Core Damage...What does it Mean?

Ranger Man

Member
Joined
Jan 17, 2007
RO Number
24906
Messages
11
Looking for opinions/suggestions.

As though I haven't experienced enough problems already, we recently found water damage to the core of my 2006 Motor Yacht. It seems to be pretty significant along the bow of the boat underneath the salon windshield. This boat was bought new and has been plagued with numerous problems.

With that said, can such damage be repaired without any affect to the value of the boat. I'm concerned that the declaration of such damage and it's repair would scare off a potential buyer.

What affect, if any, would this have on your decision to buy a boat in this condition. What do you guys think. What should I expect.

Ranger Man
 
If its a Searay I wouldn't touch it with a 10 foot pole. Get rid of it, their cored issues are well established.

For other boats, the repair notes/documentation will tell the story as to whether it will be of diminished value post repair. You will need to clearly show the cause of the problem has been identified and corrected. It is not sufficient to merely show that the damaged material has been replaced. It DOES matter what kind of core material we are talking about. Not all core materials are created equal.

For a 2006, I'd walk and get another boat.

I don't personally recall your other problems or the particular boat yoru are dealing with.
 
I hope that it is covered under warranty. Sounds like your windshield was not sealed properly and water is leaking in. If the core is fixed properly and the original problem that caused core to get wet is properly fixed, then I don't think it would have big consequences on resale. A buyer should get a good survey anyway, and if there is nothing else wrong then they will pay market value. If I were you though, I would get it properly fixed under warranty then sell it, that boat is too new to have that kind of problem, plus the other problems you hinted at here.

So where is the thread about your other problems?

Shel
 
that's the problem with coring. in theoryland, it's a benefit and it shoudlnt'get wet but out there in the real world, builders and yards don't properly seal holes, boats get scratched, etc...

if you caught it early and only a small area needs to be repaired, you shoudl be ok. if it's an extensive repair, then you've got a problem. hire a surveyor, get the builder to address the problem if it is not caused by an accident or third party work and document eveything.

what kind of boat is this ? I think you posted about a number of problems with that boat, didn't you ?
 
If I were a buyer and knew of core damage and replacement on a 2006 boat - I would run away from it.
 
Hi PascalG,

I’m back looking for more advice.

Problems continue to persist with my 2006 415 Cruisers Motor Yacht. The most recent problem being the core damage and a continuation of a myriad of past unresolved issues that go back to the day the boat was purchased. The leaks have significantly damaged the interior on the starboard side of the boat. The water stains have left an ugly trail of damage to the cherry wood which, of course, would have to be replaced as well.

In response to Shel’s question…My original thread has been deleted from the Cruisers Forum. Too much stuff to repeat again.

In my last round of concessions with the manufacturer, the leaks and the damaged interior were to be repaired properly. They neglected to do that and now we have significant core damage and further staining to the interior.

What to do…what to expect?

Robert
 
Core damage is serious. Your boat's value has been seriously affected. I cant imagine a maker not taking immediate action to remedy the problem. You need to escalate the issue to the highest corporate levels if you are not getting satisfaction. A written surveyors report from someone experienced with these issues may help.
 
The cause of the core damage was most likely related to the way that the windshield was installed. I suspect the frame was screwed to the deck without proper sealing of the penetrations of perhaps a poor design whereby the area of attachment has coring instead of solid glass. You can go into coring with bolts but the holes should be predrilled, routed out and treated with epoxy or something similar that is allowed to cure prior to attaching fixtures. This problem will show up on a survey and is probably a well known problem to most surveyors who will look for it. It will certainly lower your selling price. You should get expert advice on how the repairs should be made and keep good records and photos so show any buyers' surveyors. Sorry to hear about this issue.
 
What will be required to complete the repair will probably consist of the following:
1 Remove all cabinets, joinery and head linigs in the affected area.
2. Cut oout the inner fiberglass layer over the whole area affecetde by water intrusion and beyound by at least six incehs into good core.
3. Remove all rotten core material and the surounding core until back to good core.
4. Seal and glass over all areas where the water was intruding
5. Install a new core layer where the old material was removed. This will probably require a vacuum bag setup to et the adhesion required.
6. Glass over the new core areas and overlap to the surrounding good glass.
7. Re-install cabinets, fittings and headliner adjusting fit where the repaired area does not have the original profile.
8. Re-install and seal any bolt through fittings such as windscreen, cleats, rails etc.

It may be more cost effective and give a better result with less impact on your resale value for the manufacturer to remove the whole deck moulding and install a new deck fresh from the mold. I would expect the labor to possibly be the same or less for this action and you should get a good as new result.

It may be
 
don't remember why the thread was pulled from the Cruisers section, but i recall you were having many issues with the boat.

you need a surveyor to document how extensive the damage is, that may force Cruisers to do something about. Repairs will be complicated, depending ho how much coring has to be removed and how easy it is to access.

I find it surprising that a manufacturer can't produce a boat that doesn't leak and when it happens doens't take it seriously.

core repairs can be done from inside or outside... inside means a lot of stuff (cabinetry, headliner, ...) being removed but less issue with matching gelcoast and non skid.

you need a surveyor on your side to ensure it's repaired properly. they migh tempted to inject some epoxy in the damaged core, which is ok for a small area, not for a larger area.
 
Just had a friend here that bought a new 52' Cruiser and when it rained his entire windshield leaked. Within 2 days it looked like a pit crew on his boat. Of course the windshield was not the only issue but I just can't believe that a new boat would be in such a condition as to leak around the whole windshield. What happened to QA?
 
Ranger-I know there is no lemon law on boats in most (if not all) states, but you may want to talk to a lawyer. If you make enough noise with the company maybe they will buy the boat back from you. Definitely get a surveyor to your boat asap so you have good documentation of all damage etc. I hope you have kept paper records of all your troubles, courts love documentation.
 
I don't know if this would help but doesn't Boat US have an arbitration system in place for problems like this? You may want to contact them about your problems. Take care. Bill
 
Any boat can be fixed so it is almmost impossiable to see the repair. If this is a limited area just around the windshield, it is not a huge repair. If it involves wet core in the entire deck, then Pascal's suggestion becomes effective. I have known of instances where a partial deck was molded and then the old bad area cut out, and the partial deck installed.

In any case, the manufacturer is responsiable and needs to stand behind the boat until it is totally right. I hadn't seen this thread before. Cored boats are fine, if properly done. Unfortunately many manufacturers take short cuts and don't do the proper type of sealing of core as noted should be above. Any cut into a cored deck or hull, needs have the core routed out, the core replaced with epoxy, and redrilled. Any screw has to have the hole drilled out oversize and then the new hole for the screw drilled into the epoxy. If you have a boat which this is not done on, then do it now!

I recently purchased a 3 year old boat with known damage for half of its value because of cockpit deck core rot. The company paid for the repair, which I supervised and the new core was a material which will not rot, and it was sealed anyway.

We cut up a number of hurricane damaged boats a couple of years ago doing some core research--and the Cruisers was one of the best boats--as far as lamination and intact core.

One other tact which may work is to go to the company's "investor relations" with your complaint. I don't know the history, but would avoid being adversial until you were at the point of legal action.

I went to the Cruiser's forum on Boat Fix and read your posts there. There are several cases that I am aware of with Luhrs--where 41/44 footers are felt to be write off boats. This appears to be due to hull design. There are many quality control problems in many boats, unfortunately. I purcahsed a new boat last year which had multiple problems--it was not as expensive as yours, but I can understand the frustration. I did most of the repairs myself--because the dealer was some distance away and he was not equipt to do the repairs satisfactorilly--The factory co-operated--and they got a good deal because they saved on the labor--but supplied all of the supplies and new parts I needed. Sort of the state of the industry!
 
Back
Top