Cored hulls?

king5899

Active member
exMember
Joined
Nov 22, 2005
RO Number
19628
Messages
1,432
I was reading another thread about cored hulls and water intrusion that got me thinking about which manufacturers are using wood coring below the waterline. I read an article that Maxum is all fiberglass with no coring on the hull, which surprised me, while Larson is balsa cored in the hull. I emailed Regal, but never got a response.

We would like to step up to a 2000 - 2005 32 or 33 foot express cruiser maybe this coming year and was wondering who uses wood coring. If you know what a specific manufacturer uses as a core material, can you post it? I am most interested in the following manufacturers.

Regal 3260
Four Winns 328
Monterey 322
Larson 330
Maxum 3300
Sea Ray 320

Thanks for any input,
MJK
 
I don't believe that any of us has much up-to-date info on this. Seems to me that the easiest way for you to proceed is to contact the manufacturers directly. The big name outfits are usually quite responsive to a question from a potential buyer. Just make sure that you are very clear in the type info you seek.
Good Luck.
 
Trojan International series 10 Meter 33'

No coring below waterline.

Express Cruiser models (not mid cabin) featured a full liner and vacuum bagged construction with 4 hollow stringers - no significant structural wood below the water line except the rear engine room bulkhead.

RWS
 
I wondered the same thing as I would rather stay away from a cored hull as well. I havent come across a website either that deals with this topic specifically.
 
This topic opens up a whole bag of considerations. Most experienced boaters have come to look down on any cored construction below the waterline. Topsides are cored in most production boats (I don't know of any that are not). The material used varies. At one time balsa wood was common. Advances have led to open and closed core materials that are acceptable and enable the builder to construct a light but very strong hull. Good design, experienced workers, production line quality control and good construction materials are the key.

My experience sez you must pay for quality work. And the key to satisfaction in pre-owned boats is tied to surveys and nit-pickin owner's pre-purchase inspections. Before you go to the expense of a survey and enter into any agreements with a seller or broker, get an experienced friend to help you do a close inspection. Seek some friendly but educated help in sorting things out. Don't fall for a fresh polished boat that has warts beneath the surface.
 
with alot of manufacturers that use coring, it depends on model and year. Coring is fine as long as the manufacturer takes the time to do it correctly,ie: "windows" for thru hull, and sealing the top edge of teh hullsides instead of cutting and leaving bare. Also,sealing any porthole and sink/shower/pump discharge cutout.
 
We recently went through the same purchase (2000-2005 32') and I have a pretty good idea. As stated, though, all the mfg's you listed should be very open to providing specs, and it would be a good idea to contact them with any questions to be absolutely sure. I know the ones I contacted were more than willing to help.

I am only considering below the waterline -

Regal - no coring
Four Winns - no coring
Monterey - ??
Larson - ??
Maxum - no coring
Sea Ray - no coring
 
i woudlnt' be so quick to ASSume things... Sea Ray cored a lot of boast below the waterline, at least the larger boats. Make sure your information is accurate before making a decision.

Indeed, as Ram said, IF the manufacturer has done it right, IF the owner(s) and yard(s) have not drilled holes to add transducers for instance (cant' shoot thru a cored hull so it has to be drilled) then cored hulls (below WL) are fine. but those are big IFs, and some "reputable" manufacturers have shown they cant' be trusted to do it right.
 
Just to add some additional points. I wanted to stay away from cored hulls (bottom AND sides) until I ended up owning an older Slickcraft (Tiara). It was not cored on the bottom, but it was cored on the hull sides just above the waterline. To this day, it was the best built boat I have ever owned. The way they cored the sides, the coring was IN ADDITION TO, an already substantial fiberglass layup that could have stood on its own. The final hull side thickness was 7/8" and amazingly strong. The coring added strength and a significant amount of damping (both sound and structural) to the hull. It was the most solid ride I have ever seen. It was also engineered and sealed properly. AND....it was well taken care of by owners/boatyards over its life, which was 30 years when I owned it (and still going strong). What I learned was that coring can be done in a way to add a lot of value, and can last a good long time if engineered properly. But....coring can also be done in such a way that the glasswork would not stand on its own without the coring. The coring is a way to build boats with LESS glass and resin, achieving a designed in amount of strength while also saving weight and more importantly cost. Saving weight is a double edged sword. In some fashion, it can allow a boatbuilder to equip the boat with smaller engines, but still achieve good power/weight ratio's and save the cost of a larger engine footprint. Depending upon the boat, that can be a good thing, but can also produce boats that are so lightweight for their size that sacrifices are seen in both stability as well as the surefooted ability to shoulder their way through a larger sea. In MY opinion of what makes for a good boat, these are the wrong reasons to use coring. "Beancounter" engineering at its worst. Now, I stop short of saying that designing strong panels at a minimum of weight to be a bad thing. In most cases, its a good thing. Especially if you are designing a panel to support a flybridge, where you want a certain amount of design strength at an absolute least amount of weight up high. Coring is a great way to do that.

Anyhow, the short of it is this.

1.) I still would never own a boat cored below the waterline, just too risky.
2.) But...I've grown to not only accept but sometimes prefer a boat cored on the hull sides above the waterline.
3.) I've learned that while cored panels have inherently more risk than non cored panels, done correctly they can easily last the life of the boat, while adding superior value.
4.) Finally, but not least of all, the REASON WHY the manufacturer cored a certain component is of utmost importance. Even if the panel never fails, coring to blindly save weight and cost is not always a good tradeoff, but as of late a strong trend in the industry.

...just my $.02
 
With all of the high tech that is finding it's way into the boating world recently, seems like there should be some new materials and/or processes that could be used for coring that would not have the water absorption issues? It really amazes me that balsa is still even an option anywhere on a boat.
 
it's all about costs! Balsa costs 1/3 of the price of Divinicel (I know there is a Y in there but i never remember where...)... that's a BIG temptation for boat builders.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Nibbs

With all of the high tech that is finding it's way into the boating world recently, seems like there should be some new materials and/or processes that could be used for coring that would not have the water absorption issues? It really amazes me that balsa is still even an option anywhere on a boat.




Balsa is not an issue if done right, matter of fact it’s much better if done right and maintained like anything else high tech. its stronger, lighter etc. than plain laid up Glass.
if it’s thrown together by cheap labor and the owner is clueless about the requirements of such high tech construction then it will fail big time.
 
I know of several large Hatteras boats with rot in the flybridge top deck coring. One guy had to spend a mere 60K to clean out the rotten balsa coring on the top deck, and refill with closed cell foam. Ouch!
 
problem on older hatts is that the flybridge is screwed to the top deck... with so many screws, it's only a matter of time till water gets in the core. $60k though?

the advantage of Balsa, vs foam, is that resin sticks better to the balsa than to foam although now with vacuum bagging and other new techniques, good bonding can be achieved. Still more expensive altogether than balsa.
 
Yep, had to have the whole flybridge deck removed on a 58 yachtfish, the balsa stripped out, and the foam blasted in. Yikes. Job was done right though!

I just looked at a lovely 60 ft+ vessel (not a hat, name removed) where a similar process took place, but, it appeared ice was forming in part of the "redone structure", forcing separation, and icy trails were running down the side of the vessel. Sad, and enough to make the owner cry I'll bet.
 
It's pretty interesting to see the different opinions each has on coring. I think I need to do some more homework as to the individual manufacturers practice of building hulls. So a combination of a quaility manufacturer and a poorly maintained boat can be just as bad or worse as a lower quality manufacturer but an excellently maintained boat. Regardless, I would like to steer away from balsa cored below the waterline just for the mere fact that $hit happens and it would happen to me.

So now if I could only sell my boat this spring.

MJK
 
Grand Banks is coming out with a new line of lighter more fuel efficient hulls that will be a cored hull and using the "resin Infusion" method which is leading edge technology. From what I read it will be a great layup giving high strength and very consistent quality. I don't think they're using balsa. Additionally the deck construction uses a inside pan that makes the engine room a gelcoat finish. Pretty cool.
 
Also King...just because a people may think a manufacturer is a quality one, doesn't make it so.
 
Pascal, not sure if your response was directed at me regarding assumptions and Sea Ray coring, but let me just clarify my response. The RO's original question was regarding a specific span of years, and a relatively small group of manufacturers. My answer was in response to that question only. You are correct, many manufacturers, even Cruisers (who could easily fall into King's list based on the mfg's he's listed), who absolutely swears by coring, has switched back and forth over the years, and any potential buyer is doing themselves an injustice by not doing the appropriate homework for the specific boat they are considering.

RamSport, you've gotten more subtle...you didn't just come out and say that Sea Ray is a piece of crap!!;)
 
Back
Top