Bow Thrusters

Grady:

I am not confused at all - I am very familiar with the method as I use it often - alone.
 
Our dockmaster forbids springline docking. Claims it tears up his docks. As a result we always briefly discuss docking conditions on the way in and decide the best way. Once we start docking the only time we speak is when my wife secures the first line and says "got it". If you satisfy yourself that that particular thruster is powerful enough for your boat and you have the money go for it. I'd love to have a thruster as an additional tool but my finances won't permit. I really enjoy it when dockmates comment that they never hear us yelling and cursing when we dock and I especially enjoy that they no longer scamper over to help us. Practice makes perfect but I'd still love the additional help of a thruster.
 
Grady,
Im with yea... ive been trying to show them the light for years... Let them bust there ass running around the deck. I made a comment last year about a sextant... ud think id killed someone.. AS said were not helping to answer the question... sadly and as usual hijacking...

Rob
 
quote:

Originally posted by In the know

Grady:

I am not confused at all - I am very familiar with the method as I use it often - alone.






I didn't realize you had a center console. You have the benefit of an open bow. Raul's Bayliner may be a little tougher to get to the bow line on, and running up there with the boat in gear could quite possibly be unsafe, which may be why he's asking about a bowthruster....

The guy that sold me my boat (single screw- straight inboard) specifically dumped it to find a single screw with a bowthruster. I believe the move from the Grady to the Albin w/thruster cost him close to a eighty grand.

Using those numbers, $2500 for a thruster seems like a bargain to me. :-)
 
Raul,

This is one of those threads that unfortunately guys don't like to stick to the topic but rather ride you about putting something on your boat that "you don't need, because real boaters don't use them".

I have a 26' cruiser (29' LOA) - single screw. I bought my 2003 Crownline 262CR used. I know the previous owner - who loved the boat but hated the way it handled/reacted in slow speed manuevering - low draft and high freeboard.

When we bought it, we had a bow thruster installed.

I had looked at the Sideshift as an option. I opted for a thru hull bow thruster instead because (at the time) we were trailering and it was going to be a PITA to install and remove it at the launch every day. I also didn't like the look of it..........I think when I was looking the Sideshift with the joystick, extra battery, etc was close to $3000. For another $2000 (not to make it sound like $2000 isn't a lot of money) I had a bow thruster installed and now I don't have to mess with anything.

Where we boat, we have 4 car bridges and a RR bridge (that always seems to be broken or closed) and that's just to get thru town to head to the lake.
Between these bridges, there isn't too much room....put it this way, it gets cozy between the bridges just like it's cozy at your favorite bay to anchor with a bunch of boats.

I often run my boat "1 1/2 handed" (I have one of my boys help - 6 and 10 1/2). My boys are way too young and unexperienced to try to handle a dock line, let alone get behind the helm and operate the engine. So what I'm able to do (if the wife isn't along) is before I get to a dock or slip is get my lines and fenders set (boat in neutral, safely away from the dock), once I'm settled in the slip I'll have one of the boys behind the helm to handle the bow thruster........this way I can walk off the swimplatform with my stern line in hand. Tie that off, have them use the thruster to bring the bow towards the dock (if needed) and then tie off the bow. Get back on and shut everything down and thank them for the help (IMHO, it's important to encourage and praise them for the help!)

If it makes boating more enjoyable for you and your family and you can swing it, go for it! I don't use mine all the time but the marina I'm in is very tight where they keep the "under 30' boats".
 
Whether you need it only you can decide. Whether it is worth it is again your call, you will not get it back if you sell the boat. Nobody is going to pay you extra for the thruster when you sell. I have a thruster and had one on my last boat. I never paid for it, it came as a promotion with my VP engines. I use them mainly to help my wife reach the poles. I personally do not believe that the cost will be justified on a sub 30 foot boat. The thrusters for that size boat will have less force then you can push off with one arm. I do not believe I have any experience in backing a single into a slip so I cannot judge whether it would be helpful there. It will not be more help then pushing off when parallel docked to a pier.
 
the original question was "I am wondering if the SS 230 BOW THRUSTER is worth the $2,500.00."

i really don't think that the replies have been off topic....

there is no black or white answer, it really depends on the conditions one routinely encounters. by conditions I mean usual current, wind, dock setup and risks. If you routinely deal with high currrent/wind and a setup where you could easily damage the boat, then yes. I'll be the first one saying that thrusters woudl be very useful.

on the other hand, here are a few examples where i dont' think you need thrusters...

"to reach the piling"... that can easily be done with engines and / or with a telescopic boat hook ! I have one on the boat, 5' collapsed, 13 or 14' when expanded, we can reach just about any cleat or piling...

"when pinned by the wind"... now that's the good one... if you're pinned by the wind, 75% of the thrusters will strugle pushing the boat off the dock, then it's only going to push the bow anyway(unless you also add a stern thruster). so you push the bow, then use the engines to kick the stern. hopefully your ruddes will be big enough to create enough kick... then when you have to reverse so that you don't hit the guy ahead of you, you loose the ground you've made becasue the wind is still pushing your stern but you're now in reverse... doesn't work.

if you have twins, you dont' even need to use a spring line and leave the helm. on a fixed dock, place a pair of 18" ball at the bow to cushion the bow ($100 from Boatfix, for the pair) and use the dockside engine as a virtual spring line... off side engine in forward, rudders hard over into the dock, dockside engine in reverse. adjust RPM as needed. the stern will kick out, your bow nicely cushioned by the fenders. when at a 45 deg angle, off side engine goes in reverse, back out. no need to leave the helm, no drama. I do that prety often in winter when we have 20kts northerly winds at my favorite park.. works every time.

with a single engine boat, you will have to use a spring line, but again, there is no way a bow thruster is going to get the stern off the dock aginst a 20kts wind.

Grady, running down to the bow is should not even be an option, there is NO NEED for that. When i had expresses (25 single and 37 twin) i would also always single hand them and as long as i could get the stern near the dock, i coudlnt' care less where the bow was. i'd always set up the lines with the bitter end coming back to the cockpit, this way i could step off the boat at the stern with both stern and bow lines in hand. if the wind woudl push the bow away, i'd bring it back with the bow line since i already had it. no problem. obviously, that doesn't work with a larger boat but this is why i dont' see the point of spending a few thousand dollars on a thrusters on a small boat, again UNLESS you routinely dock in "tricky" conditions.
 
well Pasc, rrio asked if they're effective. Not many of the responses answered that question - and somehwere, there's an objective answer. His second inquiry was more about value - more subjective, but we still made it personal without offering much solid advice.

as far as the pinned by wind example, 75% of thrusters being underpowered hasn't been my experience, but I do my boating in a different part of the country. My own experience is with a powerful thruster paired to DDEC's. Together they could dance - against current, wind or BOTH. I didn't have to mess with rudders or throttles and someone with average skills could put a boat with that combo anywhere they wanted.
 
slw... ok... then explain to me how a bow thruster is going to help you move a boat that's pinned by the wind against a dock, with boats imediately behind and ahead. a pretty common set up around the country...

the bow thruster will move the bow away from the dock, agaisnt the wind. but what about the stern? how do you move the stern away from the dock ? not with the bow thruster, that's for sure.

you're going to have to use the engine/trannies with the rudders into the dock so that prop wash kicks the stern away, right ? problem is that even if your bow thruster can push agaisnt the wind AND against the boat rotation, you will still need to reverse not to ram into the boat ahead. while you do that, no more prop wash, stern slides back in... so you still have to jugle teh boat back and forth, with trannies, rudders and thrusters.

on the other hand, without a thruster and just a pair of fenders at the bow, you can kick the stern away with assymetrical thrust and back out. much easier ...

of course, you could also put the fenders are the stern and move the bow out with the thruster to leave in forward but i find it much harder to protect the aft corner/stern than the bow. how do you keep a fender in place aginst a corner ? and on boats with non integral swim platform, you're putting a lot stress on the platform.

I'm willing to understand how you make it work...no really... :-) please explain !
 
"I'm willing to understand how you make it work...no really... :-) please explain !"

Glad to see that I am not the only one that does not get it.
 
geeeeez you guys. Are you telling me that you've been ranting and raving against thrusters all these years without knowing how they're really supposed to work?!?!?

ok, I'm docked along a wall, stbd-side to. The wind is pushing me against the dock and I have boats in front of and behind me.

DDEC's in low, engines in neutral, rudders amidship, where they'll stay throughout the manuever. Cast all lines off. Thrust to port - just a quick burst, then let go. The bow begins to swing out. Then port into fwd, stbd into reverse and the stern begins to follow the bow out. There's no fwd OR reverse motion of the boat. Now back to neutral and another burst of the thruster. Repeat as necessary and the boat moves laterally away from the wall.

In really high winds, the engines have to go to regular idle and longer bursts of the thruster are used. At no point do you have to contend with fwd or rev movement of the boat - I'm performing an altered pivot is all.

In gas boats or diesels without low idle, you might have to use throttle, but as long as the thruster is adaquate, everything else still applies. It's still a pivot.

Easy and fast.
 
It's possible that when you've seen thrusters spinning away like a starbucks coffee maker that it's just too small for the boat. Another possibility is that the skipper is over-correcting, forgetting that there's a delay, some people thrust too far, then thrust back and begin a ridiculous cycle.
 
quote:

Originally posted by SLW

.....as far as the pinned by wind example, 75% of thrusters being underpowered hasn't been my experience, but I do my boating in a different part of the country. My own experience is with a powerful thruster paired to DDEC's. Together they could dance - against current, wind or BOTH. ....




My boat falls into the 75% and the thruster is a waste of good hand/eye coordination when the wind is pinning me against the dock( or blowing me away from it)
Don’t get me wrong I use the thruster often to hold me against the dock in light winds etc…
But it seems it never has the balls to really help when you think is should so I don’t rely on it – just the mains, Fenders,(and fender balls) and of course the infamous spring line
 
Diff'rent strokes for diff'rent folks. Time and again I've WISHED I had a bow thruster, AND a stern thruster, and even a traction beam; but I always made it to the dock, or away from same. It wasn't always pretty, but SO FAR no $$$$. Sometimes I used a spring. Sometimes a bow line. On occasion a stern line. Sometimes I had to get creative. A couple time I actually had to drop an anchor to get the boat under control...

Crew? What's a crew? All I ever get is Passengers; and I tell 'em to sit down and watch the show.

Practice, practice, practice. And THINK.
 
slw... then most of the thrusters i see out there in the real world arent' up to the job... or myabe they got tiny props n rudders... i see a lot of guys strugling to get off walls, sometimes giving a good scare to the guy ahead. a month or so ago, a 45 footer swiped the side of a sailboat, ripping out stanchions... with the thruster on full blast. so you still have the possibilty of over correcting during that balancing act... with just a pair of fenders, assymetrical thurst and prop wash on a rudder, there is nothing to over correct. minor variation on the throttle maybe needed to keep the boat in place, that's it. only 1 set of control to adjust vs throttles, gears AND joystick :-)

abalmuth, you dont' need a spring line with twins... you can simply use the dockside engine in reverse to cancel out the forward thurst of the offside engine in forward and let the rudders do the work. give it a try.
 
quote:

Originally posted by PascalG

abalmuth, you dont' need a spring line with twins... you can simply use the dockside engine in reverse to cancel out the forward thurst of the offside engine in forward and let the rudders do the work. give it a try.



Pas
I am out of the water for a couple of weeks while the marina sets up a new floating dock for me – I will give it a shot when I’m back in
 
Pasc, that could very well be the case. I bet if we were to take a random poll at a marina, most thrusters owners wouldn't even know they had a choice of size/power.

Even the thrusters themselves can have bad props on them. A lot of people think that because they're in a tube, that they're impervious to damage. That's not true.

My point is that a proper thruster can be a very effective tool, and that was how this whole discussion got started.
 
"My point is that a proper thruster can be a very effective tool, and that was how this whole discussion got started."

No it is not how this discussion got started. The discussion got started by the OP asking if a thruster was worth $2,500.00 to be installed on a 26' boat. I have the same answer now as I did then - NO
 
Everyone Thank you, I know more about thrusters!!! Thank you for all this information, and discussion!!!

Raul
 
I'm glad you found it valuable Raul.

ITK, please re-read Raul's original post. You'll see that he asked if the Sideshift was effective, and if it was worth $2,500.

If you had allowed yourself to acknowledge that you weren't "In The Know" on this subject, your replies would have, and should have, been different.

Let's not lose sight of the fact that this is boatered.com, not egoboatered.com...
 
Back
Top