bottom paint.....really necessary?

BJL

Active member
Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
RO Number
1308
Messages
1,640
Our 30+ year old boat probably has a many coats of bottom paint on it. Each year we put a new coat on and that's it. We're in salt water approx. 5 months of the year on Long Island, NY. Today I started thinking........what if I don't bottom paint anymore? What terrible things will happen to our boat? During the summer months there are many times we anchor in shallow water and are able to scrub the bottom if needed. So.........opinions please.
 
well, you dont' need to paint every year... i've stretched 3 years and that's here in so fl where the water is much hotter. down here we have divers scrubbing the hull and running gear once a month, at $1.5 to $2 a foot. Well worth it, it's much cheaper than hauling out and cheaper than wasting fuel with a dirty bottom.

but north, where you haul out anyway, what' the problem ? too many coats ?
 
There are "active" ingredients in bottom paint. These prevent marine growth. Also if your boat is wooden, it must be protected from marine boring worms (Torados)--by the bottom paint.

If you are willing to use a heavy scrubbing pad or sand paper on the boat every week or two you may well be OK for a glass boat.
 
Aurora makes a product that is suppose to eliminate the need. I'm old school on this though. I use ablative to reduce weight buildup and let it go a couple to three years. I have not done it on this boat yet but it goes on in three coats the first season. The first coat is color X and the next 2 are color Y which is on the opposite end of the color scale. When I start to see X, it is time to repaint with Y. Works for me.
 
It would be helpful to know what kind of boat and bottom paint we're talking about. Some paints are multi-season and some aren't.
 
The boat is fiberglass trihull. Not sure what kind of paint was the put on last year but I don't believe it was ablative.
 
Probably nothing TERRIBLE will happen... but you MIGHT have to scrape off some critters.

There's only one way to find out...
 
I don't think I could go without on the Central Florida Gulf Coast. I left the dink in the water for two weeks this summer and had a HUGE mess to clean up. I was shocked to find that I had litterally thousands of barnacles growing on the bottom. Of course, the water was 92 degrees during that time, but holy crap, what a mess!
 
The water here never gets that warm. We probably get into the high 70's in a good season but for most of our boating season the water is cooler than that. Like Willie said, we might have to scrape off some stuff but that's probably about it.
 
Folks talk about the weight of bottom paints, layer after layer. Does a gallon or two of paint really weight that much? My guess is a good portion of the weight is in the container, not the paint itself And, will adding layer after layer year after year really add enough weight to the boat to affect fuel efficiency? I personally do not buy it and would love to see data on this.
 
Greg,

Well, we know that fresh water is about 8lbs. to the gallon. The paint is much more dense and therefore weighs much more. I suppose it depends on how much paint is applied and how many times. I'm just not smart enough to do the math...
 
Well, if it's not mult-season ablative, you probably have no ablative properties left even though you still see paint. Try it and see how bad it is at haulout or if your performance suffers midway through the season. Personnaly, I keep my boat bottom well covered to help avoid blisters in addition to keeping it clean and fuel costs down.
 
We just had our repainted with hard, not alblative. Previous owner did it every 2 years and we plan to do the same.

A handful of folks said we should sand her down to the fiberglass and start from scratch because of the added weight and drag. I hear them, in theory, but I question whether it makes that much of a difference. I could argue draining the water from the ice cooler daily instead of at the end of our trip decreases the same amount of weight, or buy beer at each stop, versus brining 2 cases on at one time, to keep weight down. Just a thought, not ranting.

I would love to see some data on this. My guess is it's one of those 'feel good' things, passed around during shop talk, and nobody has actually ever studied it.
 
Some bottom paints are 50% copper, yes it's HEAVY and no it's NOT the container. Ablative bottom paint washes off with use so the buildup should be minimal. The old hard bottom paints do build up, but as the copper does leach out into the water I don't think it's as bad as some would claim. On a fast boat it would be a consideration; but for me I don't think stripping and recoating would be worth the expense.
 
Slightly unrelated, is the 'stuff' (alblative and hard) that falls off into the water 'safe' for the water? I assume it is since it's on the market, but who knows?
 
The maintenance schedule for the bottom of a boat in FL has little relation to the recommended maintenance of a boat bottom in NY. Hard paints lose their effectiveness if out of the water for more than a month or so... most FL boats stay in the water so they can go several years on the same dose of hard paint. Boats in the north that are hauled for months at a time are not good candidates for hard paints for the same reason that they are acceptable for use in FL. If your bottom has hard paint and you haul for the winter, yes, you do need to repaint if you expect to keep a clean bottom. Ablatives, on the other hand, wear away over time as the boat moves through the water so, even after being on the hard, once launched the paint will slowly wear away and continually expose fresh biocides. In the north a couple of coats of a quality ablative should last a few years and you will never need to "sand to the gelcoat" to get rid of the build-up of many coats.
 
quote:

Originally posted by MikeeH

The maintenance schedule for the bottom of a boat in FL has little relation to the recommended maintenance of a boat bottom in NY. Hard paints lose their effectiveness if out of the water for more than a month or so... most FL boats stay in the water so they can go several years on the same dose of hard paint. Boats in the north that are hauled for months at a time are not good candidates for hard paints for the same reason that they are acceptable for use in FL. If your bottom has hard paint and you haul for the winter, yes, you do need to repaint if you expect to keep a clean bottom. Ablatives, on the other hand, wear away over time as the boat moves through the water so, even after being on the hard, once launched the paint will slowly wear away and continually expose fresh biocides. In the north a couple of coats of a quality ablative should last a few years and you will never need to "sand to the gelcoat" to get rid of the build-up of many coats.






We put 2 coats of hard on ours in November. We put her back in the water mid to late November. We hit a log 4 weeks ago and she has been on the hard since for repairs, and probably will be for 3-4 more weeks.

Are you telling me we have to repaint the bottom now?
 
Lots of hard paints have a timeline of max 60 days from painting to launch. After that, they lose their anti-fouling properties. Check the instructions for your particular paint.
 
The active ingredient in bottom paint is copper. How would copper go bad out of the water? I live in NJ, on the Shrewsbury River. I use Petit Trinidad, a hard, non-ablative paint on my Whaler. After three seasons, it's worn away and I repaint. Boat is in the water for six months. For your boat, a trihull, I imagine you have a trailer. Splash it without painting this spring. Stick your hand in the water whever you visit the boat. If barnacles start growing (which I doubt), haul and paint. What have you lost? Bob
 
Bob, no trailer but it does get blocked in our yard for the winter. I might touch up some bare spots, etc. but that's all I'm gonna do this spring. Then it goes in and I check it. Worst scenario is like you said..........if things start to grow I can haul it out on the trailer for the other boat (which would already be in the water) and do the painting.
 
Back
Top