Boat Previews

quote:

Originally posted by Shel

I have taken Ernesto's list and formatted and generalized a little. You can see it in the link below. Is this a good format? It's done in a way that can be printed and clipped to a clipboard.

http://docs.google.com/View?docid=ddtx2drw_13zpwp5ghp

Shel




Shel
Nice job
You may want to make a print version for the previewing RO to use onsite at the boat in question- this version prints to 12 pages
 
it's a great idea, with two issues related to posting the results.

1)- risk of someone coming in and snatching the boat after reading the "Review". It happened at leaswt once a couple of years ago... I went to look at a Tolly, took many pictures, and someone made an offer on the boat after realizing it was a good buy...

2)- i wonder how liable BE or the previewer would be if negatives are listed on a public site... the seller might have a case, or think he may have a case, claiming the review caused him harm.
 
Andy,

What would you suggest, removing the comments sections of the check items? It prints that much because of the space in these comments. I also gave a little bit of space for someone to write down the file names of any image files associated with the check item, if the previewer so desires. Should we have a version with and without the comments section?

Thanks,
Shel
 
I just noticed "j-d", who did a wonderful job previewing a boat for me, is not an "anchored" member at the moment. It certainly did not affect his willingness to help, even beyond the actual boat preview (he may take a look at the boat before transport, and has had several phone conversations with me).

I think BEd needs to be careful about what is made more available to anchored members than non anchored members. I understand some articles, how-to's, maybe even a preview checklist could be made available to anchored members only as a way for the website to show more value to those who register, but if so it shouldn't be done in a way that seems to alienate non anchored members or make them less willing to do such a thing as ask for a boat preview.

If a checklist is made available to all, it may just be that everyone gets their shot equally at a preview, but naturally if someone comes here only to get 20 boats previewed and not contribute anything else, it may get to a point where no one will be wanting to preview a boat for this person.

In my case, I did my best to send at least one update to most people that previewed boats, because I wanted them to know that I wasn't wasting their time and that I really had the intention of buying a boat as soon as the right one turned up.
 
Pascal,

I was thinking that once the preview was arranged, the results could be kept private to avoid exactly the type of situation you describe. I remember when that happened--it wasn't much fun. Ernesto has played his cards close to his chest on his deal, and that makes sense. But if someone wants to carry on the preview dialog in public, that's fine, too.

Nancy
 
The beauty of BE is that it creates a diverse community where boaters can connect with each other. One of the many pleasures of boating is the courtesy most boaters extend to fellow boaters, especially lending assistance. A non-professional preview of a boat for another is just that, a courtesy. There are now several cases where that kind of friendly preview was made possible by the connection that BE provided.

Frankly, I don't see any legal issues for BE so long as it it is done between fellow boaters. Cross that line into a pay-for-service and I can see where there could be issues. However, I don't see how limiting access to paying members of BE can be construed as a pay-for-service arrangement. The service that BE provides is connection, not the preview.

All that said, I don't see practically how requests and responses to requests can be limited to paying users, unless Les wants to delete any post in an open forum that asks for a preview. I don't believe that kind of restriction would be consistent with the intent of BE.

One aspect where BE could help is to allow a pre-survey buyers checklist, created by the RO's, to be stored and accessed. Perhaps as a link in a sticky post somewhere. Maybe there should be a forum on buying boats - there are a lot of threads that start with someone wanting to know about what to look for, how about this boat, etc. Given the number of requests that start with someone new in ATC, I suggest it be an open forum, because those will continue anyway. The dedicated forum will just provide a way to organize and collect them.
 
After reading the many thoughtful comments my conclusion is leave it the way it is. Somebody asks for what he wants and somebody agrees to provide that. The details are agreed between the parties without incorporating some outside expectations or organization details. If the parties agree to great detail that is up to them but their decision is not influenced by some BE "standard".

Personally I wouldn’t feel right about asking someone to do what appears a mini survey nor would I want to take on the responsibility of doing one. I’ll gladly go take a look at a boat and would have appreciated that service when I was looking at remote boats but more than that is something to be done by professionals for a fee.

So I suggest leaving things as they are. Nobody will be flooding BE with requests from Google and recognizing the unpredictability of peoples response to service as occasionally witnessed here about BF a lot of turmoil will be avoided by continuing a casual approach.

IIABDFI
 
A preview is never a "survey" or a "mini survey" regardless of how thorough it may be. A preview is just a preview, a way to document and convey photographs and the previewers impressions on the boat to the possible buyer. Even after j-d and Eric did that incredible preview of my boat, I had a surveyor go out there and do a survey. That is the real deal and when you can find out if there's any real issues with the boat.

But before surveying, you need to decide if that's the boat for you, and that's where a thorough preview, for those of us that wish to go that route, is very helpful.

I do agree that keeping it casual for individual RO's to figure out, other than some guideline document or checklist, is the best way to go. But I do think many people would find such a list very helpful. I know I've sent the list to two other users (who have emailed me asking for it) for previews and they've both appreciated it. Even the people who do previews seem to appreciate the list, even if they can't always cover it all, because they can just go down the list and it makes their time efficient rather than sitting there wondering what to document and what not to document.
 
This has obviously stimulated some good feedback on this potential assistance from RO to RO. One thing I think I saw somewhere but wanted to make sure it was clarified...I wasn't proposing to make public the results of the preview by posting here on BE for the world to see....that would be solely up to the potential purchasing RO if he/she wanted to share.

As a follow up on Ernesto's preview, here is a link to all of the pictures we took during the preview by j-d and me:

http://web.mac.com/eric.shepherd/Site/2001_Tiara_2900_Open_for_Ernesto.html
 
Well this thread seems to have gone away with no result? Can we at least come up with a template document, available to RO's that may aid in a boat preview whenever needed?

We could simplify my list a bit so that it's not so thorough and potentially overwhelming, and Shel's document sure seemed to be a step in the right direction in regards to format, being printable and allowing space for notes.
 
Back
Top