Boat Decision

Split Decision

Member
exMember
Joined
Apr 26, 2007
RO Number
26024
Messages
261
Greetings,

I have enjoyed reading the "ATC" forum over the last couple of months. If I may, I'd like to compliment the folks who reply to the vast array of questions for their knowledge and professionalism. I have learnt a few things and can appreciate the range of opinions sometimes offered.

My wife and I are in the process of looking for our next boat. We have very much enjoyed our 1988 Doral Prestancia (30 foot, twin V8's)for the past 5 years and wish to move up to an early 2000 model year in the 34 foot size cruiser. We mainly boat on Lake St.Clair, with boating vacations into Lake Erie and Lake Huron.

Our top two contenders at this poinit are the Cruisers 3372 or the Rinker 340/342. Has anyone else made a comparison between these two boats? I'd really like to hear anyone's thoughts as to which boat they would prefer and why. In terms of construction, does one boat to a little better job in some areas of boat fabrication than the other? Is there any other model similar to the above two that you would want to consider?

Thanking you in advance for your time,
Mike.
 
Man, I almost hate to reply to a brand comparison like this as I'm sure that tons of Rinker owners will lash out at me for what I'm about to say, but here goes:

The Cruisers Inc boat is definitely better built than the Rinker. Out at our marina I have spent quite a bit of time on 4 or 5 different Rinkers, ranging from 15 years old to brand new. I've also spent a lot of time helping out on 3 Cruisers Inc, ranging again, from about 15 years old to brand new.

In virtually every aspect, the Cruisers is a better built, better finished, better designed boat. Of course, the Cruisers are also quite a bit more expensive, comparing similiar new models.

Now I'm not trying to say that Rinkers are bad, not at all. They're a price point boat and offer quite a bit for the money. They're just not a Cruisers Inc.

My view may be a bit jaded, as one dockmate in particular that has a 32' Rinker Fiesta V cruiser has had nothing but hassles with it. Something is always breaking on it and she bought it new 3 seasons ago and has had about 25% to 40% downtime *each* year that she's owned it. It's currently for sale and she's switching brands to, and I quote, "ANYTHING but another Rinker!!!"
 
I know a lot of Rinker owners who are very satisfied with their boats. Many of them have moved up within the Rinker family. Rinkers are a very good value. Too bad about GaryMartin's dockmate experience, but I think that is the exception, not the rule with Rinkers!

Comparing Crusaders to Rinkers is like comparing an Escort to an Escalade........
 
I'll take a different approach. If you can't appreciate the difference between a Rinker and a Cruisers....get the Rinker, you'll be much happier and richer.
 
Never thought of it that way walshie but you're right!
 
Both r good but get on them and see for yourself. I would think the better of the 2 would be the Cruisers but it depends on your needs. My buddy had a Rinker that size and was very happy with it.
 
I'd go with the Cruisers, just my opinion... They're very well built and they customer service is outstanding from what I hear, even when out of warranty they'll be reachable and answer your questions, give you advice etc. I like their layouts and finishes more than Rinker's. I bet it'll hold it's value a bit better too.

Like any balsa cored hull though, make sure you survey and be absolutely positive the coring is dry.

Good luck shopping! BTW, Did Doral really use the "Prestancia" name as far back as 1988? They better come up with some new names!!! LOL

glenncal - good question... my wild guess is that Doral's offering in that category, the 330/Elegante, is a very unique/quirky layout. You love it or hate it. No fixed berth up front, for example. Two cockpit tables... etc etc etc. It's actually my least favorite layout in Doral's lineup, although some people love it... Also a bit small compared to the other boats he's looking at. And then the 360 is too big. But again, I'm just guessing.
 
Thanks to all who have expressed their opinion (preference) of the 3372 Cruiser vs. 342 Rinker question.

On the Yachtworld website for the 2002/2003 model year they list fifthteen 3372 Cruisers for sale and thirty 342 Rinkers for sale at this time. If you average the asking price for the fifthteen 3372 Cruiser boats it comes in at $113,000. The average asking price of the thirty 342 Rinkers for sale was within $1500.00 of the Cruisers.Not much difference.

Since some people have felt the Cruisers is a better boat(I don't dispute that) , can someone comment of why it is said to be a better boat. Can someone give examples as to where the Cruisers are better built over the Rinkers? I can see the fit/finish seems to better, but how about the actual boat construction itself. Is the hull stronger, built with better materials etc.? Can it take 4-5 waves better?

Ernesto - Your guess was pretty close. We did look at the newer Doral's but didn't warm up to their layout.

And yes Doral did use the "Prestancia" name starting in 1988. My understanding is this was year one for the Doral Prestancia. Doral ran this model till about 1994. Actually the reason why we are looking at the Cruisers 3372 or Rinker 342 is the layout is close to our Doral Prestancia and the performance should be very close as well. Our Prestancia had the V8's in it instead of the more commom V6's.

Mike.
 
I don't know how much you want to spend, but you can get a nice 2000 Maxum 3300 SCR for around $75,000 with all the bells and whistles. I have one and we love it. We've had it since '05 and it has still held it's value.

thanks

Baltimore
 
Since you've narrowed your search to two models, go and check both out then make your decision. I've been on Cruisers and Rinkers and I favor the Cruisers. I can't explain why, they just feel like a better boat.

Last year, I was narrowed my choice between two boats (Silverton 330 and Carver 350). After checking out at least two of each model, we went with the Silverton. There wasn't a substantial difference between the boats but for some reason, both the wife and I preferred the "feel" of the Silverton....So far, no regrets!

Get on the boats and see if you get the same "Feeling" from one vs the other.
 
Of course I am known as the Cruisers freak around here, and I will always stand up for Cruisers whenever I can, but I will also admit when another brand is superior. And this is in no way a shot at Rinker, but there is a big difference in those two manufacturers. Rinkers are meant to meet a certain price point, and they do a good job. And of course there are happy Rinker owners, just like there are happy Bayliner owners, Maxum owners, any brand! If the boat offers what you are looking for, and you are comfortable with it's layout, features, and quality, then no matter what brand it is, it's the right one for you!

But, I don't necessarily think those two brands belong in the same league, nor should they be compared. Now, I would put Rinker in the same category with Maxum, both have nice finishes and offer lots of room, but they are built to a little less quality standards, and they use some cheaper materials for manufacturing. Will it float, run and cruise? Sure. All boats (well, most boats) do, but I think you would be much happier with the Cruisers. The 3375/3372 hull was one of their best ever, it they are very popular. In fact, I like them so much that I bought one today! My offer was accepted and we are doing the inspection, engine & survey and sea trial next week, then closing. My FOURTH Cruisers Yacht and I am just as excited about this one as the first one.
 
quote:

The 3375/3372 hull was one of their best ever, it they are very popular. In fact, I like them so much that I bought one today! My offer was accepted and we are doing the inspection, engine & survey and sea trial next week, then closing. My FOURTH Cruisers Yacht and I am just as excited about this one as the first one.





Wow! That was a quick turnaround, congrats on the new purchase!

Kevin
 
Congrats Jason on your 3375 Cruisers purchase and thanks for taking the time to reply.

Did the Cruisers boat you placed your offer on have the I/O's or V drives? Do you personally have a preference of one over the other in this boat?

Thanks,
Mike.
 
If you really are going to have to choose between a Rinker and Cruisers, in my opinion and that of others in my marina, go with Cruisers.
 
quote:

On the Yachtworld website for the 2002/2003 model year they list fifthteen 3372 Cruisers for sale and thirty 342 Rinkers for sale at this time. If you average the asking price for the fifthteen 3372 Cruiser boats it comes in at $113,000. The average asking price of the thirty 342 Rinkers for sale was within $1500.00 of the Cruisers.Not much difference.





An observation: Is this because the Cruisers is not that superior to the Rinker, or that the Rinker is a better boat than being presented here?

IMHO, you are talking USED so the maintainence, upkeep and overall condition of the boat to date is really more important.

Won't comment on other makes because that's not what you asked about, but FinnBill makes a good point,,,

Good Luck,

Fred
.
 
On the 3375 my preference is hands down the I/O's, that boat performs so well with I/O's, it's crazy! If the 3372 you are looking at has Volvo Penta 5.7 320's, e-mail me at RadioguyJ(at)aol.com and I can send you the performance report from the factory. It is amazing the economy that boat gets at cruise speed.
 
I do not have any experince with the Cruisers, but my Uncle has a 2007 342 Rinker. Fit and finish behind the scenes is not very good.

He has had the boat since May. It has been out of service 3 times, since then. Twice we lost power to the starboard engine. The GPS, system has failed. He also has had problems with one of the outdrives. (Not sure what outdrives he has)

The second time he lost power to the starboard engine, we were on a 10 day cruise. It took the helm apart to see if I could find the problem, The wiring behind the helm, was held in place by a piece of line, so that the cabin door would not rub it. I did not find the problem there, so I went to the battery switches so I could trace the power to the helm. The wires coming from the battery switch were so short and tight, that when he hit a wake, it pulled the wire off the main fuse. It look like a bowl of spaghetti.
 
Jason,

I would think the I/O would give the boat better performance, but is a 35' LOA boat tough to handle around the docks with I/O's?

I always figured going over 30' would require inboards for close quarter manuvering. My 29 is tough to bring the bow into the wind with I/O's. I would expect it gets harder as the boat length and bow height increase.
 
Back
Top