Blocking nightmare

Your boat differs from the almost 300 that we launch and haul by crane every year at our yacht club.
 
I guess so whiskywizard, I just wanted to let people know not to ASSUME sling marks also indicate block points.... don't want anyone to have the same issues I did... but thanks for your input
 
BillyBo, whiskywizard, I believe that you are both somewhat correct. The answer lies in the design of the boat. N/C is correct, in that the sling marks indicate the optimum balance point ( based on CG ). But the absence or presence of a bulkhead is not necessarily indicated by the sling marks.

Example:

Two different types of wooden hull construction: "ribbed" and skinned with plywood, and "stitch and glue". The "S&G" hull has few, if any, bulkheads, whereas the "ribbed" type has more or less equally spaced ribs at "stations" from stem to stern.

The answer, of course, is what is recommended: Look before you block.
 
Same thing happened to my boat THE DAY I BOUGHT IT! The boat yard just couldn't wait for me to have it moved so they moved it. Thinking that the boat yard knew what they were doing, I didn't give it a thought. They blocked it at three points - two in the stern and one in the bow. The touble is that the point chosen in the bow was way too far back and the weight was not properly distributed. Lucky for me I had contacted a fiberglass repairman and he and I went down the next day to take pics and survey the boat. The yard paid for the repairs and I've been using the boat for eight years now.
 
I have no sling marks.
When the boat is hauled, the rear sling goes a couple feet ahead of the packing glands.
This puts the rear sling right at the aft end of the keel.
The front sling goes about 1/4 from the bow, where the bottom is straight.
I still cannot believe that the blocks would go thru the bottom of a boat.
Some boats must be thin skinned.
 
rduhon hints at the other function of the sling positions--the position of the sling, so it does not interfere with the running gear/plus the balance as above. There are lots of cases of boats caving in from improperly blocking. The blocking cannot be a small point of contact, but be properly done so that there is plenty of contact area in strong parts of the hull construction.
 
One of the problems with blocking is you can't block exactly where the sling is (it's in the way)... so if the sling is on the bulkhead the block will NOT be. Also some boats don't really have "keels" any more. My suggestion would be many blocks to spread the load. Also extra stands on the chines (also a strong point) if possible to take some of the weight off the keel.
 
I've noticed that the layup/strengthing along the lower sections of my hull isn't the same along it's length.

The stern section underneath the engines up to the first bulkhead is like concrete, and one block close to the transom normally works fine. Further forward, the section underneath the water tank / mid-cabin is thinner, and goes "clang" when you hit it, partially because of the tank, but there's definitely less fibreglass there. I wouldn't want it to be blocked there at all. Moving further forward, the forward sections are again concrete-like, where the forward block goes. I've no idea why this is the case, and tapping around other boats of the same model gets the same result.

On the hard, it's also supported at four points along each chine. No problems so far...

dv.
 
quote:

Originally posted by whiskywizard

Your boat differs from the almost 300 that we launch and haul by crane every year at our yacht club.






Do you go into each boat and inspect the sling points for bulheads/reinforcement? If not how do you arrive at your conclusion?

G
 
Don't forget those aft sling marks are also meant to keep the strap off the shafts

Niles
 
Stands are for balance - the load should be on the keel, properly blocked. As someone mentioned, some boats have no keel to speak of (ugh), and so a proper blocking plan (whether it be resultant from the designer's intentions or your own carefully considered ideations) is all the more crucial. Even with a stout keel, sufficient support must be provided. Boats are designed to the result of stable equilibrium (yeah, I know) IN WATER. The buoyant force exerts upon the entire wetted surface, not just a few pieces of blocking.

Just ask Archimedes.
 
"Just ask Archimedes."

I could not find him listed in the white pages.

G
 
quote:

Originally posted by whiskywizard

quote:

Originally posted by gcolton

Sling locations are ONLY for load balance. They do not tell the viewer if there is any structural material in that location. DO NOT use those locations expecting there to by any structure behind.

G






This isn't correct. Sling locations align with internal bulkheads that add rigidity at that point.








That's what the manual for my boat says.
 
quote:

Originally posted by gcolton

quote:

Originally posted by whiskywizard

Your boat differs from the almost 300 that we launch and haul by crane every year at our yacht club.






Do you go into each boat and inspect the sling points for bulheads/reinforcement? If not how do you arrive at your conclusion?

G








Of course not, but directing sling placement means I have seen hundreds over the years.

How do you support your conclusion that slings positions are "only for load balance"?

Few boats hang level. Many have a substantial fore or aft pitch. That's because hull strength takes priority over COG of the lift.
 
If you look at this logically, the sling marks have nothing to do with where to block it. If the boat is in the slings, you can't block it there.

The proper place to block a 30 foot boat is at the keel/transom and about under the base of the windshield. About 60%-70% on the blocks and 30%-40% on the stands. If something happens to the boat under these conditions, there is something wrong with the boat.
 
No, I wouldn't say ONLY for stability in terms of the hoist, but also of the ability of the boats structure to distribute the point-loading of the force of the full weight of the boat at the point where it is slung. As several pointed out, you CANNOT block exactly at this point - strap would be in the way. Blocking at the keel is a 'gimme', but the rest need be thought out.

Also, to reiterate (this is coming from someone who spent years as a yard monkey at three of the Cape's largest boatyards doing just these things), STANDS are for stability, not load bearing. The full weight of the boat should rest on the blocking, then the stands, having been sufficiently footed and placed in appropriate spots in consideration of the boats structure, should be snugged up enough that they won't budge. If the boat doesn't sit level, they should be used to correct such, but shouldn't be used as primary weight-bearing devices.
 
I am not being an a$$ or anything, but I would definitely scratch a boat off any short list
if it would crack or crush the hull when it is sitting on blocks.
What would happen if you have to ground the boat on purpose?
 
rduhon
Not sure I understand your post, do you mean you are going to put blocks in every position under boat before you buy it?

eg. bocks 4" X 4" under 30' boat, in every position, that would = 90 different positions you would have to try to ensure you cover every inch of hull. Thats alot of time and money (paying someone to lift and set down) also as I mentioned in original post the collapse did not happen for about an hour, (assuming 20 minutes for each lift) of just lifting and setting down, dont forget the 1 hour wait time
total = 120 hours at $100hr (wait time for crane)

GRAND TOTAL $12,000 ....

What would happen if you have to ground the boat on purpose???? Why would anyone do that
 
Back
Top