My .02 just having sold my boats. I looked at all three books, and also looked at asking prices for every single same model boat within 2 model years and turned that into a chart. Asking prices are actually very important, as it seemed to me that most serious buyers are very aware of what the other boats on the market are, and what they are being listed for. So you have to take the whole picture into account.
It's a tough market, but I ended up having three believable offers in a matter of a week, so I had buyers on the sideline in case my buyer didn't qualify for financing. So if you have a desirable boat you'll still get it sold for a fair amount. I actually took the luxury of outright declining two offers including the ultimate buyer's initial "firm" offer initially, which wasn't insulting, but just not quite enough for me. People think they can buy any boat for whatever price nowadays, but in most cases that won't get you the really nice pampered and extremely well maintained boats that are the most desirable. In my case, having the only 2004 Doral Intrigue in the market in the nation surely helped also, if it had been a more common boat it would have been harder for me to hold the line firmer on price.