Boat Test Results

psalzer

Well-known member
Member
Joined
May 14, 2001
RO Number
4570
Messages
1,383
I know everyone is looking forward to the results of our rip to NC to test boats for US Marine. As Mike mentioned this was a great opportunity and it was a privilege to represent BoaterEd. We were offered 12 boats to test ranging from the entry level Bayliner 175 (more about this boat later) to the 37' Maxum 3700. In order to keep this from becoming a "book" I will probably make several entries and hope Mike will chime in frequently.
I will begin with the Maxum 3700

DSC01852.jpg


This was the first boat we tested, Mike & I met David, a US Marine employee who was brought in from vacation to assist. David took the boat away from the dock and handed it over to me, saying "have fun". The 3700 weighs 19,300lbs and is posered by 2 8.1L 420 HP engines. To say the least advancing the electronic throttles causes some excitment. The boat quckly jumped on plane and soon topped out at 47 MPH (the GPS was reading MPH not KT) the boat was very smooth at all speeds. We did not encounter any rough water as we were in the intracostal, but crossing boat wakes caused no surprizes. The instrumentation was very good, the electronic throttles were very sensative and took some getting used to.
DSC01855-1-1.jpg

This man looks happy ... Mike had the job or getting us safely back to the marina.

Overall this was a great boat, would be very comfortable for extended cruising.

I will add another post with another boat soon.
 
Where on the helm are the "electronic throttles"? Are they switches or a joy stick or??????
 
If you look just to the right of the wheel the throttles look no different than what we are used to except they are not using cables. They send an electrinic signal. On this boat there was little resistence so at first it was easy to add more throttle than desired. The "joy stick" comes with the test on the Bayliner 3200 (my favorite boat) and the Maxum 3100SE. It is called the "Axius Package" and is amazing.
 
Oh, it is almost hidden by the wheel, right? I'm looking forward to all of your and Mikee's reports!
 
After turning the 3700 back over to David for docking (for some reason they did not want us to scratch the shiney new boat) we were escourted to the next boat the Bayliner 225 Bow Rider. Mike and I stood there for a few minutes waiting for our "chaperone", and they asked what we were waiting for. It was then that we found out that we were on our own!! They said get in and have fun, bring it back in an hour!!
DSC01871.jpg

While I am not exactly a fan of bowriders Mike and I agreed that this boat was FUN!! As we were leaving the dock one of the US Marine reps. directed is to a canal about a mile down the intercoastal and said it would be a good place to "wring the boat out and see what it will do", so taking him at his word we headed out and found the canal. This boat was powered by a 5.0L 260HP and weighed 3750 lbs. I opened it up and trimmed it up ... RPM 5200 and indicated 56 MPH (no GPS .. I wish I had brought my handheld). The canal was smooth and the boat was preforming great. I noticed what appeared to be a shallow point ahead, but the depth finder was still recording 8'+, and we had been told this was a great place to "wring it out", so on we went. The depth finder quickly read 5.4.3.2 and we launched over the sandbar!! The drive kicked up and looking behind us we was a lot of mud and water, but we were now back in deep water no worse for wear!! There was no vibration, and the Bayliner did not break in half!! We idled across and were soon on our way, only to see one of the test boat (captained by the guy who sent us there) coming our way!! We signaled that the water was getting "skinny", but they waved and continued. When they saw the shallow water they pulled the throttle back and ended up "stranded" and had to get out and push. If anyone had any doubts as to the durability of these boats that should clear up any questions. The 225 was fast, got on plane quickly and was crisp and solid at any speed. Mike & I both agreed that of all the bowriders this was the most fun, and the most expensive with a base price of $39,598 including trailer. Mike again got us safely back to the marina and we were escourted to our next boat. There was no formal "debriefing" by the US Marine folks, but they were definately interested in out comments, what we liked and why as well as what we did not like and why. Stay tuned for the next boat!!
 
Flutter... yes, a bit hidden behind the wheel.

I'll add to Pete's comments on the 3700.
The throttles did take a bit of getting used to. To say they were sensitive would be an understatement. We we not certain if they needed some adjustment in the mechanicals of the actual throttle levers' tension or if the reaction to movements of the throttles was just a function of the electrovics and therefore needed some "getting used to". My personal issue was related to the single "throttle/tranny" lever set-up. Being very much accustom to seperate sticks for the trannies and the throttles it did take some concentration on my part when working close in manuevers such as you would in docking. Safe to say that forgetting that the throttles are on the same control as the tranny can cause captain and crew a few exciting moments when you attempt to do a spin by throwing each into full fwd/rev... the boat does respond, although a bit more violently than one would prefer! Overall, a very nice handling vessel.

The layout below decks was as one would expect. Full head with stall shower, centerline master berth, huge mid-berth. Sorry, but we didn't get into the engine room because this was the first boat tested in the morning and we were a bit rushed to move on so the next guys could run her and Dave could get back on his vacation.
 
Before I get too far, for those who may be concerned about Bosun, he was waiting (somewhat impatiently) for us when we got to the condo!
DSC01851.jpg

However his spirits improved after the first Red Stripe and on being introduced to Amy & Paige. These two young ladies are the ones who made this event a success.
DSC01878.jpg

They kept on schedule, made sure we were on the right boat at the right time, handled food, transportation, lodging and a million other details (other than coffee!) Always with a smile.

And after a good dinner and a little wine
DSC01879.jpg


Bosun went to sleep!
DSC01880.jpg


Bosun and Mrs. Bosun returned to Atlanta with me, he will travel to Aberdeen South Dakota for a little fishing and whaterver he can get into.
 
How about some impressions of the event itself and the people from US Marine? Did they treat you well? Did you get to meet other writers, besides the guys from Boating Mag?
 
Les, the event was extremely well organized and we were treated like royalty. The US Marine folks were very friendly and very interested in our opinions. If you liked one boat over another they were interested in exactly what did you like, or did not like. The repeated many times "do not be afraid to be critical" and answered every question. As Mike said above if they did not know, the called someone for the answer. There were writers there from Southern Boating, Sea Magazine, Lakeland Boating, Iboats, and several others. Most of them were going over the boats in more detail than Mike and I were, but busy as they were, they were very friendly. Obviously we got to know Dan & Kevin better than the others. The factory tour was impressive, but no photography was allowed inside. We were encouraged to ask any question we wanted and speak to any of the workers, and again all questions were answered with detailed answers if necessary. As I mentioned in the "Bosun" post, Amy and Paige literally saw to every detail.
 
I'm going to skip ahead to my favorite boat, the Bayliner 3200.
DSC01872.jpg

This boat was powered by 2 350 Mag/B3 and weighed a little over 12,000lbs. When I took the helm of this boat I knew I was in love!! Everything seemed to "fit", the visibility was good, and while it had the "electronic throttle" they were not as sensative as the 3700, it was expalined to me that these were by "Mercruiser" so they were a little different from the 3700. This boat had plenty of power, quickly jumping up on plane and reaching nearly 50 MPH (no GPS, indicated), and crusied nicely at 3300 RPM with an indicated speed of about 28 MPH, burning about 25 GPH. This boat handled well in the "old fashioned" way, using fwd/reverse as with any other twin screw boat, but the real treat was the Axius system. This is the "joystick" that Flutterby asked about earlier. When the throttles return to neutral the Axius is engaged. You have a joystick by your right hand, that you move the way you want the boat to move. If you want to go forward push the stick fopward, backward,pull it back. If you want to rotate or spin the boat, twist to stick in the direction you want to go!! Want to go sideways??? No problem, just move the stick sideways!! The more you move the stick the faster you will move, now I thought this may lead to inadvertant bursts of power,not so, because there is a "docking mode". When yo engage the "docking mode" it limits the RPM to about 1200. How does all this work without using thrusters?? As it was explained to me the 2 B3 drives are not connceted as in a usual twin engine setup, they operate independently of each other. When you move the stick, the computer figures out what the dirves need to do to make it happen, and it does!! Personally I think it is magic!! Watching the US Marine person dock this boat in between 2 boats with about 2 feet to spare at the bow and stern, in a very cramped area, with a strong wind was amazing. What I liked most about this boat (aside from the Axius) was the fact that there was little or no "low speed wander" that is evident with most V bottom boats, even the 3700. The below decks were as expected, head with stall shower, nice galley and seating. Now if I could only find and additional $150,000 laying around somewhere!!

That's all for tonight ... this was a great trip. I'll try and cover a couple of more tomorrow
 
I'll add some details:
We were met at the airport by Amy and Paige who transported Pete, me and a representative from BOC to Southport Marina in the large passanger van they had rented. When we arrived at Southport we were directed to our condo which was actually a 4 bedroom twin home at the marina. US Marine had rented several of the condos for the event. Since Pete and I were the first to arrive at our condo we were told that we get first choice of the bedrooms. Pete immediately selected the bedroom suite on the 1st floor while I went upstairs to pick one of the 3 BR's on the 2nd flr. I was pleased to find the REAL master suite on the 2nd flr with a canopied bed that actually had a 32" HD plasma TV mounted on the canopy at the foot end of the bed!!! SWEET! The fridge was stocked with beer (5 different brands), 2 different cheeses and bottled water. The cabinets were stocked with chips, crackers, chewing gum and Oreo cookies. We were set... except for the lack of coffee. Later that day we were each given gifts of very nice garment bags and FLIP video cameras! These FLIP video cameras are incredible cool and I would suggest that anyone looking for a "pocket" video camera invsetigate them. Really, really cool!!!

Dinner on Tuesday evening was at a country club restaurant that they reserved exclusively for our group, now numbering about 26 people including the US Marine staff. Open bar and a buffet of steamed clams and mussels, king crab legs, cooked shrimp, kielbasa, potatoes, corn on the cob, corn bread, veggies, and a mac & cheese that you would die for... really! We chowed down and still could not come close to clearing the buffet table. Dinner was served on the outside deck but we eventually moved inside to continue enjoying the bar when the "skeeters" took over the deck.

On Wednesday morning the catered breakfast was delivered to each condo. I honestly don't even remember what breakfast was but it was good! Lunch was a BBQ in the picnic grove by the docks. Another buffet of BBQ chicken, pulled pork sandwiches, cole slaw, potatoe salad, green beans and banana pudding. Good stuff!

Wednesday's night's rainy weather caused a change in dinner plans. Amy had made reservations at a very, very nice restaurant on Bald Head Island. There is no bridge to the island and no cars other than service vehicles and the trams. We checked real estate prices on the island and found that if you didn't have a checkbook balance with at least 2 commas before the decimal point there was no use even dreaming about moving to there. We were going to take the boats over but the weather nixed that idea so we boarded the ferry for the trip. Dinner was a choice of a pork chop entree that Pete devoured, a grouper stuffed with mushrooms, spinach, roasted peppers and cheese that I thoroughly enjoyed or filet mignon that looked great. Appetizers, salads, cheesecake, chocolate cake, carrot cake, plenty of wine and drinks of your choice all served by a young and very efficient staff. I started with vodka and with Amy's personal encouragement countinued with vodka before being forced to help finish of a bottle of Pinot and then chasing it all with beer when we got back to the condo. Yes, I felt like crap in the morning!

However, feeling like crap on Thursday morning did not stop me from enjoying the grits and shrimp, eggs and fruit breakfast when it was delivered to the condo. Pete passed on breakfast except for the fruit.

Our last lunch was a box lunch we were provided with just before heading to the airport.

So, you see, we were treated royally and as Pete said, US Marine wanted our honest opinions about the boats. They were particularly interested in anything we said we really like or disliked and they encouraged us to write honest opinions when we returned home.... we will do our best to keep up our end of that deal.

Lastly, Amy and Paige were absolutely wonderful and tried to make sure all of our needs were met. I now count them among my friends and hope that we can stay in touch in the future.
 
Pete's doing a great job expressing our findings about the boats so my comments will be brief to avoid being redundant.

I absolutely LOVED the 225!! That boat is just so much fun. Fast and stable, I never felt that we were at the limits of our control, even when cutting tight curves at speed or launching out of the water over wakes. There were a few other of the test boats in the creek at the same time we were there with the 225 so there was plenty of time to run her through some fresh wakes at WOT... she jumped them smoothly and effortlessly. The helm seat and bolster was just right for my 6'1" frame so I could easily see over the winshield without interference with the bolster up or through the clear windshield with the bolster down. This boat has plenty of storage (the US Marine guys call it the "Mobster Boat" because there is space to hide several bodies) and very comfortable seating for at least 8 - 10 persons. We did find that the cushions in the aft seating needs to be better secured as it kept blowing off and nearly out of the boat when we were running at speed. We found that the only way to rectify that issue was to keep the center windshield and passageway to the bow in the closed position to restrict airflow through the cockpit. We hope that US Marine will rectify this as it's nice to have that airflow and not suffer the loss of cushions if the operator does forget to close things up before dropping the hammer on this beauty.

BTW, we did ask about a 225 with a cuddy rather than a bow rider and learned that US Marine is not building cuddies for the domestic market because the market isn't there for them any longer. They do, however, build them for the European market where there is demand for cuddies but bow riders are unpopular. Go figure!
 
Thanks for the fluff, but lets get to the meat of it.

How did it handle the slop? If the day was mill pond conditions, will you get a chance to take it out again?

How was engine access? Could you reach all necessary components without scraping knuckles, or was the pre K class involved in the design? Photos of engine access?

Generator? Access? How did it sit?

Stringers? Construction type and ability to inspect?

Helm set up? From the few pictires I have seen of the helms - not impressed.

Deck to hull joint construction?

Wiring?

Thru hulls?

Were you running fully loaded with fuel or only partial?

Foredeck access?

Access to cleats? Could you easily single hand these boats with spring lines, or again was the pre K class involved in the design?

Layup schedule?

Wood in the construction? Properly encapsulated?
 
All tests were done in the intracoastal, thus no rough water I mentioned this in the first post "We did not encounter any rough water as we were in the intracostal, but crossing boat wakes caused no surprizes"

Engine access was good in all boats that we had engine access to .. that would be all but the 3700 due to tight scheduling. Here is Mike in the engine room of the 3200
DSC01876.jpg

His arm is on the gererator.

The wiring appeared to be neatly installed and easily identified.

Boats started out with full fuel, but no water or any of the usual "stuff" the average family would have aboard. You can assume they were lighter than they would be in normal use. These boats came direct from the factory.

I would have had no problem single handing any of these boats.

On our factory tour we found quite a bit of wood in the boats, but it all appeared to be well encapsulated.

I can't comment on deck to hull construction.

I found the helm set up to be acceptable, especially on the 3200.

Neither Mike nor I are surveyors, and we only had 1 hour on each boat, so our observations were somewhat limited.
 
as mentioned in another thread, the electronic location on the 3700 is all wrong.. they're too far down and too far to the side. i'd hate to run that boat in crappy conditions, like coming in some unfamliar channel at night where you have to really move your eyes, head and body down and to the side to get a good look. yuck.

it's fine for a quick run in good weather... when you dont' need the electroncis!

wish you guys had pics of the 3700 engine compartment, on the old one (1998) the layout was fantastic with plenty of room.

whenever I look at a boat, the first place i look at is the ER...
 
quote:

Originally posted by PascalG

whenever I look at a boat, the first place i look at is the ER...






Ditto.

BTW, glad you had a great trip up North. Sorry I could not help you out in Newport.
 
When I look at a boat that I amd considering to buy I also look at the engine room, though maybe not first. Please understand that we had 1 hour with each of these boats. When we returned them to the dock there was someone else waiting to take them out. The 3700 was one of the most popular, we were the first to test it, and when we returned there just was no time to raise the hatch etc. We probably could have used the whole hour to crawl around the engine and look at wiring etc. instead of actually running the boat..
 
Pete, is that Maxum 3700 a sitdown boat or can you pilot it standing. From your picture it looks like it would be very difficult to stand at the helm.

When I look at a new (or used) boat this is one of the first things I do. If I cannot comfortable stand at the helm that boat is put on the no go list.

Very nice writeup.

G
 
Back
Top