CAT 3126s

bsteven43

Member
Joined
Sep 26, 2007
RO Number
28678
Messages
76
Guys - Looking at a 2001 convertible with twin CAT 3126s 430HP each. 200 freshwater hours.

Overall impressions of this engine and reliability?

Things to look for while inspecting the boat?

Anyone offer opinions on average fuel use at say 8kts and cruise? 28000lb 42 foot convertible.
 
My first call would be to the CAT dealer for wherever the boat is to see if it has been recalled and/or fixed. You probably will need the serial numbers. These engines do not enjoy a good reputation.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Doc

My first call would be to the CAT dealer for wherever the boat is to see if it has been recalled and/or fixed. You probably will need the serial numbers. These engines do not enjoy a good reputation.






What is their reputation?
 
My previous boat was powered by 350HP versions of this engine. They are economical and reliable.
 
Ive surveyed some 350hp versions. Seems to be a good engine to me. I havent heard of any recalls.
 
In the mid/late 90's, Caterpillar produced a LOT of 3116's and 3126's which suffered catastrophic failures at a young age. (eating valves, soft blocks and head probs) While not everyone agrees, (because repeated failures occurred too), it's "widely-believed" that the failures were not due to a design flaw but instead were attributed to soft castings from a French supplier.

Unlike the 3196 after-cooler debacle, Cat had a reputation at the time for stepping up and taking care of 3116 & 3126 owners. (I contrast the 2 issues only because of the class-action suit over the 3196) Our neighbor lost his port engine after the warranty expired, but Cat replaced it anyway.

At the peak of the failures, we were at a marina that was 80% occupied by SeaRays. There were days that it seemed like the carcases of 31XX's, laying on pallets, out-numbered dockboxes. The failures in that series were so predictable that an unrepaired example to be out there now is very unlikely.

Since then, 3116's and 3126's have slowly been losing notoriety. However, the sheer number of failures goes a long way in preserving the before-mentioned bad reputation.
 
the 3116's used a mechanical fuel pump, the 3126's have a HEUI system. Very common engine in Caterpillars line, and parts are readily available at most dealerships...check with yours to be sure. I like 'em. Good engines.
 
I've had the 3126's for 3 years now, they had 1100 hrs when I bought the boat It's a 1999 Silverton) and now have 1860 hours (this includes 2 trips from NC to Bahamas). Only problem has been a cracked injector sleeve on the port engine (it was getting fuel into the coolant). Replaced all sleeves and injectors on that engine. Both engines run well and I have been pleased with performance. Mine are mechanicals, the 2001 may be electronic, which would be a plus.

My boat is 46 feet long and weighs about 28K pounds, so sounds similiar. I cruise at 20 - 21 knots and top end is 26 - 27 knots. While I don't really know fuel burn at different speeds, on the last trip using the engine hour meter I averaged about 13.2 miles per hour and burned 13.7 gallons per hour. I used a total of 2560 gallons of fuel over a period of 186 engine hours. My best guess would be about 2 - 3 mpg at 8 knots and .9 mpg at 20 knots.

There is good local CAT service and parts are readily available, although expensive IMO. The CAT service tech also charges $2.50 per mile each way for use of the van. For me that's $250 plus his time to get to my boat. I don't mind paying for his time, but that's an expensive van. Last time I offered to send a limo to pick him up.

Hope this is helpful.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Ted Williams

I've had the 3126's for 3 years now, they had 1100 hrs when I bought the boat It's a 1999 Silverton) and now have 1860 hours (this includes 2 trips from NC to Bahamas). Only problem has been a cracked injector sleeve on the port engine (it was getting fuel into the coolant). Replaced all sleeves and injectors on that engine. Both engines run well and I have been pleased with performance. Mine are mechanicals, the 2001 may be electronic, which would be a plus.

My boat is 46 feet long and weighs about 28K pounds, so sounds similiar. I cruise at 20 - 21 knots and top end is 26 - 27 knots. While I don't really know fuel burn at different speeds, on the last trip using the engine hour meter I averaged about 13.2 miles per hour and burned 13.7 gallons per hour. I used a total of 2560 gallons of fuel over a period of 186 engine hours. My best guess would be about 2 - 3 mpg at 8 knots and .9 mpg at 20 knots.

There is good local CAT service and parts are readily available, although expensive IMO. The CAT service tech also charges $2.50 per mile each way for use of the van. For me that's $250 plus his time to get to my boat. I don't mind paying for his time, but that's an expensive van. Last time I offered to send a limo to pick him up.

Hope this is helpful.






Great info - thanks. Sounds like a mixed bag on opinions on the 3126. The fuel consumption estimates look about like what I was expecting. By the way, the convertible I'm looking at is a Silverton - how do you like yours?
 
I've got twin 2003 mechanical 3126's 420hp each. Bought the boat with approx 300 hours on them - I put 150 hours on them this summer. Had the engines surveyed while up in Maine by very experienced CAT mechanics - they built them for 15 years prior to going out on their own. The survey came up like they were new - and with only 300 hours on them they were almost new. So far they have performed without any issues. My boat is 40' and weighs 28,000 lbs. I cruise at 2200 rpm - 20 knots and burn 21.7 gallons per hour at cruise. Average burn for the entire season was 14.7 gallons per hour.
 
quote:

Originally posted by kindredspirits

the 3116's used a mechanical fuel pump, the 3126's have a HEUI system.





To clarify here...the 3116TA and the 3126TA are both mechanical. The 3126B are HEUI and I think, but I'm not certain, they became the C7.

quote:

Originally posted by Sea Gull

My previous boat was powered by 350HP versions of this engine. They are economical and reliable.






Which is now my current boat. They remain reliable and fuel efficient. These 2003 3126TAs are in a 24000 LB Sea Ray 410DA. I have kept very accurate logs of my time and distance over this past season. In over 75 Hrs of run time I am averaging just a hair over 1.0 SM/Gal and making 21-23 Knots at 2250-2350 RPM. Key, and I men KEY is to make sure that you do not overload them, or any engine for that matter, and have your boat propped to reach at or above the recommended Loaded RPM range. On these engines you should see 2850 RPM (or darn close) with FULL load (fuel, water, people, stuff). Have the engines surveyed by a CAT technician. Should cost about a $1000.

hope this helps...
 
bsteven, overall I have been pleased with the Silverton. It is very well made - has a solid fiberglass bottom, for example, and replacement parts are readily available from Silverton. Engines and systems in the boat are brand-name and of good quality. Finish may not be top of the line but generally very good.

There's an active Silverton Owners Club where you can learn more about specific models. You can join without actually owning a boat. go to http//silvertonclub.com

BTW, the above fuel burn numbers also include the genset use. We tended to anchor out most of the time in the Bahamas, only going in about once a week for water (and sometimes then we didn't stay at the marina, only filled our tanks).

I agree with Dominic about making sure the boat is not over propped. I recently had trouble reaching wot (2850) and just reduced the cuppng on the prop from #5 to #3 and it made a world of difference in the performance.

Hope this is helpful...
 
If you check with Cat, or a Cat technician, he'll tell you how many they replaced. Something to do with block casting problems. They dry-sleeved them and put both short and long replacement blocks in. I had a customer with this trouble and Cat stood behind it almost 100 percent. They were both under the extended 5yr warranty program. Cat keeps very good history on their engines, but I don't know if the engines are past the warranty if they'll cover any replacement. I would think with the history of the amount they replaced, they're admitting to a defect and some recourse is expected. Remember, no, is not the reply you want to hear! It might take some effort. The repair/replacement blocks were dry-sleeved, one Cat technician said, it'll last longer than a good cast original. Another Cat tech told me that the original ones that ran for over 150 hrs and the problem didn't show up, were good one's too. Those engines, set up right, run real nice. The earlier 3116 and 3126's used the same mechanical fuel delivery system. Good power to weight ratio, easy of fuel if not run hard, and clean for a non-fully electronic.
 
Thanks for all the great information guys. I'm going to talk to the broker and get more engine detail. I'm not sure what version of 3126 it is. I'm not sure it's a good or bad thing that the boat only has 200 hours on it. I'm going to do some more research for sure.

Generally speaking, is there on or two engines in that size range (~400HP) that have really good reputations for reliability, maintenance avoidance etc.?
 
Guys - can someone give me a quick overview of Cummins 6CTAs? They seem fairly common. Reliable? Reputations? Thanks.
 
quote:

Originally posted by bsteven43

Guys - can someone give me a quick overview of Cummins 6CTAs? They seem fairly common. Reliable? Reputations? Thanks.




I had a pair of 450hp C's in my Formula 41PC- had close to 1400 hours on them when I sold the boat - This boat was run at "200 of the top" for most of those hours by me and the previous owner - at about 1000hours the head gaskets were updated to a newer style because of a slight oil leak and they looked brand new inside - dealer paid ;-)
I can't say anything about the newer versions where they are getting over 500HP out of them-BUT I think the C's are one of the best engines ever made
 
a few years ago we went out on a ride on a 5-year old boat w/ 6CTA's. As we pulled away, the captain mentioned that he was a little nervous because the port engine recently died and had to be replaced. I was surprised, because they have a good reputation for reliability. I asked how many hours were on it. He said, "Only 5,400! I don't know what happened."

The stbd engine was still going strong. I've been a fan of them ever since.
 
dominic....to my knowledge, when Cat started production of the 3126 they were electronically controlled injectors from the start. This is what differentiated the 3116 line(with mechanical fuel pumps) from the 3126. Cat has recently introduced ACCERT technology(emissions)........this started the "C" series engines. You would be correct in saying that the 3126 has "evolved" into the C7.
 
I think the 3116 is 403CI/6.6LTR and the 3126 is 441CI/7.24Ltr
 
the Cummins 6 cta has proven to be one of the best of the mechanical diesels. While Cat was having their problems the cummins engines were not so there may be a price difference in the used market.
 
Back
Top