The beauty of BE is that it creates a diverse community where boaters can connect with each other. One of the many pleasures of boating is the courtesy most boaters extend to fellow boaters, especially lending assistance. A non-professional preview of a boat for another is just that, a courtesy. There are now several cases where that kind of friendly preview was made possible by the connection that BE provided.
Frankly, I don't see any legal issues for BE so long as it it is done between fellow boaters. Cross that line into a pay-for-service and I can see where there could be issues. However, I don't see how limiting access to paying members of BE can be construed as a pay-for-service arrangement. The service that BE provides is connection, not the preview.
All that said, I don't see practically how requests and responses to requests can be limited to paying users, unless Les wants to delete any post in an open forum that asks for a preview. I don't believe that kind of restriction would be consistent with the intent of BE.
One aspect where BE could help is to allow a pre-survey buyers checklist, created by the RO's, to be stored and accessed. Perhaps as a link in a sticky post somewhere. Maybe there should be a forum on buying boats - there are a lot of threads that start with someone wanting to know about what to look for, how about this boat, etc. Given the number of requests that start with someone new in ATC, I suggest it be an open forum, because those will continue anyway. The dedicated forum will just provide a way to organize and collect them.