Boating Ethics Question

http://www.boatered.com/forum/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=108905 If we do not support such facilities dont count on them being around in the not too distant future.

Land based gas stations sell a ton more fuel compared to marine.
It takes much longer to fuel and move boats through a gas dock compared to land based.
Envioromental costs are growing for marine based fuel stops.

I can go on.

Its our choice?

Personaly I feel I get more "bang" for the buck by supporting companies that support us boaters.
 
This is America, buy gas where you want. You are paying the Marina for a slip, you don't owe them anything.
 
quote:

Originally posted by oldfishboat

http://www.boatered.com/forum/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=108905

If we do not support such facilities dont count on them being around in the not too distant future.

Land based gas stations sell a ton more fuel compared to marine.
It takes much longer to fuel and move boats through a gas dock compared to land based.
Envioromental costs are growing for marine based fuel stops.

I can go on.

Its our choice?

Personaly I feel I get more "bang" for the buck by supporting companies that support us boaters.






Riiiggghht. Because when I go to West Marine and they have the "same exact" Fram oil filter for my 5.7 Volvo Engine as Murray's Auto, but Murrays has it for $3.99 and for some strange reason West Marines is $8.99, you're still buying it at West Marine because they "support boaters". Riiiiggghhhht
 
quote:

Originally posted by Gregory Saracco

Bob, if you think you're not paying road tax in Pa. (you are), how do you explain the high prices?






Well, you're right (that I pay the road taxes), because I don't generally buy gas at the docks (I'm a trailer boater).

However, in some states (I think PA is one of them), the road tax is not included on fuel that is not used for cars, trucks, motorcycles, etc. that do NOT use the roads. This is the reason #2 heating oil is dyed red, because it is not taxed, and if you get caught using red fuel oil in your diesel Dodge Ram (diesel fuel and #2 heating oil are exactly the same thing), you're in BIG trouble.

Some states even have a refund form you can fill out, that lets you recoup the tax if you claim you bought taxed fuel for use in your off-road vehicle (boat, farm tractor, generator, etc).

Oh, I forgot to answer the question: The high price is a convenience fee of purchasing right there on the water!
 
black pearl, what's with the HUGE picture of the boat at the end of your post?
 
With gas prices skyrocketing on the highway, Fuel has actually been cheaper at the marina much of the spring. The marina I do business with charges a fixed rate more per gallon than they buy it for. Whatever that turns out to be is what they charge until a new shipment is received. Because in some cases it was a few weeks between shipments, the marina fuel became a bargain. At the moment, it's about a dime more at the marina than on the road for 89 octane. But to the point, I'd buy the fuel where ever it made sense to me.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Chriznat20

quote:

Originally posted by oldfishboat

http://www.boatered.com/forum/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=108905

If we do not support such facilities dont count on them being around in the not too distant future.

Land based gas stations sell a ton more fuel compared to marine.
It takes much longer to fuel and move boats through a gas dock compared to land based.
Envioromental costs are growing for marine based fuel stops.

I can go on.

Its our choice?

Personaly I feel I get more "bang" for the buck by supporting companies that support us boaters.






Riiiggghht. Because when I go to West Marine and they have the "same exact" Fram oil filter for my 5.7 Volvo Engine as Murray's Auto, but Murrays has it for $3.99 and for some strange reason West Marines is $8.99, you're still buying it at West Marine because they "support boaters". Riiiiggghhhht








Personaly I have found the need for on the water resources.

I have found I am unable to walk on water, or recieve goods from Fed Ex while out for the weekend. Imagine what a pump out might cost when that tank is full.

Examples but.

YMMV.
 
Nope Bob, you're paying highway taxes on fuel you buy in the marina in Pa just like we do in WV. It's not dyed like heating oil or aviation gas either.
 
Maybe if the marina was giving you your slip for free there would be an obligation...
 
So aside from the tax discussion, if you had or have a trailer, would you haul across the street from your marina to save $.80/gallon and get speedy rewards points that will get you $10-$20 off a fillup?
 
Chriz,

I would do it if I thought the cost savings were worth it. i wouldn't worry about the marina unless there was a clause in your slip agreement not to. It's part of the advanateg fo having a small enouigh boat to do so. PLus with all the times yuo have hauled the boat for repairs, you'd be silly not to put it back in the water full.

Now sounds like yuo need to smack your mechanic around a little and have him get teh job right the first time.
 
Yes, I would put my boat a trailer in a minute to save $50-$100. Then I'd spend that money at the marina store.
 
In DE if you save your receipts you can apply for a refund.

Actually you were right until about a year and a half ago on the dye:

Blue: #2 Home Heating Oil....now different than off road diesel mainly because of sulphur content and additives
Red: Off Road Diesel dyed to prevent use in on-road because of tax
Clear: ULS Diesel (Ultra Low Sulphur)

Get caught with Blue in anything other than a home heating oil tank and you are in trouble, same as getting caught with the Red in an on road vehicle.
 
A few years ago, more like 15 years, I rented a bobcat to do some major landscaping. When I went to the gas station to fill up 5 gallon containers I told them it was for off road use. They did not charge road tax on the purchase. I'm in Pa but things might have changed since then.
I say the choice of buying it there or across the street is the owners choice. Most boaters who trailer are going to fill up while on the road instead of paying the higher prices at the marina. I wouldn't be surprised to hear the marina say they are only making a few pennies off fuel. The reason they get away with the additional $0.50 to $1.00 is because they can.
 
Our marina (and the other 2 on the lake) gouge us with at least $1.00/gallon OVER street prices...and this is for normal gas, not "offroad only gas" so the road taxes are being charged. Fortunately Texas will refund the $0.20/gallon road tax if you fill out the form every year and provide documentation/receipts/logs.
 
My big objection is to folks who haul gas to the dock to pour into their boat's tank. This is so very dangerous, most docks will not allow it and insurance companys are totally against it. The problem is static electricity which can make a spark and BOOM! [:-timebm] [:-timebm] [:-splat]

In CA we pay different taxes for marina-sold gas. Some of the tax is earmarked for boating specific state services such as low cost loans for marina and launch ramp construction. The Feds also have a marina-specific tax which is earmarked for boater related services and improvements. Sooooo, some of that $$$ you pay at the gas dock supports and benefits all boaters.

But I would go across the road with my boat in this day of high gas prices too.
 
You can buy your gas whereever you want. To me, it is simply not worth the time and effort to trailer the boat to a land station.
 
well i have to say its all about quality of life. we boat not because its more economical than bowling, but because we can and we like it. to drag 5 gallon cans of gas to your boat saves $4.00 a can, to haul the boat to the pump to save about $50.00 takes at least an hour round trip. if you have nothing else to do with the time, save the money. but personally if that hour or more of time came out of my boating day on the water, i'd pay much more than the 50 bucks for another hour at sea. its all about your own priorties and what gives you more satisfaction, saving the time or the money. the marina knows this and is counting on the convienence factor in their pricing. if the station across the street were another 15 miles away the spread would be even greater. don't worry about the marina's feelings, if they are worried about it, they'll lower the spread. but kuddos to you for thinking of the ethics over the money.
 
quote:

Originally posted by vic33004

well i have to say its all about quality of life. we boat not because its more economical than bowling, but because we can and we like it. to drag 5 gallon cans of gas to your boat saves $4.00 a can, to haul the boat to the pump to save about $50.00 takes at least an hour round trip. if you have nothing else to do with the time, save the money. but personally if that hour or more of time came out of my boating day on the water, i'd pay much more than the 50 bucks for another hour at sea. its all about your own priorties and what gives you more satisfaction, saving the time or the money. the marina knows this and is counting on the convienence factor in their pricing. if the station across the street were another 15 miles away the spread would be even greater. don't worry about the marina's feelings, if they are worried about it, they'll lower the spread. but kuddos to you for thinking of the ethics over the money.






Exactly! If we'd stop and consider how much we *pay* for every hour on the water, then that amount for the convenience of on-water fuel is really insignificant.

Also, Chriznat20, what are you spending in fuel for your tow vehicle and wear and tear on both it and the trailer to make those fueling runs? It may be minor, but it all adds up. Also, add up the half hour to hour it takes you to load, haul, fillup, relaunch and then park the trailer. ;)

Heck, when I add up the cost of the boat, slip fees, personal property tax and maintenance, well that makes the cost of fuel extremely insignificant.
 
It's called Free Enterprise. If the gas is of good quality, I would go for the cheaper one if it is of a price difference that makes it worth loading and launching the boat. And while you are out of the water, wash that dirty hull... LOL
 
Back
Top