Boarding

Wal

Member
Joined
Dec 22, 2004
RO Number
15939
Messages
10
This post may cause a little controversy, but I have a question about our rights on our boats. A friend returned from fishing for winter flounder the other day. When he pulled up to his dock he was approached by the NJ State Police who walked through his private property, boarded his boat and checked his catch. All was in order and the cop left. My question is when must we allow our boats to be searched? I know about the Coast Guard but what about other agencies? BTW I practice conservation and would never violate the law. Just wondering.
 
you have very few rights on a boat... i believe most local officers have the right to board (granted by USCG) and even if they dont' the USCG is just a call away.

now, are they allowed to walk on private property to get to a boat ? i dont' know but i'd suspect they are.
 
i thought game wardens could go wherever they wanted but police needed cause
 
I think they all can search. At least my experiences have been that way. Lake Havasu City is between Cali and Arizona. Both sides plus the USCG patrol on busy weekends. They're just doing their jobs but it get crazy when almost every other boat is a cop.
 
Welcome to the Country of New Jersey! This is a police state.
 
They can not enter private property. If they did they were wrong to do so.

Rob
 
The big question is; was he tied up to the dock or not?

If he was tied up, then I believe he is under the jurisdiction of the land-based laws, and I don’t believe the police have the right to search the boat without a warrant. They may have asked; “mind if I take a look inside?”, and if your fiend said yes, then it was a consensual search. However, if he was not tied up (even if he was an inch from the dock), then he is on the water and under the jurisdiction of the NJ State Police Marine Division, and/or the U.S. Coast Guard. The Marine Police generally follow the same laws as he CG, which gives them the right to board and inspect the boat without warrant or cause.

I believe that’s the way it works.
 
In Mich a police officer can not enter private property without permission to conduct a search, however there are some circumstances that the laws of search and seizure can be circumvented. Now if you are talking about a DNR Officer (Fish and Game) they have a whole different set of rules. They can and will enter private land without permission or a search warrant to conduct investigations. Homeland security has also changed privacy rights when it comes to a vehicle (boat, car, plane)in motion.
 
Most of the local authorities here, including Cleveland and the suburbs, have jurisdiction from their local municipality borders to the center of Lake Erie, specifically, the Canadian Border. They are charged with the enforcement of the law inside of that jurisdiction, including maritime law. They also work in conjunction with the USCG. The local Police have their own boats and they perform safety inspections and DUI stops. The USCG will call upon them to take over a DUI or drug violation and you go to court in the city in which the crime was committed.

This is nothing new to us and it has always been this way. Boats are allowed to be inspected by any proper authority. I would like hear a legal opinion about the private property issue, but a vessel is not considered to be private property, where warrants apply, even on the Great Lakes, you are always subject to a boarding.
 
Mike,
The way i read it ... and i could be wrong is the boat had returned to the dock and the state police entered tru the property not the dock or boat....

But that's my interpretation...
 
I see what your are saying Robski97, and I see the point, and this does raise a private property question, I was not considering my own real estate was being crossed in order to get to the vessel. I was thinking the boat as my property. I must learn to read better... What about private yacht club property? Police can enter property to perform an investigation - what is found there may not be admissible unless they properly attain a search warrant and in most cases, what was found before they get the warrant will also be admissible. I think that is the difference, investigate vs. search. Only my opinion, I do not claim to be a lawyer.

One more question - can a normal police officer perform a boarding or does he/she have to be designated marine patrol or police?
 
Good to see people seeing the distinction between a search and an inspection - HUGE difference, and it's NOT just semantics.

Also, significant distinctions exist between local, state and United States Coast Guard - primarily, Coasties are, without question, the best dressed, best looking #!=$**s on the water!!!
 
We have had a few run ins with the USCG but we are not a U.S. flagged vessel so when we are in international waters we have the right to deny a boarding according the the USCG. We have yet to have the need as they have always been very respectful asking for permission to come aboard. I asked them to limit their boarding party to 2 with one being an officer they complied with my request and all went well.

We are not exactly the smuggler profile with a 4 year old on board.

SeaQuest OE
A Lagoon 570
Anchored at Georgetown, Bahamas
 
quote:

Originally posted by November Charlie

"with one being an officer" - curious about that....






Why? A simple and reasonable request.

SeaQuest OE
 
I'm curious about the difference between a 'search' and an 'inspection'.
 
Police officers are allowed to stop motor vehicles in order to perform routine safety inspections, and to look inside the vehicles without obtaining a search warrant.
You of course you have the legal right to refuse to grant permission for inspection of your vehicle, but the result of that would probably mean that you would be detained until a warrant was obtained. And that might just take half a day or more.
Fish and game officers in all US jurisdictions are authorized to search boats and vehicles for fish and game violations without first obtaining a warrant. If they should come upon any other evidence in their search the search and seizure of the evidence will stand up in court.
 
ADRFIT,
U are 100 % incorrect. A police officer needs cause to pull u over. There is no routine pull over. If u do do get pulled over for something they can only see whats in plain sight. For anything more they need cause. No cause no search....

Rob
 
Not saying it's unreasonable at all. I'm just curious is all. Myself, I'd rather be boarded by a more experienced BO...

Simple curiosity is all...
 
quote:

Originally posted by Robski97

ADRFIT,
A police officer needs cause to pull u over. There is no routine pull over.
Rob





My wife got stopped by state troopers one night on Route 309 in Montgomeryvile for a "routine check". She was driving because I had a couple of beers (good thing, huh?). They talked to her and told her this was a safety check, obviously looking for signs of intoxication. They were stopping everyone. I guess the CG or Fish and game can do the same - conduct a safety check, and then make an arrest if they happen to "notice" something else.
 
Back
Top