CO gas

Hits real close to home! About 17 slips down the dock in fact. I am at a loss for words. Can't understand why they would run the gen tied up in the slip? No CO detector. Tragic.
 
Probably a portable gas generator as well. It's a shame.
 
Ya gotta wonder if alcohol played any part in this disaster???

Went for a ride late at night, came back to the dock and passed out from being very drunk???

Like Craig said, can't imagine why they would use the genset at the dock unless they forgot to shut it down.

Jonathan
 
I'm with Craig, I'm right behind the boat at the marina, I spoke with the sister Saturday. I've escaped a close call once, I now carry 3 portable detectors plus the built in one.

Mike
 
Why were they running it a dock that has electric....Makes no sense ...

Rob
 
Guys ,
Can u tell me what brand of boat it was??? And if it was a searay its serial #....

Appreciate it

Rob
 
quote:

Originally posted by Robyns Nest

Like Craig said, can't imagine why they would use the genset at the dock





I can give one possible scenario.

The news article said that they were heading home after a father's day celebration and stopped at the boat. So they weren't out on the boat prior.

Perhaps the boat owner (not sure which one it was) did NOT have air conditioning at home. If it was a very hot day they might have decided to stop at the new boat and enjoy its air conditioning and the general coolness around the water.

The article said the boat was new. Perhaps the owner never got around to getting all the proper electrical cords. It is common for the A/C to operate off a separate circuit, requiring a second cord. If the owner didn't have the second cord the easy solution would be to simply run the generator.

I would like to point out that it wasn't necessarily a leak that caused the CO poisoning. If there was no wind to keep the air moving the generator could easily create a CO cloud around the boat, totally engulfing it.

I highly recommend to everyone to have a CO detector on board. Note that it doesn't have to be YOUR generator that poisons you, your neighbors could do it just as easily.

Rod
 
this is not a "brand new boat" as the article and video report says... no way ! looks like 90s boat... if it was new, it woudl have had at least one CO detector, the report said it didn't have any.

Rod is right, it's likely to be the accumulation of trapped CO that caused this, not necessarily a leak. running a genset, or any gas engine, at the dock for longer than absolutely necessary is a bad idea...
 
They probably meant new to the owner... but yes they do say new cabin cruiser ....

Rob
 
they used the words... "brand new" :-) typical accurate reporting !
 
It was a 91ish Searay 310/330. The news also reported that 30 ppm co is a lethal level.That's not consistent with any of the scales that I have seen. I would think it would have to be much higher than that to be lethal overnight. Truly some mysterious and tragic circumstances.
 
I went down to the marina to wash our boat without knowing about this tragedy and when I arrived, the first person I saw to ask what was going on was the boat's owner. His sister and two of her friends decided to stop by the boat on the way home even after they had been warned not to be on the boat without the owner being present. Guess is they did not know how to run the A/C without the genny running - it was a built in genset. He just picked up the boat Sat but the dealer could not locate the cabin key so he could not lock the cabin door. This may have been enough to prevent this tragedy. The "guests" would have been forced to sit out in the fresh air on deck. The boat is an older Sea Ray that was probably built before CO detectors and having the blowers tied into the generator when running where being done as standards. If you have a built in genset, whether the boat came with a CO detector or not, you need to have one. According to the owner, the level of CO was over 300ppm not the 30ppm as reported in the news.
 
Member of a local yacht club lost his wife to CO poisoning on a run in from offshore. She just went into the cabin while the boat was underway and I understand genset was not running. Simply the "station wagon effect."
 
This was a recently purchased boat. Surveys are required for by insurance companies (for insurance) and banks (for financing). The ABYC and the NFPA require CO detectors aboard gasoline powered boats.

Who performed the survey? What recommendations were made to the purchaser (the deceased)?
 
1st priority is to match the generator to the boat's needs and purchase an appropriate unit for the intended use
2nd priority should be to ensure that the genny setup minimizes the probability of CO poisoning.
3nd priority is to monitor the situation to see whether it changes, revert back to #2.
last priority is to have CO monitor for a last ditch save to a bad situation that should have been prevented.

Sorry, but all I ever hear on boatered is about the CO monitor. VERY few are willing to acknowlege the other critical priorties to ensuring safety. I would not trust a CO monitor to save my life.

bp
 
Don't count on just one old monitor either. Minimum of 2 I have 3 the one in the salon closest to the genny has a shut down circuit that kills my genset if it goes in alarm mode. But you can get CO from other sources other than your own genset.
 
That is very sad. I don't trust the built in unit I have on my boat. Now that I have a little one out on the water I have battery operated CO detectors onboard because I am scared of the station wagon effect when he naps below.
 
Back
Top