Brand order

lark

Member
Joined
Jun 20, 2007
RO Number
26900
Messages
197
I'm looking to buy a late model express cruiser around 35'. I know Regal has won a few quality awards but how do the other stack up. I see a lot of 340 Searays, some 350 Monterey and Chapperels and a ton of 342 Rinkers. I'm on a northern fresh water lake, so big water is not a concern, just reliability. The 34 Formula's are way over priced, so I'm not considering them.

My guess is

Formula
Searay
Chapperel
Monterey
Rinker
 
I would put Cruiser on the top of the list.

Walter
 
I have a Monterey that I'm happy with. You'll pay a bit of a premium for a Sea Ray (at least around here). But I gotta tell you, the bigger factors are how it's powered, the layout, and the condition (assuming used). In terms of quality, I think these boats are all pretty much the same and I would not put a whole lot into the brand among this group. Now if you were talking a Tiara or Viking vs. as Sea Ray or Monterey we would be having a different discussion.
 
you can't really put brands in any order, it depends on the year and model...

buy what you LIKE and what you NEED... not because someone says brand X is better than brand Y. Nowadays, the diference between brands, quality wise has shrunk to near nothing, especially when it comes to reliability. Most of the stuff that can break down is off the shelf anyway and similar regardless of brand. yes installation can make a difference in realiability, as sea ray found out a few years back when add thousands of boats ingesting water, but otherwise there is little difference.

looks at the features and the quality that matters to YOU
 
well, there may not be an absolute order but there are market driven cost differences. All other things being equal a used Searay cost more than a used Rinker. Some things are obvious, the cleats are bigger, the vinyl is heavier etc. But the differences are more subtle between a Monterey and a Chapperel, for example, plus a lot of the differences are hidden. When a Searay seller says, his boat is worth more because the resale is better, I can verify that by looking at Boattrader, etc. But when a Chapperel seller says it it's not as clear.
 
Well, alphabetically speaking the correct order would be:

Chapperel
Formula
Monterey
Rinker
Searay
 
You tend to get what you pay for. A lot goes into building a boat (hull lamination schedule, types of polymers, quality of gel coat, care taken in glassing in stringers and sealing cut-outs in same, connection of the hull to deck, etc. etc. etc.) that you just can't see standing on the showroom floor. Doing all of those things right drives up the cost of building a boat. These tend to be the places where corners are cut to keep the overall cost to build the boat down.

You've identified that the selected boat is in for a fairly easy life as a fresh water lake boat. The less pounding that hull will be subjected the less stress will be placed on those laminations, stringers, and hull joints and interior joinery. That said, you may be fine strictly focusing on layout. There has been a recent thread on walk-around vs over-the-console foredeck access. That is an important consideration in my opinion and should be taken into account since it will impact your life over and over again. Making sure the Admiral is happy is, of course, paramount.
 
quote:

Originally posted by TiaraJim

You tend to get what you pay for. A lot goes into building a boat (hull lamination schedule, types of polymers, quality of gel coat, care taken in glassing in stringers and sealing cut-outs in same, connection of the hull to deck, etc. etc. etc.) that you just can't see standing on the showroom floor. Doing all of those things right drives up the cost of building a boat. These tend to be the places where corners are cut to keep the overall cost to build the boat down.

You've identified that the selected boat is in for a fairly easy life as a fresh water lake boat. The less pounding that hull will be subjected the less stress will be placed on those laminations, stringers, and hull joints and interior joinery. That said, you may be fine strictly focusing on layout. There has been a recent thread on walk-around vs over-the-console foredeck access. That is an important consideration in my opinion and should be taken into account since it will impact your life over and over again. Making sure the Admiral is happy is, of course, paramount.




I totally agree with this. A boat that is regularly used in big water and salt water is obviously going to have a tough life-- especially if it also sits in the sun the whole time. Whereas a freshwater boat--inland lake--covered slip-- blah blah blah--then the requirements drop and I believe you get diminished returns on high dollar boats. Personally, I love Formulas, but I think they're somewhat overkill on our lake. I just don't think they are used to their full potential.

A friend at our marina has an '05 Chapp 35. That boat is gorgeous; probably my favorite boat I've seen in that class. Lots of wood and lots of amenities. I don't know of the build quality on these, but everything sure looks really nice to me- fit and finish, etc.

Another friend has about the same size and year in a Rinker. It has the best cockpit, IMO, but the gel coat has already gone dull! I just don't think it started with as good a quality in that regard. That's a real killer at resale time.

FWIW- in that category, I personally would start my search with Regals, then Cruisers, and then Sea Rays (mainly because there are sooo many on our lake and I would just like to have something a little different). I would also add Four Winns to the list.

Paul
 
I'm impressed by Chaps. My biggest complaint is that the name is too hard to spell: Chaparral. 1 p, 2 r's 3 a's.

I've spent a fair amount of time on a 28 and a 27 Signature, and the quality appears to be way more than skin-deep. I like things like the snap-in cabin carpet, high-quality hardware on the deck, nice layout, appropriate power choices, high-quality gel-work and a good ride.
 
Chaparral, got it, feels like there should be an E in there :)
 
Lark, I just got out of a 34 Formula, you are probably doing yourself a disservice by not even considering them. As was stated previously, if you knew what went into the build you may get a different perspective on cost. Even if you are using it on a lake without swells and chop, wouldn't you want the boat to stand up for years on end and still look good?

My present 5 year old boat came from the factory with Formula shrink wrap markings, most at the marina thought I had bought a new boat even after the wrap was taken off! You get what you pay for after all is said and done.
 
Dead give-away of a boat I'm not interested in:

A single bow cleat for both port and starboard bow lines (and maybe the anchor rode, too).
 
What, you don't have Tiara on there anywhere? Well, you were looking at a Searay so Tiara is probably out of the question.
 
Sometimes you get LESS than you pay for.

It's unusual to get MORE than you pay for.

Freshwater lake it's not as much of an issue but consideration should be given to

Hull design and engineering, sould that be more important than the color of the interior fabrics, how will it handle rough water and how well is it constructed?

ALL boats look pretty when new.

RWS
 
We're buying a complete boat so it all matters, construction, color, layout, reliability, cost, service. I can't just buy a rugged he man hull with big cleats, that's ugly and uncomfortable to sleep on.

Formula's aren't necessarily off the list, but every Formula I find is 30% more than any competitor, and the few I've looked at were beat. I love the Regal 37, but the wife hates the layout. Tiara's are too fish boaty, and most don't have the mid/aft cabin in this size range. Rinkers are falling off the list because the gelcoat seems to chalk up very quickly.

Cruisers should be on the list, but they don't have dealer within 50 miles.
 
Don't rule out rough water handling from your list of priorities. I boat in a river, the wind can gust to 50 mph, and we will still only get one footers on it, but go out on a Saturday or Sunday afternoon in July and your are talking rough stuff. The biggest I've gone over this year was 6-7 foot swells from the wake of a 50 footer "mushing" up the river. I believe rough water handling should be on everyones list when shopping boats. You never really know what the conditions will be like on a busy day. And who says you won't venture off of that lake and into more rough waters in the future?

Shel
 
Back
Top