Brand order

Originally posted by lark

Tiara's are too fish boaty, and most don't have the mid/aft cabin in this size range./quote]

Depends on the Tiara. They can be built to fish or built to cruise. Our Open is a cruising boat and has no fish stuff at all. The Sovrans are built purely for cruising. Both style are comfortable to live on and have great ammenities.
 
I agree with sbw1, nothing fishy about some of those Tiara Opens, and especially the Sovrans. That new 3500 Sovran has got to be one of the best cruisers in that size range in all aspects. It even has a nice theater style mid cabin.

Shel
 
Ok, Ok, sorry I stepped on the Tiara toes, the Sovrans look less fishy. However they all have too much beam (13') for my dock. 12' feet and change is my limit, besides isn't 13' a little beamy for a 36' boat?
 
It will all come down to what layout and ride quality you and the Admiral are happy with. We are partial to Regls but if the layout is not what will work for you, then so be it. The fit and finish of the others are very good. I think that Se Ray is a bit over priced compared to the others. I don't like paying for a name. Resale is higher because the intial purchase is higher. The other thing to consider is service. Which brand has a reputable dealer or service close to you. If everyone liks a particular layyout and can get good service from any of your short list boats, it should work out.
 
What about Larson and Four Winns, am I right in considering the Larson a price boat and the Four Winns more middle of the pack. Some tell me that Four Winns is closer to premium like Formula.
 
I think you should compare any late model 2001+ Four Winns with any of the brands you believe are top brands. I know many people with Four Winns, My Father-in-Law has one. I am of the opinion that Four Winns must have better Quality Assurance measures than some other "top" brands, because the people I know never have a problem with their new boats. I know a guy who bought a new 378 Vista this season and has no, I mean no, initial problems. That is rare. I know plenty others who have bought new boats form other brands and their season has been nothing but headaches. I also know a guy who bought a new 348(now a 358) a few years ago. He has never had a problem with the boat.

That 358 Vista is a pretty fine boat. It has a really nice riding hull, designed by Raymond Hunt. I think with a slightly used late model Four Winns 348/358 you can actually get what you pay for. Flat fore decks, good access to the side decks from the swim platform and cockpit. Nice separate shower setup.

Crawling around inside the Four Winns and the other "top" brands it is my opinion that Four Winns construction is on par if not better than the others I have been in.

Shel
 
What about?
Cabo
Rampage
Tiara
Etc. Etc.

It's really a tough subjective list to place boats by "Brand" when you don't have a definition of type, design, usage, lake or ocean and price.
 
There are a lot of decent boats out there. Doral worked for me, it may for you as well! I liked the one level cockpit with seat extension, folding arch, size of head fit my shoulders. Also like the large platform option. It has reasonably wide side decks with walkthrough windshield as well. With 5.7 Volvos the 310 will top out at 48MPH and Cruise at a 1.5GPH on the river. The dash has space for the ad ons without sticking them between you and the windshield. The engine room allows for room to do the mantainence and is easy to keep clean. The hardware is solid, the fit and finish will match up with any mentioned above. There is no boat without negatives and this one has some, however I would bet that your list will differ from mine!
 
I thought I was clear. type, design: "late model express cruiser", usage, lake: weekending on a lake. I guess I wasn't clear on the style issue, boats that look fishy really are not in the running for us.

Maybe I should grow some and let her know who's boss but we've been married 25 years, and we're going to buy a pretty boat.

Thanks for all the help
 
I'll echo Larry's sentiments on the Doral. We own the exact boat as Larry, just a different year. Our engines, genset, batteries, a/c unit, basically everything is very accessible, more so than any other modern 30' express I've been on, even better than some larger boats I've seen. Also the wide side decks are very unique for this size and type of boat, and you do get the windshield walkthrough also.

Screen door to the cabin was a must for the Admiral (she hates bugs), as well as fiberglass liner on cabin (no glued down carpet). 7.3kw generator versus many other express models with smaller ones. And the cockpit is huge for a 30'er, it has as much seating as many larger models and all in one level. Plus, we love all the beautiful stainless detailing, woodwork in the cabin, large swim platform with teak, high and thick bow rails, etc.... Basically we loved this boat the moment we saw it. FWIW, our runner-up brands were Regal and Cruisers.

The fold down arch was nice when we had the boat transported, but we don't benefit from it otherwise.

Of course, what we like may be different from what you like, so the important thing is you just look at everything and buy the boat that you fall in love with. And make sure it looks good! LOL

We do love the looks of our boat...

IMG_0538.jpg


Boatavatar.jpg


5041575_5_37196.jpg


1825002-R1-037-17.jpg
 
Lark, sorry, you were clear. I got distracted/lost the main topic while perusing through the other reply's.

After you distinguish what a good brand is, it's a matter of personal taste and functionality of a particular boat for you family needs. Screw everyone else's opinions...8^)
 
Didn't mean to sound testy. There's lots of thing to consider and again, thanks to everyone. I started the thread as brand order, hoping to find some way to quanitfy big price differences between very similar boats. Some of it is invented quality differences created by advertising, but some of it is real quality differences. You can't just ignore the invented quality because it effects resale. I'm only buying one boat, so I'm going to reject a bunch of boats. Whole classes and brands will just be rejected, I can't look at every boat.
 
Back
Top