Boat Previews

"From what I read, the real question here is whether it's worth standardizing a more official service, with a commitment for a very thorough preview (my list as an example), in which case it may make sense to charge a small fee, and maybe offer a discount for anchored members?"

THIS I think would probably create Legal Issues.
Charging for anything like this I THINK would make you responsible for your comments afterwards.
Wouldn't charging for the service in fact be putting yourself in business?
 
I doubt Les would want to touch that. If there's no money, then this should be pretty simple. We just post some guidelines or reference docs for people to use when doing a preview.

But I don't think it should be for anchored ROs only in that case, right?
 
quote:

Originally posted by muddkatt

quote:

Originally posted by WaxedElvis

..this should require an anchor....




Yes, an anchor should be required. If someone has not contributed to anchor fund, they should not be entitled to the "good stuff".
It takes time to preview a boat, (I just did one this past weekend). If this is put out for everyone, then every tire kicker in the country will have us running around looking at boats. IF, and that is a BIG IF, they purchase a boat that was previewed for them, chances are they would disappear after the purchase.
Les, will make the final call, but I say if someone wants a preview, let them come up with the 20 dollars for an anchor.

Ken








Yes, yes, by all means, let's make BoaterEd.com even more exclusive! :(
 
But "IF" (Big IF), there was a small fee, for say a small business of a network of "previewers", what would be the legal issues be of someone paying for someones eyes, camera, and essentially a warm body in a location that you can't get to without paying a lot of money? No one is paying for a professional opinion, nor a professional service. I am interested in what the legal ramifications would be in this case.

I'm trying to think of a comparison with an existing service, but I can't think of one at the moment...

Shel
 
If you're paying for it, it becomes a "professional" opinion, and is subject to lawsuits.

Let's look at this scenerio:

I purchase an anchor from BoaterEd. This allows me into the area where I can ask someone to "preview" a boat for me. They take pictures and report back that they didn't see any problems. I buy the boat, and the hull is soaked and has holes in it. I now sue BoaterEd, and conceivablly I have a case, since I paid for some services that BoaterEd provided, and did not perform to my satistfaction.

Now, if it's in an area where no consideration has changed hands, there is no contract, therefore, no basis for a non-performance law suit.

3 semesters of Business Law 101 at Bloomsburg University (I failed the first 2 times).
 
Well, I'm grasping here but, what if someone paid a professional Photographer to photograph a house you were thinking about buying. What if that person didn't buy the house because of something seen in the professional photos? Would the Photographer be liable?

Shel
 
quote:

Originally posted by Shel

Well, I'm grasping here but, what if someone paid a professional Photographer to photograph a house you were thinking about buying. What if that person didn't buy the house because of something seen in the professional photos? Would the Photographer be liable?

Shel





Liable for what? For uncovering something that you, the seller, did not disclose?
 
IMO it is most unusual to not personally inspect a boat before buying and certainly not something i would ever do. I always though the previews were a way to sort out the long distance options not a way to make a long distance purchase decision.
 
quote:

Originally posted by blouderback

Let's look at this scenerio:

I purchase an anchor from BoaterEd. This allows me into the area where I can ask someone to "preview" a boat for me. They take pictures and report back that they didn't see any problems. I buy the boat, and the hull is soaked and has holes in it. I now sue BoaterEd, and conceivablly I have a case, since I paid for some services that BoaterEd provided, and did not perform to my satistfaction.






I don't know law at all, but this sounds silly to me. The customer did not pay for a survey, they paid for some pictures. Couldn't a "waiver of liability" be used for the crazies who don't get a survey?
 
Rest assured that I'm reading this regularly - as noted, I want to see what everyone is saying. The idea of standardizing the system is a good one. Personally, I'd like to keep it all volunteer. Any payment or reimbursement for expenses would be strictly between ROs. But you all do need to decide the "scope" - everyone or just subscribers.
 
By all means, I think it's a stellar idea, but I think that making it part of the subscription benefits opens up BoaterEd.com to legal problems.

It should be formalized, but not under the "paid subscribers only" area. BTW, I will be glad to help preview boats in Florida and Hawaii, as long as you pay my expenses. :)
 
quote:

Originally posted by blouderback

If you're paying for it, it becomes a "professional" opinion, and is subject to lawsuits.

Let's look at this scenerio:

I purchase an anchor from BoaterEd. This allows me into the area where I can ask someone to "preview" a boat for me. They take pictures and report back that they didn't see any problems. I buy the boat, and the hull is soaked and has holes in it. I now sue BoaterEd, and conceivablly I have a case, since I paid for some services that BoaterEd provided, and did not perform to my satistfaction.

Now, if it's in an area where no consideration has changed hands, there is no contract, therefore, no basis for a non-performance law suit.





I think Bob has a very good point here. Even if a lawsuit had no merit, it would cost boatered.com, Les, to defend themselves. I doubt Les wants that!

Remember KISS. No, not Bob, but Keep It Simple Stupid!!! I think as it has been is just fine and anything else is going to be a can of worms.

Just the realization that respected posters such as Ernesto used this process will encourage others to give it a try!
 
My concern is this: A google search will show that this is available. Then everyone that wants to have a boat "previewed" will sign up at the site. Get "x" amount of boats previewed and then move on. All that will end up happening is "the previewers" running around looking at boats that the person has no intention of buying.
The idea of being an anchored member is simply to address the above. I would have no problem helping a non-anchored RO, even BOB.
But while I am on the subject, Bob, you had an anchor. You alone decided that fate. Your actions is one of the main reasons I am for making it for paid members.

As for as a fee, I did one last week, drove over 2 hours round trip, over 100 miles. I did not take a cent. I did it because I wanted to. I am not a surveyor, and I KNOW that taking money could have legal ramifications. That is one bridge I will not go down.

Ken
 
I'm with muddkatt on this one now. At first I had no real opinion as to wether or not to limit it to Anchored RO's but after re-considering and having it brought up regarding the Google search showing the availability I now think it's a good idea for exactly the reasons stated.
Boaters and wanna-be-boaters and dreamers would probably flood the forum looking for someone to look at a boat that they MIGHT be THINKING about buying SOMEtime.
When I sold my Sea-Ray 6 years ago I took out an ad in a local paper and believe me.....I was flooded with calls with people wanting to look at it......which obviously there is no problem with cause nobody would buy it without first looking........but was actually surprised at the number of people that wanted to ....
"Take er out for a spin"
because they were thinking about buying a boat sometime next spring.
Needless to say that there were very few "little spins" given and I sold it to someone that really never even brought it up. He came over one afternoon and looked at it.....said he'd get back to me later that night...called me two hours later and offered me $200.00 less than what I was asking and showed up the next morning with the cash.
It was actually me that insisted we go for a ride before finalizing just to make sure he knew what he was getting and didn't have a case of buyers remorse after the fact because maybe it just wasn't quite as fast as he thought it would be......or maybe it was noisier than he thought it would be......There's all sorts of excuses. I took him out for about an hour and he was quite pleased and that was that.

Anyways....getting back to the point here....
My opinion....
Anchored RO's only and possibly a seperate forum for this purpose only.

Les?
 
Rut Row Shaggy...me and Tanq have agreed on 2 things this week.

I agree with your statement Tanq. First boat I bought The seller basically forced me to take a ride in the boat, (bad weather that day). When I have sold my boats, I never had a rider that did not buy.
 
I’m not a lawyer, but don’t see a liability issue even if an anchor is required. This is/will be a voluntary “favor” from one RO to another – offered, accepted and performed as such. If any $ should change hands for expenses etc. that is between those RO’s involved. Does BoaterEd have liability for the goods sold in the classifieds because it is the avenue by which buyer and seller found one another? I think not.

The thought behind an anchor being required is that those with anchors have an investment (albeit small) in the site and tend to be the more involved members therefore less likely to take advantage. (Before I get flamed – I know there are many, many “unanchored” RO’s who are wonderful assets and contributors to the site). What we DON’T want is to become a free boat preview service for the general public. What we DO want is to help out other boaters who share our interest but also PARTICAPATION in this site and an anchor demonstrates some dedication to the purposes of Boatered.

If “unanchored” members feel comfortable asking other people in ATC to preview boats so be it but a preview section with more info, detail and discussion for anchored members is a good idea in my opinion.

These anchor discussions always amaze me; you would think it cost $200 a year instead of $20.00, I certainly get my $ worth.
 
I think this should be open to everyone. Limiting it to anchored RO's won't prevent the problem that some people are concerned about - that new members will show up in hordes and ask for previews. If they want free previews, they'll be glad to plunk down $20 and then ask.

I believe the intent is to provide this favor to people that we know, not to complete strangers. So I suggest a waiting period between the time a person becomes an RO and the time he/she can request a preview. Or perhaps we'd also be looking for some participation in the forums, not just lurking.

That said, I suspect the qualification process can't be automated by the forum software, so the practicality of this idea may be a problem.

Nancy
 
I think you should keep it simple. A preview is a preview. It is one RO doing a favor for another RO. Using the form that was created will help keep the focus. However, a purchaser buys a boat sight unseen at their own risk. The preview allows you to determine if the trip is even worth it. The preview is voluntary. If someone comes in, registers and asks for a preview, nobody is under any obligation to do so. Good luck.
 
I started a Poll about this before I went to work yesterday and I don't see it now. I guess Les deleted it?
 
quote:

Originally posted by blouderback

By all means, I think it's a stellar idea, but I think that making it part of the subscription benefits opens up BoaterEd.com to legal problems.





I'm not a lawyer, but I am a member of many sites that have the option to subscribe with a cost, this gives the subscriber access to valued data that non-subscribers can't see

one of these sites is Boatdiesel

If this is RO to RO I just can't see a legal issue here
 
Back
Top