babncb, I have a few years under the belt as an insurance agent, and the "captain aboard" requirement is passed downward from the ins co underwriter, through the agent, to the prospect. Not all companies require it, not all prospects need it. Basically, it comes about when a boater jumps from one size of vessel to a larger vessel that requires considerably more seamanship than the smaller vessel. It is offered when all other underwriting indicates a "good risk", but the lack of proven experience requires denial of the application. By having a licensed captain aboard, until experience can be demonstrated, the ins co can offer coverage.
Note that often it is the lower priced ( or broader coverage ) ins carrier that makes such requirements. Other ins carriers do not make the requirement, but include this additional risk in their calculations, and offer coverage at a higher rate. Not all companies and coverages are the same, YMMV. Marine insurance is far from standardized, and policies and coverages may vary widely( vs "homeowner's" which is rather standardized ).