Coast Guard Question

firstlight

Member
Joined
Mar 25, 2005
RO Number
16749
Messages
222
Passengers seated on the bow of a moving 33ft. vessel. Is it allow at slow speed, no wake zone or totally illegal.
Thanks
 
In NY state they must be in a seat according to the Niagara County Sheriff.
I was stopped for just that.
 
Not a Coast Guard question...depends on state law.

Generally, no legs can hang over the side...ever. Seating on the bow is ok if there are seats engineered into the boat (bowrider, large cruisers, etc). Everything else depends on law enforcement's interpretation of "safe operation of the vessel"
 
The local, state and USCG pretty much let you do what you want here, unless you have body parts hanging over the side, or outside any safety rails. As long as you are in the boat, inside the rails, you are o.k. If you don't have rails, you need to be in the cockpit, inside the gunnels or inside the boat if it is moving.
 
The NY Navigation Law prohibits reckless operation but does not say what that is. Section 45 (1)(a) is the section that covers this. http://www.nyss.com/NYS.html There is no specific mention of bowriding in there that I can see.

However, here is the result of a legal appeal wherein a guy was stopped, ticketed and apparently arrested on Lake George for letting his son bowride. It says he was acquitted at trial, but then he sued the state over the arrest. And the court found his claims meritless and said the officers had good reason to stop him for this obviously dangerous action. http://caselaw.lp.findlaw.com/cgi-bin/getcase.pl?court=2nd&navby=case&no=957462

So good luck figuring all that out. To me it nets out to, you can certainly get a ticket in NY for this, and while spending a lot of time and money to beat it might work out, it's not likely most of us have that time or money, or would want to spend it on that if we did have it.

Just to make it murkier, tidal waters are subject to Town and/or Village laws, so the NY waters where I boat may have a different set of laws on top of the state ones. Who knows what those say (they aren't on the web.)

I do sometimes operate my Pacemaker with one of my daughters on the cabin roof in between a set of rails, below hull speed. And I have had local Bay Constables pass me when that is the case and not give a second look. Which tells me it's subject to a lot of interpretation and no one is going to give you a definitive answer.
 
it's not necessarily stupid... it depends on the boat, the speed and the conditions.

at slow speed on a 30 footer with a sun pad and grab rails on the sides of the sunpad? i dont' see how that's stupid.

at high speed close to the bow of a 25 footer in a 2' chop? probably stupid and likely to be considered reckless.

there is no clear cut answer to this question... use common sense and hope the LEO you run into agree with your definition of common sense.
 
On page 46 of the NYS Boater's Guide, it states " Never allow passengers to ride on the bow, seat backs or gunwales. Riding in these positions may increase the risk of falling overboard. Operators who permit passengers to ride in these locations may be cited for reckless operation, which in New York is a misdemeanor."

Why take a chance. If someone falls off your bow while you are underway, there is a good chance that they will be chopped up somewhat by your props. To me, it is just irresponsible to allow someone to ride up front. There are enough problems in our lives, why create more?

just my .02
 
Awesome memories riding on the bow of my parents boats. Like pascal said slow speeds with proper precautions whats the problem ? When do we install seat belts on boats ? helmets... etc....

Give me a break .... No reason u cant be on the bow in a no wake area....

Rob
 
So is it legal to sit here while underway? It has a seat...

FourWinnsSternSeat.jpg
 
Blouderback, that will get you a ticket in La.
 
The new Sea Ray 310 has a fold out Jump seat on the swim platform like that. The literature states that it is to be used at anchor.
 
I don't need a law to tell me what is safe. I will have people ride on the bow - it is not unsafe until the captain allows it to be that way.

You can't legislate safety, or intelligence for that matter. Some think you can.

The LFO is also human - be reasonable and they will be as well.
 
Bob, I doubt it is legal and I know it is dangerous due to carbon dioxide. Someone could die while riding back there. Don't do it if the engine is running!
 
Yeah, I thought that too. I wonder why they actually put seats back there?
 
Bob, If you have her do the talking it will probably get you out of a ticket I've been led to believe!
 
A few years back there was a big ruckus going on in the San Francisco Bay area when the Coast Guard starting citing sailboats that had crew sitting on the gunwale with their legs over the side.

This is fairly standard practice and something that you will see in most sailboat races. There was such an uproar from the outraged sailors that the Coast Guard backed down, apologized and the cases were dismissed.

That said, it is technically illegal for someone to be riding in a boat with any part of their body outside of the rails/gunwale. Like the sailboat example there are several cases where it is common and the law tends to just ignore. Driving an inflatable while sitting on the tube is a good example.

To be legal riding on the bow there needs to be a suitable rail to keep someone from falling overboard. How you define "suitable" is open for debate. A cruise ship has a deck up at the bow with a suitable railing and passengers can ride up there if they like. My 36' Carver had a stout waist high railing and was suitable for bow riding. The ski boat I had years back didn't have any railing at all and it would not have been legal to ride up on the bow.

Rod
 
Back
Top