Boating vs. Camping

Prospective

Active member
Joined
Sep 7, 2006
RO Number
23085
Messages
1,343
Before buying our first and current boat, my wife and I, and then with our kids, did a fair amount of tent camping. Since having the boat we have not done any. But this past weekend we decided to go camping in NH as part of our last pilgramige to Storyland with our youngest. Anyway I digress,

I have often describe boating to my non boating friends as a lot like camping. Obviously this comparison will vary depending on the size of your Boat or RV. But I tent camp and I've got a pretty small boat. Anyway here are my thoughts.

Location: Obviously this can vary a lot but you either get beaches and water or trees and mountains. I love both but I'm an ocean guy at heart so I give the edge to boating with the water view and warm beaches.

Sleeping: I sleep like crap on the boat. I know many will disagree and tell me all about how great they sleep. But I hear water slapping my hull, worry about little noises and am cramped into a berth just 2 inches longer than I am. Plus it can get hot and stuffy even with fans. Meanwhile, I have a roomy tent with an air mattress. Cool mountain air wafted over my head all night. Edge to camping..

Eating: This one is tough. We ate like kings this weekend and, in my opinion, everything tastes better roasted over a fire. But we eat well on the boat too. I love the fresh seafood and I love cooking breakfast on my gas grill off the back of the boat each morning. I'll give this one a tie.

Dirt and Smell: Okay this is pretty easy. No showers at the campground I was at. I stunk pretty good despite deoderant and freash water swiming. My cloaths wreaked of campfire and bug spray. And I had lots of dirt tracked into my tent. Meanwhile showers are more plentiful while boating. Worst case I always have my stern shower and can use some soap. Big edge to boating.

Worry factor: I have to admit I find boating a little more stressful than camping. I always am concerned with weather, sea conditions, and mechanical failure. With camping, as long as it doesn't rain, not much to worry about. Then again the heightened need for planning and skill with boating does make the result more personaly rewarding. But still, I don't have to think about strange marinas and docking the boat when I'm camping. Edge to camping.

Cost: Not much to say hear. $18 bucks a nite for the campsite and I bought a new 6 person tent for $80. Nuff said, camping.

I'm not keeping score but camping has a lot going for it and I would like to do more. But if you just asked which I liked better I would say boating. Which just proved to me that there's something about boating you just can't explain.

Other thoughts are welcomed.
 
We did a lot a backpacking before I got the boat and made some wilderness trips that were more than a day's hike from the nearest road. There aren't any campsite fees for that. My experience in backpacking helped me a lot in choosing a suitable boat and equipping it for anchoring out. Our boating is mostly from the marina to an anchorage for overnights and returning to the marina. We do some day trips. Marina to marina trips are rare.

Our boat is closer to RV camping than wilderness backpacking but it's a far cry from big boat yachting. We use an alcohol stove for cooking, ice for refrigeration and big screened windows and hatches for cooling. We also have ammenties like Purasan Type 1 sanitation, electronic toys and the like and use inflatable boats for rowing and hiking ashore. We can anchor out for up to six days is some nice isolated spot in the tules and enjoy the wildlife. Not a bad combination of two worlds.
 
And after six days on 26' boat I walk funny on land.
 
Sounds like the final argument for getting a bigger boat!
 
I had the same problem as yzer so I moved up to slightly bigger boat. Now I have plenty of stretching room and sleep like a baby being gently rocked by the wind/water. The sounds only bothered me for the first few times I slept on the boat. Now, I awake if the sounds stop, such as when the current stops just before the tide change. Good time to go potty and verify boat is in proper position.

At a marina, I use a couple of strategically placed fans to cool me at night. These also keep mosquitoes, flies and no see 'ums away from me. I even have a couple of DC fans for when I'm away from electricity.

Boating offers no dirt/sand and no sleeping with creepy crawlies! A definite plus for me.

I've given up camping for boating. RVing is very similar to boating in my book and takes you places that a boat can't go.
 
My wife and I sleep like babies on our boat. This is actually ironic because the reason I looked at a larger boat was all my nieghbors were getting campers. I figured one that floated would be more fun. In my situation the boat is set up like an office, with internet, WiFi, Satellite TV & Phone system. I also like my shower in the boat better than any of the 3 we have at home. I love the seat where I can let the hot water hit my neck, great relief for my bad back. My wife would never go camping so for us boating is a no brainer over camping.

Bill
 
I used to be a huge backpacking fanatic. In fact, I walked the entire Appalachian Trail from Georgia to Maine not once but twice from end to end. I also backpacked all over the world...Alaska, Cazech Republic, Slovakia, Ireland, Hawaii, over on the left coast (california), etc. It was at least as much of a lifestyle for me as boating has become. In fact, pre-boating, we pretty much went backpacking every single weekend if weather was half way decent and I love bad weather so I pretty much consider all weather "half way decent"). Every vacation and pretty much every ounce of freetime was devoted to backpacking.
And then...we bought a boat. Actually, first we started having children THEN we bought the boat. I don't think I've put my backpack on since. Part of me actually misses it and I keep saying I am going to get back into it and all that but then the weekend rolls around and we choose the boat instead! :)
Bottom line...put me on my boat anchored in a quiet secluded cove or rafted with friends, let me have my wife and children with me and our kayak and there's really nowhere else I'd rather be. I suspect if we ever were boatless again we'd get back into camping/backpacking but for now it's boating.... :)
 
We continued to backpack for a while. Our daughter was three on her first trip.

Boating became the favorite family outing especially when we took the kids friends along for day trips. Time required for boat maintenance also became a factor. Ripstop tents, butane stoves and mummy bags didn't need that much maintenance.

We have never seriously considered a larger boat after the nest was emptied. We could have used one when the kids were around a lot, but the 26' is perfect for me alone or for the two of us. The old boat floorplan has a lot more moving space than a newer 32'. When the kids were around, we did more of the raft up scene with larger boats in the family. Plus, the 26' length and 2 1/2' draft gets us to places in the Delta where sailboats and larger cruisers can't go.
 
Back in December of 1967 I went on a long backpack trip in Vietnam that lasted just over 18 months. I can't really call it a hunting trip although some would say that was a big part of it.

That cured me of ever again wanting to sleep in/on/near the ground.

I don't really like RV camping, too many people in too small a space when in a camp ground and when bad situations arise moving to another location is a hassle. Not so with the boat.

But, my 28' Voyager with its 2'10" draft will let me get just about anywhere I care to go on the water. Finding totally secluded places to anchor out is never a problem. Head, shower, stove, refrigerator, comfortable bed and A/C make it a pleasure instead of a task.

Plus, you have to admit, sitting on the fly bridge and watching the sun come up over the water and sipping a really good cup of coffee just can't be beat.

On the boat I sleep the sleep of an inocent man!

Bob
 
Camping --- Hiking garb from L.L. Bean

Boating --- Bikinis :D

Any questions?
 
Try making eye contact and and saying hello to half the people you meet camping. Good Luck . I find the people in the boating community a lot more friendly and helpful and pleasant to be around. I"ve done both and will never go camping again. Ok I do have a queen berth with ac and a full galley and all the trimmings. camping was in a tent crawling on rocks and walking in dirt in the middle of the night to pee. Edge BOATING!!!!!!
 
Good topic.

Prior to 07 we were very consistent 35-40 night a year overnight boaters. We started with a 21' cuddy cabin & finished with a very comphy 32'er. We still have the 32'er though it has been on the hard for 2 years now.

In late 06 we bought, for $80K, an 06 36' 5th wheel trailer & a 06 Chevy diesel 1 ton dually with only 16K miles on it. Since then we have done the 'delivery trip' from TX to MD, a 2 1/2 month MD to NM rtn MD (balloon fiesta) trip, 4 month MD to AK rtn MD, 2 month MD to New England rtn, 4 month MD to WY,CO,UT rtn, a planned 2 month MD to Canada Maritimes this fall.

We have done some serious traveling to places a boat would never go in just a few years.

We are not camping. Our trailer has all the comforts of a 40' plus trawler & it is just the 2 of us.

Which is better? No contest. We enjoy both.

With boating we are generally rafted up with the same families every weekend anchoring out at one of maybe 10 locations, none further than an 2 hours from our mooring.

On the road we have met many many people, especially during the Alaska trip. Our RVing style is more about using State Parks & COE parks than private/marina style parks with all the ammenities.

Costwise. RVing is far cheaper than boating. Still, we are not giving up our boat. It quietly sits waitng for us to return & put it back into service. In the meantime we boat onboard the best boats in the world. Other peoples.
 
quote:

Originally posted by billybokay

Try making eye contact and and saying hello to half the people you meet camping. Good Luck . I find the people in the boating community a lot more friendly and helpful and pleasant to be around. I"ve done both and will never go camping again. Ok I do have a queen berth with ac and a full galley and all the trimmings. camping was in a tent crawling on rocks and walking in dirt in the middle of the night to pee. Edge BOATING!!!!!!






I have to disagree with the statement that campers won't make eye contact but I guess it depends on how you define "camping." If you are talking yahoos in the KOA in an RV, yeah, I agree with that. If you are talking wilderness backpackers, I totally disagree. Backpackers are truly "out there" beyond the walmarts of the world and they are generally, extremely friendly and helpful to others. I think the lack of eye contact/friendliness is relative to one's involvement in the "day to day humdrum" of life. Get yourself out of that mold and you see that we are all human and life is fragile and life is best lived being helpful and kind. Hard to teach that lesson to some folks that are in a 60' RV or a 100' yacht...if you don't have to work together or rely upon others it is easy to stay within your own shell and not expand horizons.
 
A weekend boat trip costs me $800-$1000. A weekend camping trip cost me $100 or less. I like both but the costs sometimes make me wonder about boating.
 
Great topic!

When I was a kid we camped at Lake Shasta every year for one or two weeks. Campground was boat in only, and we hauled in everything we needed on a 16' Glaspar with a 35 Johnson. It took a couple of trips from the ramp to the campground, but other than the daily trip to the "marina" for ice cream, we were set for the duration. As a kid, we did that from the time I was 3 or so until I was 17. I learned to camp, ski, fish and I got the "bug" for boating.

Fast forward 50 years and I now go to the same cove with a bunch of old farts (I'm the youngest at 55) in a 12-sleeper houseboat.

Last time my girlfriend went out on my boat, she was there for the prep. She was surprised that it took us a couple of hours to get everything ready for a two-night trip. Camping or boating (in my boat, anyway,) it's all about the prep. I don't want to spend my time messing with food prep, I just want to cook it and eat it! Any prep that can be done ahead of time is time spent enjoying the scenery, fishing, having a cocktail or whatever, later.

I give boating the nod, just because I can change the scenery at will.
 
Back
Top