coolers

bob t

Member
Joined
Sep 10, 2007
RO Number
28533
Messages
26
any recommendations for a new cooler? have been looking at engel, yeti, icee cool, etc. experiences with any of these or better/
thanks
bob t
 
This question was asked here a few years ago, and the most knowledgeable recommended the 58-qt. Coleman Xtreme... so I bought one and they were right. It will hold ice for several days, no problem.

Edited for price paid: By the way, I paid only $29.95 at BJs Wholesale Club.
 
Igloo has improved their Marine coolers and the new Marine series is called the Igloo "Marine Elite". It is rated at 9 days in 90 degree heat. ---- At least the bigger coolers are 9 days....not sure about the smaller ones. We have the older model 162 quart Igloo Marine (Non-Elite) Marine cooler which is rated for 5 days.
I froze about 2 cases (48 bottles) of drinking water to add to the cooler. Also added pre-chilled (from fridge) beer and sode, as well as two 16 pound bags of ice. After 4 days of highs near 90-92 (nights in low 70s), most of the water bottles had most of their ice still left, and the ones near the bottom were still almost solid ice. It was quite impressive. One of the key things is not to open any cooler very much or very long. Anyway, I was impressed with the cooler, and this is the Igloo non-Elite Marine 5-day. The new Igloo Marine Elite 9-day cooler must be incredible. The Elite series also has stainless hinges and clasps instead of plastic.

You can't go wrong with the 9-day Igloo Marine Elite series. Even the 5-day (non-Elite) Igloo Marine cooler was impressive.

Oh, and one more thing. The Igloo marine coolers have an optional cushion that snaps on top for a seat.
 
I have an Igloo Marine with the seat. I put a block of ice on one side, then fill it up with drinks. Then I put crushed ice all over everything. It is located on the flybridge, covered but also exposed depending on angle. It will keep drinks cold all weekend long and the block is only half gone when I throw it into the lake on Sunday. This is at Lake Mead in Vegas and 115 temps.
 
Without a doubt a Yeti. I bought mine a few months ago and could not be happier.

Do a simple test... Go lift a few of the normal marine cooler (just painted white) and then lift the Yeti. The cooler weights a ton.

The reason why; insulation. Yes they are expensive but you get what you pay for.

The cooler is also approved for dry ice in the event you need to stay out for numerous days.
 
I have a thermoelectric cooler similar to this http://www.compactappliance.com/C18...lt,pd.html?cgid=Outdoor_Living-Travel_Coolers

I keep all of my food items in it and have it down below where it is the coolest. Then I put all my beverages in an ice chest with lots of ice. I hate to have food floating around in water, so avoid that with the cooler. And it doesn't get opened frequently like an ice chest does. I like "yzer"s idea to place a damp white towel over the top to help keep the ice longer.
 
<<..."I hate to have food floating around in water,"....>>

You can avoid the "loose" water by using frozen water bottles. As they melt, the water is still contaied. Also, this serves double duty. You don't need separate ice and drinking water. The melting ice in the bottles becomes the drinking water. Plastic water bottles in your freezer at home won't bust. They have enough expansion room and flexibility. Don't try this with glass or metal cans.
 
We have an Outer Banks, and I adapted an Igloo seat to the top. Works very good, and I many times use the frozen bottle routine.

When I went to work last week there were 20 or so coolers (Igloo) sitting in the warehouse section of the store, and since I had to move them to unload the truck,, someone informed me that Igloo was sending replacement parts for something on the coolers that was not ?holding up. They didn't know what, but many had the new stainless latches, and hinges, that didn't look , to me, very substantial. Just some general info, for if you buy an Igloo, check to be sure it is currrent.
 
We have an ICE Station Zero which is kinda like the "Yeti". One other thing to look for in the better coolers would be the rubber sealing gasket in the lid for a positive seal.
Ours is an 120 quart and we use it as our "ice box" on our dock. I have two water proof containers with lids on top that set inside the cooler and I pack ice all around them and just add ice as needed. The containers allow you to keep food dry and works very much like a convetional ice box, We keep our beverages in a seperate ice chest as people are constantly getting into them for drinks and they don't need to be kept dry.
 
I have an Igloo 72qt cooler with the cushion on top. Was great at first but now after 5 years, does not seem to keep ice as long. Anybody know why that could happen?
 
32carv - check the fitting of your cooler lid... I just replaced an Igloo for the same reason. Ours sat out in the sun and the lid got contorted and didn't fit well anymore.

We replaced ours with an Outer Banks and it appears to be doing really well holding ice. Of course if you fill the cooler with hot drinks, etc. it will melt down the ice until everything gets cool.
 
Coleman extreme's are great. Had a party this weekend in 90 plus degree weather. Still go ice in the cooler 3 days alter adn the beer is at the perfect temperature.
 
Another trick we use is to "pre-cool" the cooler. I start filing the coolers with ice Thursday or Friday (we have a countertop icemaker that pumps out the ice), keep draining off the melt, load them up with supplies on Saturday, then top off with more ice. This tip is brought to you by the instructions provided with the Coleman Extreme series. (who would've thought you would need directions for a cooler...)
 
And prechill everything you put into the cooler. As mentioned before, don't place "room temperature" drinks into the cooler......
 
Even better is to "pre-freeze" whatever you can, such as water bottles, as mentioned before.

Also keep in mind that it is not just the number of pounds of ice you use, but the type of ice. A 20 pound block of ice has a lot less surface area than 20 pounds of ice cubes, so the block will melt much slower. The frozen water bottles make really big "ice cubes" and melt slower than regular ice cubes. For even slower melting, you can also freeze an entire gallon jug of water to make an "ice block". You'll need to put it in the freezer a couple days ahead of time. Like the smaller water bottles, the frozen gallon of water serves double duty as ice and as drinking water as it melts.

Another tip: If you do use ice cubes, don't pour off the melt-water. The icy cold melt-water helps hold the cold. The only time you pour off melt-water is if you are adding more ice and you simply need more room to get the ice to fit.
 
The Coleman extreme has worked very well for us for a couple of years now. Still ice in the cooler at the end of a hot weekend.
We've also used dry ice to keep things frozen. And boy does that work. Ice cream...burgers etc stay frozen solid all weekend.
 
Coleman (I think) had a cooler years ago that was red steel. The walls were very thin by todays standards, but it worked like a chap. The lid had a latch similar to an interior window latch that locked it down tight. That was the best cooler I ever had. It sat in between the seats of my bow rider with a towel on top. Kept ice for a week in 90*+ weather. If you see one like that, go for it. Wish I could find another one.
 
I have three Coleman extreme coolers. We used to use them on our boat and now use them for camping. On a recent camping trip we went 5 days only having to refresh the ice once. Just make sure the lids are tightly shut. Also, I find that the ice lasts longer with the plug open to allow the water to drain. Leaving the melt water in will keep things colder, but letting it drain will keep the ice frozen longer.
 
quote:

Originally posted by KiDa

Coleman had a cooler years ago that was red steel. Kept ice for a week in 90*+ weather.





Many years ago when my husband, kids and I would pile into the jeep to explore the Sierras offroad, we packed up a green Coleman steel cooler as you described. It was rugged and wonderful for keep our food stored safely and bears could not get into it! That thing had hundreds of offroad miles under it......great memories!
 
Back
Top