Compass deep water accuracy?

Capt. Art

Active member
exMember
Joined
Apr 17, 2007
RO Number
25924
Messages
1,538
Does the accuracy of a Compass degrade the deeper you go?
 
I'll try the straight answer:

Your magnetic compass is unaffected by water depth.

--

Of course, if you are in the process of sinking to the bottom, it may be difficult to read accurately. ;)
 
After about 400 ft, it will be hard to read unless you have more than ambient light available. However, depth of water will have no effect on compass accuracy.
 
Probably Geographically and mathematically there's a difference. How deep you plan to go???:D
 
since water is a conductor it is unlikly there would be much magnetic fiel under water.
 
Once you are on bottom, the water will no longer be a good conductor (since you are now grounded). The compass will be easy to read if you turn on your dash lights. ;-)
 
Wow, I don't mean my boat will be under water:) I was just curious if the compass would be affected on lets say a submarine at very deep depths? I know my GPS or Chartplotters wouldn't work since they wouldn't receive the satellite signals but the magnetic compass may read different at deep depths as it's closer to the Earths Core?
 
Well finally a topic I know something about.. I did about 13 years on subs and one time when I cared to add up the time over 6 yrs actually underwater on sub's. The compass is not affected by water depth just standard deviations that affect everyone from airplanes on down. As you can all imagine using a compass to navigate by is not a very accurate way to do things. we all know using GPS like the rest of the military does requires an antenna above the water and would be useless to a submarine when submerged as they do for months at a time. They use a form of gyroscope spinning very fast if you have ever held a gyroscope you can feel that they resist any motion. the device they use actually measures this resistance to motion as the submarine moves around it. It's actually extremely accurate much more than gps but also very expensive well into the Millions and large about the size of a small car. They also have a few backups running all the time because from time to time they tend to get lost. this is the unclassified version you can find in any good submarine book. In reality the science behind it is very neat.
 
Nice post Joe.
The Compass is aligning itself with those magical lines of Flux extending from one pole to the other.

The compass will always point to north, unless somebody parked a Car right next to your compass.
That Car becomes a 'Deviation' and the lines will swarm around it one way or the other and your compass will point to the greater collection of those distorted lines.
Lay your Pistol up on your dash, behind your Binical and it becomes a Deviation. your Binical will always lead you to your Pistol.

The Closer to the earths core, the more accurate the compass will be. The lines are more concentrated down there.
Assuming there's no Deviation of those lines.
The Higher you go, up in the air, the less the effect will be on your compass. You are getting away from that group of lines.

I forgot to mention the Balls near your compass that function as a counter measure to the Distortion of those Flux lines that the Hull of your Sub or Aircraft Carrier become. That's how a Magnetic compass on a Sub stays on course.

Those Motorized Gyros (Directional Gyros) are used as a quick reference. My flight instructor told me to use it first. After awhile they get a little off course and you have to adjust them, but for hours n' hours of continued use they are normally sufficient for reference. Lot's easier to read than that little thing up above the Cocpit windshield.

A magnetic compass with a Small card, something less than a Foot or so across is a real difficult thing to navigate by.

The closer you get to the Poles of the Earth, the less accurate your Magnetic compass will be, because the lines are so concentrated the Compass has too many similar choices. The needle will wander back and forth, sometimes stopping, but then continuing on, and actually never stopping on any course.
 
Yeah. I once towed a guy 15 miles to a place he could buy some gas.
He'd been following his Pistol in the fog. Thinking he was headed for port.
He still had his pistol at the ready, up on the dash, lodged in place between his compass and thetwo sides of the cabin. He'd need it if he ever caught a big Halibut. He was certainly headed out to where the Big Halibut lay. Somewhere between the mainland and Kodiak Island.
There's lots wrong with stories like that, but they make good object lessons.

As a Boy scout I got off course and waded through a lot of muddy salt flats. That day, that one experience, taught me to know a lot more about navigating with a compass and map.
 
The device used for independant submerged navigation is called a SINS (spacial inertial navigation system - I think). It senses movements and accelerations and would be OK for ordinary navigation for a long time - longer than the normal span beteeen excursions to periscope depth for various reasons for a reset. For fire control purposes they needed to be reset more often. A submarine passing under your boat would very probably not affect your magnetic compass. The ASW types have (had) a device called a MAD (magnetic anomoly detector) which was on a boom on the tail of an aircraft. It would work, sometimes, if the plane was very low and the submarine very shallow. Luck. Dale
 
I'll bet they worked on that SINS a long time before they trusted it.
You know how difficult it is to plot a course across several oceanic movments, and then put a hood on a guy, and make him follow that course you laid out, and see if you ever wind up where the paperwork said you would.

That's gotta be doubly tough in a Sub. It goes up n' down as well as side to side with water Temp. and current variations. Whatta trick that must be, to keep a Sub on a straight n' level course.

GPS has taken care of that problem on the surface.
Everybody's had the experience of proceeding on a nice straight heading, and suddenly found themselves off the the Side of the heading. An Underwater current is moving up over an under water obstacle with enough force to make the water you are floating in, move, taking the boat with it.
A GPS would spot that in a flash and the Needle would point to a course change immediatly.
But in a Sub, I'd need a lotta help in a situation like that.
 
The fact that the poles have changed orientation several times in the Earth's history helped prove the theory of continental drift. The extrusions along the Atlantic Rift Zone show a reversed polarity has occurred several times...north has been south and so on... so yes there is directionality at the ocean floor. Google: "earth's reverse polarity" for more info.
 
your mention of the poles switching reminded me of something I saw recently on one of the channels on tv history (discovery etc). I guess last year (2006) there were globe wide magnetic events. One switched the poles for over 5 min. I guess they have recorded localized events before but this was special because they recorded it across the globe. They said to most of the modern (GPS world) it was not even noticed. It was third world countries that it caused minor issues (navigation etc.) I wonder if the events havent always happened we are just now able to record them.
 
by Switched Poles, are you saying the lines of flux actually reversed and the little arrows (for a short time) pointed down from N to S for awhile and then went back to pointing upwards to N?
That happend recently and nobody noticed?

I went to your Google suggestion and spent a few minutes reading Wikipedia's explanation.
Wow!
I beleive! But I am amazed. I'm glad I'm not a student in a course where I have to know all that and be tested on it.
 
"since water is a conductor it is unlikly there would be much magnetic fiel under water."

The magnetic field is usually not affected by a material's electrical conductivity (I mention, usually, because, in the case of superconductivity, this is not the case). For example iron will very readily support a magnetic field and is quite conductive.
 
Back
Top