Boats Collide

It's too short of a clip to be sure of what I'm suggesting but it appears the smaller boat we see approaching cuts across the path of the larger ship and turns into it. All the room in the World, broad daylight, perfect conditions just unbelievable. Both are at fault for not avoiding a collision but the smaller craft appears to have failed to allow enough clearance of their turn.
 
By smaller boat, do you mean the one you can see as opposed to the boat with the camera? I don't see any evidence that that boat was turning. The wake looks straight to me. Although the smaller boat would be stand on because it was to the starboard of the larger boat, you're right that they are both at fault. No reason for that collision to have taken place. I wonder if either captain was paying attention.

Did you see the guy standing on the bow pulpit run back. Good thing he got out of there in time. Looks like he would have been decapitated.
 
First I agree that neither boat attempted to avoid collision leaving them both partially at fault.

It appears to me that the larger boat was not moving at the time of impact or anytime during the short video but very hard to tell for sure. Anybody else see it that way? (Not moving does not release them of their obligations thou since they don't appear to be at anchor. Perhaps underway but not making way.)
 
Yes, I'm calling the smaller boat the one we see. The boat with the camera appears as a larger ship then the boat wee see. I don't see the smaller craft as stand on in this video? It may be but I can't see that. My read of this is that the smaller boat was approaching the larger ship almost head on but turned to cross Port to Port? I wish we had a view of the rear trac the ships came from? I'll bet one of the passengers on either ship has the entire view on Video. Just a little care to be awake at the Helm to avoid this? Funny to see how fast both ships slowed down after the crash? Both Captains must have been playing chicken since either could have made a small correction to allow for a much greater clearance. With all that open water why even get close to each other? Just sooooo stupid.
 
I think that video was discussed on here a few months ago. I put 'em both at fault. If head to head they BOTH should have gone to starboard. The one vessel went to port and the other didn't really turn much at all. I think he could have turned more or sooner.

If crossing, again the give-way vessel didn't turn all that much, and again the "stand on" vessel should have stood on, instead of turning to port.

As the old saying goes, "it takes TWO to tango"...
 
I nearly got kicked out of the library today watching that video.
We are packed in, several other guys saw it over my shoulder, soon there was a lot of noise and some pretty frank vocabularies.
The the Library Matron came over. Mrs Ballbuster!
So we stood down and were quiet....except for a few snickers.
Finally another loud broad said: "Gentlemen!"
I had to leave. I was having trouble containing myself.

I saw the larger boat with the camera on board turning to port and running right into the smaller boat which was on a straight course.
Unbelievable that somebody didnt undertake some evasive action.
 
You know I've looked at it over and over and it's hard to tell if either boat turns at all. I mean the camera moves but what's on the horizon seems to stay in the same position. It looks like they both just maintain course and speed and run right into each other. Weird.
 
I sounds like someone on the big boat is screaming 'you scratched my anchor, I gonna kill you'.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Capt. Bill1

You know I've looked at it over and over and it's hard to tell if either boat turns at all. I mean the camera moves but what's on the horizon seems to stay in the same position. It looks like they both just maintain course and speed and run right into each other. Weird.






Not to belabor the point, but the horizon of the film is moving from left to right.
The Bow of the film boat stays in alignment with the bow of the victim boat, which I think seems to indicate a turn to port of the filming boat in order to stay on 'target'!
I wonder if there was anybody at the helm of the victim boat. Nothing in the film indicates any awareness on the victim boat.
Maybe the helmsman had already cut n' run for the safety of the stern?

Did you see how suddenly the victim boat stopped dead in its tracks?
That impact had to jar a lot of stuff loose. Including the Engines.
I wonder if there's any way to find out from the Coasties about the details of that one?
 
"Not to belabor the point, but the horizon of the film is moving from left to right."

If you say so. But take a look at the land mass on the horizon in the upper right of the frame. To me it never seems to move much, if at all, as it would if the vessel was turning. Now the camera moves. But that seems to do to the person holding it. Not the motion of the vessel. But, I could be wrong. :-)

It happened in the Red Sea as I recall. If you look closely you'll see that the boat being hit appears to be flying an Egyptain flag.
 
Don't they print the Rules of the Road in Spanish? The collision took place in Barcelona Spain......
 
Looking at the wake of the one vessel I thought I saw some evidence of a turn to port, but it could have just been wave action. Agree, looking at the land mass it doesn't appear that the vessel with the camera turned at all. IF any change was made by either vessel it was minor and obviously not enough.

Could be they were both on autopilot... It's happened before.
 
Back
Top