, maybe with an extra 3700 on larger boats. on a smaller boat, pumping capacity is even more critical since these boats will be drastically affected by just a small amount of water. Stuff will get wet faster and you will quickly loose stability, and freeboard. You want the water out, NOW. a 1500GPH, with real world dewatering of under 1000, will not save you butt...

In anycase, when facing an -oh-s..t-look-at-all-that-water scenario, unless you know that an engine is the cause of the water coming in, do not shut down the engines. you dont' know if they will restart. Keeping them on keeps the voltage higher as well...

about adding bilge pumps, yes ideally you should add a thruhull for each new pump. While you really dont' want two pumps to share a thurhull, size permitting you can share a thruhull with somethign that's not going to be used at the same time... for instance if you have a sink drain or even a cockpit drain that will not be used all the time, you could tap in that with Tee, obviously you want the bilge pump to go straight on, and the other one to come down the Tee and the 90 deg angle.

like everything, eahc boat and situation is different though.
 
[/quote]
That's the one I'm talking about. I saw one in action once and it was truely impressive as to how much water it will pump. I'm going to look around and, if I can find where to get them and the cost I will post it.
[/quote]
I think this is your answer. May not be a price that you like.
"CG P-6 Pump: Darley Champion 2BE pump powered by a Honda GX-200 gasoline engine with a capacity of 250 gallons per minute at 12' suction lift"
 
quote:

Originally posted by PascalG

about adding bilge pumps, yes ideally you should add a thruhull for each new pump. While you really dont' want two pumps to share a thurhull, size permitting you can share a thruhull with somethign that's not going to be used at the same time... for instance if you have a sink drain or even a cockpit drain that will not be used all the time, you could tap in that with Tee, obviously you want the bilge pump to go straight on, and the other one to come down the Tee and the 90 deg angle.

like everything, eahc boat and situation is different though.






Pascal, with sharing a thru hull with a sink drain if the pump is large is there much chance of it pushing water up through the sink instead of all of it going out the thru hull? Or with back flow from the sink into the bilge through the bilge pump?

Thanks for all the insight. There's a lot there to think about.

Bob
 
Running the wires to a camera is the hardest part, but you can get wireless cameras. You still have to power them though.

A possible alternative to a portable pump could be belt or PTO driven pumps off one or both of the engines. It would be a lot faster to "deploy" (just throw a switch) but the engine of course would have to be running.

The problem still goes back to early detection. If the ER is already flooded, you're probably done.
 
So I guess the best thing for me is to not consider the small pump as any help at all. Perhaps lose it altogether. Then move the separate float switch for the Rule 2000 down the lowest part of the bilge to would make it my 'little' pump. And then install a big-arze pump with its own thru-hull (using the 1" from the old Sahara 1100) as the backup.

Does that make sense?
 
Back
Top