Changing engine oil weight

MrsRobinson

Active member
Member
Joined
Nov 22, 2005
RO Number
19626
Messages
1,074
Our Jasper Long Blocks have approx. 125 hours on them. They are no longer under warranty. While under warranty we were told to run the Quicksilver 25W - 40, which we did.

From another thread here I discovered Shell Rotella. We are also considering switching to synthetic. While at Napa yesterday picking up some oil filters for the boat I asked the counter guy about Rotella and Mobile 1. He is a fan of both. However, both come in a 10W -40 and he cautioned us about switching oil weights, especially going to a thinner oil. He said we need to be concerned about leaking with the thinner oil. He also said we need to be concerned about the oil cleaning things up and gumming.

Ever heard of this? Should we be concerned with switching from a 25W - 40 to a 10W - 40?
 
There is nothing wrong with the QS 25-40. It's cheaper, doesn't have all those warnings, and you still change it every year.
 
rotella is 15W40 but why change from what jasper and merc recommend??? Do you think the counter guy knows more than the engine builders?
 
If you have to change to synthetic, why not use Merc 25-40 synthetic?
 
There seems to be no good reason to change brands. Keep going with what has been demonstrated is good for you. Don't believe the counterman or all the advertisments.
 
Why not just use regular Rotella 15W-40? The reason I gave up on Quicksilver 25W-40 is it is a PIA to buy. You either got to go to the marina and pay marina prices or travel 25 miles to a marine store that is usually out of stock. I switched to regular Rotella 15W-40. Quite frankly it is what most heavy duty engines run on both gas and diesel run on and my engine has really been running sweet on it. Once warmed up, there is no difference in viscosity between 25W-40 and 15W-40. Not only does the engine run good on it, it is only 6 bucks a gallon at Wally World.

I would not waste my money on Rotella synthetic. The reason for syn diesel oil is turbos. If you got gassers, a good heavy duty diesel oil like regular Rotella is more than ample for your use. I use sythetic in my truck, because it is a turbo diesel. It needs the sythetic to keep from coking the turbo shaft.

Look at all the big CATS and Cummins on over the road trucks that run on regular Rotella. If it was bad oil, you would know about it PDQ!
 
quote:

I use sythetic in my truck, because it is a turbo diesel. It needs the sythetic to keep from coking the turbo shaft.

Look at all the big CATS and Cummins on over the road trucks that run on regular Rotella. If it was bad oil, you would know about it PDQ!






Aren't those CATS and Cummins usually turbocharged diesels?[:-idea]
 
Yes they are but truckers don't shut down their engines with the turbos spinning as often as the average light diesel driver and when the big boys do it, they idle down their turbos. Shut down is where coking occurs especially without idle down. Just look at the aft end of the engines of any transport jet and I can tell you which engine they shut down first on taxi in.
 
There is a difference between 15-40 and 25-40. 15-40 has more modifiers in it to achieve the 15. Basically the closer the two numbers are, the more stable it is. That's not saying the 15-40 isn't good oil - I'm sure it is. I just know that the 25-40 is readily available to me where I am, so that's why I use it.
 
125 hours is still a brand new engine. I'd use what is recommended for a few years. I just changed my oil a few weeks ago to some low sulfer stuff and I think its coming out real soon. It is running like the valvoline all fleet does when it gets worn out. Approaching 5000 hrs on my repower.
 
quote:

There is a difference between 15-40 and 25-40. 15-40 has more modifiers in it to achieve the 15. Basically the closer the two numbers are, the more stable it is. That's not saying the 15-40 isn't good oil - I'm sure it is. I just know that the 25-40 is readily available to me where I am, so that's why I use it.





Read the label on Quicksilver oil it is not a 25W-40 oil. It is a blend of 25W and 40 weight oils. There is a difference.
 
I am not comparing brands as both are readily available in our area.

If I decide to switch to synthetic or Rotella because <insert reason here> and I cannot find a 25W - 40 in Rotella or synthetic, will switching to a 15W - 40 be an issue?
 
no it shouldn't be a major issue. With lighter weight oil it may break down sooner so you may just have to change your oil a bit more. That is if you are not always pushing the cutting edge of the peerformance of the boat. I assume you use the boats performance in a conservative manor.
 
I agree - not an issue. I am using Mobil 1 15W-50 Extended Performance and absolutely no issues or problems. The previous owner used Quicksilver 25W-40.

When we bought our 330 DA the mechanic I use who checked out the mechanicals and his boat-builder sidekick and performance engine builder buddy gave me a long list of things that I could do to improve the powerplants. At the top of their list was to change all fluids and use Mobil 1 oil. The engine builder, who is notably the best in the Houston area, stated he seas measurably less wear on engines run on Mobil 1. I was concerned about the switch leading to leaks and both told me not to worry, it wouldn't so long as the engines were sound (and they said they were). After 60 hours, no problems and no used oil. At their recommendation I am using Mobil 1 15W-50 Extended Performance.

All that said, GeeBee is correct, 25W-40 Quicksilver is not a multivis oil, but a blend of two straight-weight oils. Here is a link to Merc's latest recommendation

http://www.mercurymarine.com/serviceandwarranty/mercruiserfaqs/fueloil.php
 
Rotella 15-40 is fine--been using it for years. It's approved for diesel use too.
 
Back
Top