Cracked block question

MEfirst

Member
Joined
Apr 25, 2006
RO Number
21005
Messages
331
As some of you may have read, after a few tribulations I sold the boat back in May. I got an email the other day from the new owner saying the block was cracked so now I have some questions.

Let me give you a little background first. The boat was pulled last September and I had the marina change the oil, which happened around early October. The boat then sat in heated indoor storage until I pulled it out at the end of April. The marina dropped the boat in the well, and I took a quick 15 minute spin to make sure everything was working before I loaded it on the trailer. It was then towed to my house where it sat a few weeks until it sold.

The buyer made the sale contingent upon a compression test, a vacuum test, and a sea trial, which the boat all passed. The buyer has said he has only used the boat 3 times when he found the block cracked. It did not crack at the cylinder wall, but is letting cooling water into the oil from what I can gather. My questions are ...

1) The boat was only run 4 times since an oil change and that oil change found no evidence of water, Now, the oil has turned to "milk" per the new owner, is this possible.

2) I didn't do much to winterize the boat except the oil change, stabalize the fuel, and pull the batteries as the marina had touted the benefits of heated storage included not having to winterize the boat. Were they right.

3) The compression test was done by his local marina. Is it possible for them to not notice the cracked block while performing the test.

4) The bill of sale says "As Is". I think I'm covered but the buyer sent me pictures showing rust around where the block had cracked, implying it was a previous condition. If it was a previous condition, which I doubt and even if it had cracked I had absolutely no knowledge of it, does he have any recourse.

Thanks in advance for your answers.
 
Did the buyer have the boat surveyed?? Who did the vaccum test, compressionb test and sea trial. If I had bought your boat I would not be bothering you with my problem, I would be calling the surveyor, or kicking my a$$ for not having the boat surveyed.
 
Tell him you're very sorry, but he had the boat & engine checked over &, as far as you know, it left your ownership in good condition. You have no obligations what-so-ever.
 
As Peter and Steve stated, it HIS problem now. "AS IS" on a bill of sale ends your liability unless you gave him a written warranty.

Ken
 
I feel for you..I sold a boat this summer that had a cracked block and made sure the buyer knew about it.. It was just the water jacket and we had the engine pulled and the crack welded but like everyone, I made sure to put "as is" on the bill of sale. The guy was a diesel mechanic and didn't seem to care a lot, trusting my word that it was professionaly repaired, not JB weld LOL.. Most people ran for the hills when I told them it had a cracked block but was repaired. I don't blame them but we used it all last summer with the welded block and it held fine. The guy who did the work said he'd NEVER had one come back.. Perhaps you can point him in the direction of someone who will weld the block for him to show him you care ? I wouldn't just say "too bad buddy, not my problem".. I'd feel pretty bad about it but I also wouldn't offer him any monetary settlement
 
Without pictures, there's no way to judge the cause of the water intrusion.
 
Pictures

CrackedBlock-SideView.jpg


CrackedBlock-FrontView.jpg
 
Do you feel some compulsion to reply to this person? You see, I would not.

I'd say nothing, nothing at all; especially in writing. If he calls, then you say 'I'm sorry that it happened'. But, I'd say nothing else. Just, sorry it happened.

Given that it was the end of April or during May, whatever happened could have happened as much as when he owned the boat as when you did.

It's a good suggestion being made to you to offer him the name of someone who may be able to help him further.

Unless you feel some obligation to help him monetarily. Then, that's strictly voluntary, and I would not offer it unless he would agree to execute a hold harmless agreement against any action against you, if that is a concern to you at all.
 
I agree with Bill2. If you knew nothing about it when you sold the boat then there is nothing to talk about. On my first boat I found a deteriated hot water tank and a crappy potable water tank after purchase. It was my problem for not doing a better inspection and having a survey, not the sellers.
 
That block is scrap. It can't be welded. It took a hard freeze to crack it at that place. Looks like it has been cracked for a while from the rust on the valley tray holders.

Ken
 
The crack if fresh, as in just happened. You have no obligation legally or morally.
 
quote:

Originally posted by jtybt15

The crack if fresh, as in just happened. You have no obligation legally or morally.




How fresh Charlie, I would say its been a couple of months.
Looking at the time line of the sale, it happeneda after you sold it.

Ken
 
I had a similar situation 4 or 5 yeaars back. I had a deck boat, bought it for a great deal used it a few months, kept on trailer in my driveway. Some guy knocks on my door and wants to buy it for more than I paid. He came with a mechanic and checked out the engine. Deal closed, boat sold "as is". I had no problem with it and wouldn't have sold except he offered more than I paid. 3 weeks later he calls and tells me the block is cracked. I said sorry to hear that. End of story.
 
What's very odd is the location of the crack. Was it fresh water cooled? I wouldn't think water should be anywhere in that area because gravity would cause it to drain from up that high in the block.

Weird.

Doug
 
That big hole in the block IS a water transfer passage.

The crack still shows fresh, raw cast iron. Raw cast iron rusts fast.
 
Its hard to tell from the 2 pictures, but it looks like the top part of the crack happened when the head was removed. Or, the head gasket kept it from rusting right there.

Ken
 
Yeah, I was looking at the crack in the head surface. They meet at the water passage.
 
Thanks for the responses. I knew I'd get a variety of responses as looking at just two pictures can lead to a different conclusions, just not enough info.

It is not like me to turn my back and walk away, even though from everything I see and hear it is not my problem. This buyer is a decent guy, not like the first buyer who backed out of the deal and cancelled his deposit check. If I was in the buyer's shoes, I'd want some answers too. I said I would get back to him today, and I still plan to do that. Any more opinions on the block before I respond would be appreciated.
 
quote:

Originally posted by jtybt15

That big hole in the block IS a water transfer passage.

The crack still shows fresh, raw cast iron. Raw cast iron rusts fast.






Yes, I'm aware it is a water transfer passage but I would think block should drain below that point when the engine is shut off.

No?

Doug
 
Back
Top