Broken Shaft

maxumaa

Member
exMember
Joined
Nov 8, 2006
RO Number
24188
Messages
121
I broke the shaft on my 2001 35' Maxum a few weeks ago. I had hit something weeks before and figured I probably damaged it at that time and later it finally gave up. But when I had the new shaft installed I broke it this weekend without hitting anything. It only had 5 hours on it. I was wondering if anyone is aware of any defects, design flaws etc for that year in Merc's v-drives. It has twin 380 horse horizons. Any help/suggestions would be appreciated.
Keith
 
Sounds like you knocked something out of alignment and that is what is breaking the shafts. A bent strut could do it.

When the new shaft is in place, try turning the shaft by hand and see if it turns fairly easily. Compare it to the other shaft.

Which shaft broke? Where on the shaft?
 
The shaft broke up by the collar that mounts it in the transmission. I thought the same that something must be putting stress on the shaft due to alignment problems. The mechanic felt that if there was something putting that much stress on it that I would have felt vibration before it gave out. I didn't notice any before it broke.
 
well, sounds like the shaft is the problem, not the vee drive... for a shaft to snap that quickly, I'd suspect poor install (including not checkign the strut, poor alighement, etc...)

I'm not sure i buy the no vibration no problem excuse, it's true to some extent by not a guaranty of no issues...
 
Maybe a stupid question, but did it actually break - or is it possible the shaft came lose from the coupling?
 
I would also suspect aligment to a slightely bent strut. If your strut is just bent just a little bit, it will put a lot of stress at the collar. I would almost bet that the aligment was not properly checked by the mechanic when the new shaft was installed. A feeler gauge at the coller checking all the way around the collor is a must and the tolerances are very critical. Also, check the specs and procedure by the book, some boats require aligment in the water due to hull flex.
 
John, it actually is a break.
We are pulling the boat this week. The intent is to replace the shaft and check alignment. Has anyone heard of any issues regarding potential problems introduced by V-drives?
Keith
 
What did the fractured faces of the shafts look like. If the fracture was 90 degrees to the axis of the shaft, then bending/alignment was the problem. If the fractured face was 45 degrees (or so) to the axis, then twisting (hitting something) and the shaft failing underload was the reason for the breakage. Don't forget to check all the components in the drive system, prop, strut, strut bearing, tail shaft, couplings, coupling fasters, Vee drive, jack shaft and transmission. Check the motor mounts, they can sometimes get compressed when you shock load the system by hitting something.
 
I'll have to look more closely at the break for the angle of it. I guess there is the possibility of carrying damage over from when I did hit something the first time and it was overlooked by the mechanic. Seems like everyone is leaning towards alignment rather than "design" of v-drives etc. One last question is what about the possibility of material failure in the second shaft? Possible or highly unlikely?
Thanks to everyone for your responses.
Keith
 
Quite often they undersize shafting. What size is yours? If it's 1 1/4 it is way undersized. You can overcome this by going to an Aquamet 22 shaft. It's about twice as strong as 316. I had the same problem on my 26' and the Aquamet shaft gave me a 4:1 safety factor instead of 2:1. Gas engines should have a 3:1 safety factor and diesels 5:1.
 
Alignment has to be checked/done in the water. If they are pulling the boat and instaaling a new shaft, alignment can only be done with the boat in the water (after a few days).
 
The shafts are 1 1/2". I'm not familiar with Aquamet. Is the difference between diesels and gas due to torque? If so when I have 380 hp and four blade props and the boat is 16000 lbs. is it possbile that the load is too great?
 
1 1/2 should be okay, however I've seen Sea Rays with 380 horses that only have 1 1/4 shafts. The other thing you could do is have the fracture analyzed by a metallurgical lab to determine if there is a flaw in the shafting (it does happen though not often). Other than that, what everyone else says.
 
I'd bet all my years of experience that the shaft broke from an alignment problem.
If you bend a piece of wire enough it will break.
That shaft was being bent each time it turned over.
There is a specific method of alignment when a new shaft is installed (or even a re-installation of an old shaft) and it will expose things like bent struts and even engines that have shifted on their mounts.
You need to talk to the guys who did the work.
 
Had a shaft break on my this summer from metal fatigue. Decided to replace the shaft myself and learned a few things that may or may not help.

Aquamet 22 is superior to the standard Aquamet 19 in strength and quality. It's obviously more expensive too. I also found out that finding a propeller shop to order your shaft out of Florida can save you significant $$$. (As opposed to ordering it here in MA/RI)

It's important to have the coupling "faced" to the new shaft to assure it's perfectly perpendicular and has a snug fit.
 
All, Thanks for the responses. I spoke to our mechanic again yesterday. The feedback from the company that made the shaft was that they believe it was an alignment issue also. The boat will hauled Thursday/Friday and the shaft replaced. Our mechanic said one possiblity was that although the engine mounts looked good he would like to see it under load to see if there is any movement. Possibly that could stress the shaft. So we'll take it out when it's back together. I'll keep you posted. Thanks again.
Keith
 
Well, the new shaft was installed. Alignment was done. The owner of the shop we go to sat in the engine compartment will we were underway to see if the engine shifted while it was under load. Everything looked fine. He indicated it must have been installation error on the last shaft. We ran Saturday and Sunday without issues. I would have preferred to find an obvious problem but we'll see. Thanks again for all your input.
Keith
 
If you had to align the engine, then you did find something wrong.
 
It appears from what you have said that the "obvious problem" was the fact that the mechanic didn't check or do a proper alignment. When they did it a second time, it was done and done correctly? I hope you didn't pay a penny for the second shaft or labor??????
 
Didn't pay anything the second time around. The owner was very apologetic.
 
Back
Top