Bilge Water

mintregila

Active member
Member
Joined
Mar 23, 2004
RO Number
13060
Messages
2,554
For a few years we have been fighting bilge odors. When we run, the shaft logs drip as they should and when we are stopped, they drip very little. This leaves a few inches of salt water in the bilge (due to the vee of the hull)and over the course of a week, it gets a little smelly.

We have used the traditional bilge cleaners and have gone to a routine of flushing it with fresh water after we use the boat which all seem to help but not really solve the problem. After a week it is a cloudy, smelly slimy looking mess.

At the suggestion of a friend, last week we added some hydrogen peroxide solution (3% solution from the pharmacy). This seemed to work like a miracle. The water after a week looks crystal clear with no odor.

It worked so well that now I'm wondering if there is something that could be harmed by it.

Any thoughts?
 
Sounds like it is worth giving a try.
FWIW, I've found that salt water in the bilge is much less likely to become smelly than fresh water. Stuff you don't want in the bilge that causes odors will grow faster in fresh water.
 
Repack them with GFO packing and you will not have dripping while underway or at rest.

But let us know how the hydrogen peroxide works.
 
i agree about GFO but bilge water shouldn't smell... there is something else in there causing the smell, could it actually be the fresh water you rinse the bilge with?

I've had salt water in the bilges, never got a smell.
 
I have a foul odor on my 17 foot center console. I was spraying my wires and connections with Corrosion X and also sprayed it into the conduit that carry the cables and wires to the stern and I think this is causing the odor. I have been using Dawn Detergent but has not worked. Hydrogen peroxide is an oxydizer.If it does work let me know.
 
I had the same problem 4-5 seasons ago after I purchased my current boat. It ended up being a hairline crack in my Aluminum waste tank. After the tank was pulled I was shocked by the bilge area directly under the tank, there was about 1/2" of yellow cake waste. After numerous cleanings I then had that area of the bilge scraped and repainted. I replaced the tank with a Poly (plastic) waste tank no more odors even though I like you have bilge water in the V from my shafts. It does sound to me like you have something mixing with the bilge water.
There is also a company that makes a dry bilge system for wet boats it is expensive and I can't remember the name.
Bill
 
Isn't peroxide corrosive to metals? I'd be concerned having that sit in my bilge all week. Baking soda will inhibit the development of odors and isn't corrosive. Shake a box of that into the bilge water before leaving the boat for the week.

However, I agree that something is contaminating the bilge water. A thorough inspection of everything is called for. It may be coming from the cabin or a forward area that eventually drains to the bilge. Refer? A/C? Shower sump?

Good luck!
 
Wouldn't Baking Soda possibly clog the Impeller in the Bilge Pump when he tries to pump it out?
 
Tank, baking soda dissolves in water very easily. You can even make it into a solution by mixing with water first if you prefer. I don't think it could clog a bilge pump, but I have no experience with clogged bilge pumps, so maybe someone else can comment?

I have used baking soda in my fresh water tank several times with no problems, including the water pump in that system......
 
There may be some oil or antifreeze residue in the water causing the odor. I would not put HP in the water and instead, vacuum it out with a shop vac and a long hose. Then get an old style toilet brush and a 5 gal pail of water with some Simple Green in it. Wipe all areas of the bilge you can with it. Then hose it off and vacuum out the remainder. Keep doing this until the water left in the bilge is clear. The hour spent doing this will cure the problem. Leave the shop vac on deck and get an extension hose from the store. Don't let the shop vac fall into the bilge or it will make a mess again. Also run your blower while using the shop vac. I do this once a year and I never have any smell.
 
I wasn't clear.

I used it and it worked fantastic. Water is clean and no smell. It's not a septic smell and I had all sanitary hoses replaced when I bought the boat. My friend told me it was a tip in the Viking magazine.

Anyway it worked so well that I wondered if it is also doing harm.
 
quote:

Originally posted by mintregila

I wasn't clear.

I used it and it worked fantastic. Water is clean and no smell. It's not a septic smell and I had all sanitary hoses replaced when I bought the boat. My friend told me it was a tip in the Viking magazine.

Anyway it worked so well that I wondered if it is also doing harm.






Good tip, thanks.
 
try those solid toilet tablets. (white not b lue) in the bilges, they last along time, not corrosive and will kill the stink
 
Another good cleaning method is to fill a 2 gallon garden sprayer with hot soapy water and spray the hard to get areas. The sprayer helps blast off dirt, oil, etc.
 
I would try something organic like Raritan KO instead. Little organisms that eat organic material in concentrated form. See if that works better. Whenever I've had smelly bilge water, that usually took care of the problem in about 24 hour period.

The best solution is to work your best at eliminating nearly all bilge water. The dryer you can keep your bilget the better. A couple of suggestions. 1.) drip free packing 2.)Most bilget pumps can't get those last few inches. You can find though bronze pump screens that are able to get down to the last 1/2 inch of water and plumb them to a small pump. They will get most of the water the bilge pump can't.

I would not use any chlorine based cleaning products. Most toilet bowl or similar cleaners work great for spot cleaning but I would not use them on a regular basis. They are hard on the laminate with continued use. For constant duty de-stinkers the organic based enzyme stuff is much better, but again assumes that you can't get the water out. Get the water out and keep it out and you won't have to go that more complicated route. Bilge water is not good for your fiberglass. Osmosis works form either side of a laminate and bilges tend to be much less protected than the side that is supposed to be in water. Keeping a dry bilge is just a very good idea all around. It also is the best way to ensure that stringers don't rot, enginges don't become rust balls and generally kills the moisture/humidity/corrosion cycle that wants to get established in your engine compartments and elsewhere.

Get the water out.
 
My bilge water never smelled, then last season it became horrible. A few weeks after launch, the boat was unbearable. As it turned out, the mechanic left a cotton rag in the bilge which decomposed and was really putrid. I fished it out, and the smell got much better, though its still not yet odor free
 
Back
Top