Ceramic Foam core ?

Lots of places, including US (Technion), Israel etc claim to be the "inventors" of ceramic foam. Its vertue is that it is cheap, light and an extremely good insullator, plus reistant to high temps. Of course with any cored material, it is the lamination, and bonding which is important. I suspect that Regal has done a number of studies and investigated this material before commiting it to production in a large boat.
 
i did notice that the word cheap came up twice in the benefit section... :-)

i hope they did their homework but it woudln't be the first time a builder gets burned by a new material. has it been used in other boats ?
 
they don't say whether it's open cell or closed cell foam - open cell will create the same problems as any other kind of open cell foam.
 
Isn't that stuff basically what the tiles on the space shuttle are made of?
 
I was thinking like Rick. I would suspect a lack of strength over a span
 
Foam core in a composite panel adds very little strength to the entire structure anyways. It's just there to hold the glass/carbon sections apart (i-beam affect). Like Les said I'd be interested to see how hydrophobic it is. I have a h/s buddy who went on to become an expert in thin film technology for Corning and he sent me a small sample of the space shuttle tile once. It's very brittle actually and provides no added structural strength to the craft. Wife dropped a book on it and it just disintegrated.
 
coring doesn't add strength but it adds rigidity. If the glass to core bond is good, it's a great material as you can make very stiff panels while keeping the weight down.

Divynicel is actually very strong, it's very hard to crush and break, you can bend the 1/4" sheet pretty far before it breaks. it's also closed cell and will not absorb water.

There is very little info out there on that ceramic foam, i've seen mentions that it is open cell, at least in some form but i cant' imagine anyone using an open cell core on a boat.
 
I cannot find any reference to this material in any of my boat building references. My question is, why, when there are good foams that have been proven to be good alternatives for coring, would a builder try a new product like this and have the consumers test it out? The only reason I can think of is that its cheaper. I doubt very much that a builder would do much in the way of testing. Its not like they have the cash to make a 52' test boat and thrash it as if it had 10-20 years of use in a short time. The consumers are usually the guinea pigs for this kind of stuff.

I personally would not invest in something relatively new, and assume that a builder has my best interests in mind.

Shel
 
At the end of the day, IMO it's hard to find something better than end grain balsa when it comes to coring materials. As Pascoe puts it, "If you want to know how good balsa is as a core material, try to find a Hatteras with a core problem. Out of thousands of boats produced, there are only a few." Sure, if it gets wet it's a problem, however it can be argued that many other coring materials, if wet, also create terrible problems, like delamination. I've seen studies that show balsa being superior to basically anything else on the market when it comes to proper bonding and resulting resistance to moment forces. Of course, Hatteras didn't core below the waterline...

So, the question is, why not just use end grain balsa? And if you're concerned about using balsa below the waterline, then just make it solid! I understand the coring below the waterline concern, although it didn't stop me from buying a balsa cored hull, since I'd rather have a Baltek cored boat than something cored with some new cheaper material that God knows how it will perform in the long run!
 
ernesto, this quote is inacurate... hatteras only built a handful of boats with cored hull (below water line) and they quickly stopped. They used balsa core for decks and issues there are not uncommon... certainly more than a few, but unlike cored hulls, it can be repaired.

currently, they use Divynicel for hull sides which is a proven material. it's not cheap though, certainly more expensive than balsa... so i really suspect that cost is why some builders are trying other materials, like this new Ceramic foam...

even though Regal is a very reputable builder with excellent warranty, the lack of information on how the hull is built is troubling. But... the boat is sold out for 2 years so buyers obviously dont' care about construction techniques...fabrics and drink holders are more important :-)
 
Pascal - it's debatable whether Pascoe is right or not, however my quote itself is not innacurate. It's his words from paragraph 3:

http://www.yachtsurvey.com/boatreviews/HatterasINTRO.htm

I never meant to say that Hatteras cored below the water line, actually if your read my post again you'll notice I actually though they had NEVER done it, but I'll take it from your post that maybe at some point they did try it.
 
i meant that his statement is inacurate... core issues in decks is a problem in any boat, including hatteras, just because over the years, holes are drilled and not sealed properly. my boat has a few spots with core issues in the decks, not a big deal though but the fact is that there are more than few hatteras (and any other boat with balsa cored decks) with this issue.

i forgot the details, I read somewhere that they built a few convertibles in the 80s with balsa core below water line/bottom, but quickly stopped and even recalled/replaced some of them.
 
quote:

Originally posted by PascalG

But... the boat is sold out for 2 years so buyers obviously dont' care about construction techniques...fabrics and drink holders are more important :-)






Pascal, it's comments like this that won't get you invited to Thanksgiving Dinner in Orlando.

Could it be that these buyers have had such a good relationship with Regal and past boats that they actually TRUST a manufacturer? Is Regal perfect, of course not but they come very close in some peoples eyes.
 
I have just read that ceramic foam is also called silicon carbide. Look it up on Wikipedia. Not sure is its the same stuff used by regal but it is used for brake disks and clutches on high performance cars. I also wonder if its like the small ceramic tiles I have in my bbq. :-)

As for trusting builders, well if someone has the evidence that Regal is looking after their customers with their production decisions then I guess that person has a reason to put faith in that builder. I haven't heard of this evidence. We just need to be careful that ones faith isn't blind. There are very few builders that I would put that kind of faith in, and even then, if they were trying new materials I wouldn't want to be first in line.

I find the more a builder is confident and proud in their methods the more open they are to make it public. When I see builders giving little to no details in this regard I naturally get suspicious.

Shel
 
Rommer... darn... i love orlando (yeah right... :-) ) well, i did say "Regal is a very reputable builder with excellent warranty" ...

seriously, don't you think that when you're spending close to 1M you shoudl expect construction technique not to be a secret ? When all i see is a chop gun, a new miracle material and fir stringer, i get a little suspicious...

i really didn't start this thread to criticize one builder, but because i really wanted to know if anyone had heard of that core material.
 
quote:

Originally posted by PascalG

i get a little suspicious...






Come now, we know your a LOT suspicious!

quote:


i really didn't start this thread to criticize one builder, but because i really wanted to know if anyone had heard of that core material.






Understood, and I'm not trying to suggest blind allegiance to a manufacturer either.
 
Back
Top